WITNESS EVIDENCE Flashcards
There are
two types of evidence:
*Direct—that is, oral evidence of a witness who perceived
the facts; and
*Circumstantial—that is, evidence that does not direct-
ly establish a fact but that allows the court to decide
whether a particular fact existed. This includes opinion
evidence, which is generally the preserve of an expert
witness.
statement by witness
- The general rule is that evidence at trial should be from
witnesses who have provided a signed statement setting out
their evidence. - The statement must have been endorsed with a statement of truth and served on the opponent on time in accordance with the court directions order.
- The witness will
then attend court to give evidence and can be questioned
Effect of Failure to Serve Statement
If the witness statement is not served, a party cannot call that witness to give evidence unless the court gives permission
Competency ofWitness
A witness must be competent to give evidence. A witness is
competent if they can be lawfully called to give evidence (a
person lacking the necessary mental capacity, for example,
would be unable to give evidence).
Service of
Summons
A witness may be com-
pelled to give evidence by serving a witness summons on the witness. The court will issue a witness summons on request of a party and serve the summons on the witness at least seven days before the hearing. The witness is entitled to a sum of
money (known as conduct money) for travel and lost time,
including earnings lost on account of attending the trial.
Use of Statement by Opponent
If a party decides not to call a witness whose statement has been served, the other party can refer to the statement,
which the court will treat as hearsay evidence
FORMAT OFWITNESS STATEMENTS
Statement of Truth
Relationship to Party
EXCHANGE OFWITNESS STATEMENTS
Under the standard directions, the parties must by a certain date exchange witness statements of those witnesses on
whose evidence they intend to rely at trial.
WITNESS SUMMARIES
If it is not possible to obtain a statement before the date for
exchange in the directions order, a party may serve a witness summary. The witness summary should identify the witness
and summarise the factual issues that their evidence will cov-er. It is necessary to obtain permission of the court to serve a witness summary
AFFIDAVITS
- An afdavit is a written statement confrmed by oath or afr-
mation, predominantly for use as evidence in court. - The diference
between an afdavit and a normal witness statement is that,
whilst a witness statement contains a statement of truth, an
afdavit must be ‘sworn’, normally before a solicitor who will
endorse to say that the maker had sworn before them that
the contents were true. - In most cases, a witness statement
will sufce, but certain types of application or process require an afdavit to support, for example, applications for freezing
injunctions or search orders must be supported by afdavit.
HEARSAY EVIDENCE
Hearsay evidence is “a statement made otherwise than by
a person while giving oral evidence in proceedings which
is tendered as evidence of matters stated”. In other words,
statements made outside of court.
Hearsay evidence can be oral or in writing, but for evidence to be hearsay:
*It must have been made out of court; and
*Its purpose must be to prove the truth of what is being
stated.
It is important to appreciate that all witness statements are, at the point the witness signs the statement, hearsay. However,
if, as is generally the case, the witness comes to court to give evidence, their witness statement (plus their answers to the
other side’s cross-examination) is treated as if they had spo-
ken it in court and hence ceases to be hearsay. The position
is, however, diferent if the witness is unable to attend court.
evidence in chief
- The claimant’s witnesses will give their evidence frst. Each
witness will take the stand and frst swear an oath or afrma-
tion that their evidence is true. They will then be asked by the solicitor or barrister representing the claimant to confrm that
it is their signature on the witness statement and that their
statement is correct. Assuming they say yes, the statement
will then stand as their evidence and cease to be hearsay.
This is technically known as their evidence in chief. - Exam Tip
Be clear as to the diference between evidence in chief
and evidence given in cross-examination. Evidence
in chief is actively presented by the party, whereas
cross-examination occurs when the party asks his oppo-
nent’s witnesses questions.
Evidence ofWitnesses Who Do Not Attend Court
- If a witness is unable to attend but a party wishes the court
to consider the signed statement of the witness at the trial, the court will treat this as hearsay evidence. A judge will not place as much weight on hearsay evidence. - In making their judgment, the trial judge will indicate the
weight that they have attached to any hearsay evidence.
Process for Relying on Hearsay Evidence
- A party wishing to rely on hearsay evidence must serve a
notice on their opponent.
2.A party served with a hearsay notice may seek to call the wit-ness at trial (if the witness’s whereabouts are known) or seek
to attack the witness’s credibility at trial. To do so, the party
must act within 14 days of receiving the hearsay notice (that
is, make an application to call the witness to court for the trial within 14 days of receiving the hearsay notice or, within 14
days of receiving the hearsay notice, serve a notice of intent
to attack the credibility of the hearsay by establishing that the witness is biased, untrustworthy, or unreliable).
.