Wind, wave and tidal power - lecture 8 Flashcards

1
Q

Wind and marine energy in the UK (DECC, 2011) UK renewable energy road map- renewable energy review

A
  • onshore wind- capacity in 2010 (GW)= 4 , projected capacity in 2020 (GW) = 13
  • offshore wind- capacity in 2010 (GW)= 1.3, projected capacity in 2020 (GW) =18
  • wave capacity in 2010 (GW)= 0.002 projected capacity in 2020 (GW) =0.15
  • tidal capacity in 2010 (GW)=0 projected capacity in 2020 (GW) =0
  • tidal stream capacity in 2010 (GW)=0.002 projected capacity in 2020 (GW) = 0.15

technical resource = amount we think we could technically exploit using current technology. For example, offshore wind has a high potential with 400 TWh/yr

  • big difference between wind and how solar will be exploited.
  • what actually happened, 2016 data onshore has currently just under 10GW & offshore grown just over 5GW and if you add wave (tidal range capacity) + tidal stream together its capacity is less than 0.01 GW so seen a decline in sector.
  • UK 50% of tidal range capacity across Europe but not exploited eg. due to cost
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

Projected levelised cost ranges for electricity technologies in 2020

A
  • off shore wind reasonably competitive but once we get to marine technology, they become much more expensive.
  • one technology that can compete with combined cycle glass turbine (CCGT) is onshore wind
  • look at diagram
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

Case study: Scottish and Southern Energy’s Clyde windfarm

A
  • South Lankarkshire
  • 350 MW windfarm
  • Europe’s biggest single contested onshore windfarm will compromise 152 windturbines
  • provide enough power for 270,000 homes
  • investment of £500 million
  • more than 200 construction jobs provided
  • 30 running staff are employed
  • largest capacity of onshore wind, in 2015 wind turbines generated just under 12% of UK’s electricity, so fastest expanding and renewable technology.
  • economics is one reason for this
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

Why wind power has become so widespread& invested in:

A

1) economically competitive
2) wind turbines are a scalable technology so can be delivered at different scales so can be used for properties (local levels) or can be connected to the grid.
- so barriers of investment comes down, can fit to particular places and can’t fit inline with investment
- easy to maintain
3) low-carbon - LCA between factor of 40-80 scaling in terms of carbon that goes into production, saving you, get over lifetime between 40-80
4) know technology been around for a long period of time.

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

valley and mountain breezes

A

land heats& cools more rapidly so land is warmer than sea during the day, warming effect, heat rises get circulation, onshore breeze and opposite happens at night time and you get mountain systems whereas air warms up early in day, start to get warm air thermals rising , cold air deposited into the valley bottoms and opposite effect as mountain cool in the evening, then get cold air dropping down into valley bottoms along the sides.

  • all systems mean wind energy as a resource looks different in different places
  • get much more assurity in a coastal location, hence the drive for offshore rather than lowland onshore locations.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Map for onshore wind ( Boyle, 2004)

A
  • UK is well situated for wind density
  • particularly the North is high but there is a variation in wind density - much higher winds at sea coast > out to open sea and on the top of hills and ridges than you would have in sheltered terrain.
  • so onshore wind farms have to be in exposed places , so areas of high terrain are best but visibility issues + problems of landscape impacts.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

Wind farms

A
  • used for a long time- old technology
  • have horizontal access turbine (access horizontal and turbine spinning around it).
  • propellers spin, intercept power and convert motion of propellers into electricity.
  • 120m on land
  • also have vertical access turbines called ‘darrieus’ turbines after the inventor- they are more closed,more turbines you get, more wind you can intercept as its hitting more of the blades of the turbine.
  • ‘darrieus’ turbines spin om the vertical access to drive turbine.
  • Restricted as cab only go up to certain size, if it can be scaled up = high demand for offshore environments where high windbut potential for stress of propellers
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

Power of the wind

A

P= 0.5 . P. A . V3

- look at powerpoint

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

Power you get from turbines

A
  • look at diagram
  • all wind turbines have a ‘cut- in speed’ only start generating at a certain point eg. turbines are idyll on slightly less windy days
  • rapid increase in the amount of power you can drive into a turbine as wind speed pics up
  • turbines are designed to be less efficient at high wind speeds to prevent damage from storms.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Power you get from turbines

A
  • look at diagram
  • all wind turbines have a ‘cut- in speed’ only start generating at a certain point eg. turbines are stagnant on less wind days
  • rapid increase in amount of power you can drive into turbine as wind speed picks up
  • turbines are designed to be less efficient at high wind speeds to prevent damage from storms.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

Environmental impacts of wind turbines

A
  • noise pollution - despite technology improving for a home that is 300m away from turbine, the noise is about 40 decibels (fairly busy road in city you can expect around 60).
  • visual impact in urban locations
  • birds flying into them
    concerns about sensitivity to vibrations
  • lewis case study - land drainage & ecosystem change set up in peatland areas so many systems drainage impacts ecology
  • electro magnetic interference if you have them near a TV or radar can have impacts, reflects off turbines so interfering signals
  • radar is a big concern for military
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

Bird fatalities

A
  • look at tables
  • issue around birds focuses on highly protected species so Lewis example, local population of golden eagles
  • bird strike ( fairly rare) - study in Denmark, set up turbines offshore within migratory patterns of birds to access bird strike and found it wasn’t a major concern.
  • the birds tended to avoid the turbines
  • there are some turbines that have systems to detect large flocks of birds so can turn off turbines and protect bird species.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

Position on wind power in IEA Wind Member countries 2012

A
  • look at table
  • for large systems, wind power is making sizeable contributions
  • China & USA have massive energy demands, 5% coming from wind
  • In Denmark at extremes its 40%
  • Ireland get 24% from wind
  • Portugal gets 22% - several countries getting around 20% from wind
  • good choice as we try to de-carbonise
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

La Rance tidal power plant

A
  • In France
  • 240 mw
  • installed late 60’s early 70’s
  • harvesting variability in water heights between low and high tides
  • barrage, sites across estuary, water gets trapped, release it and drive turbines.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

Spring Tides and Neap Tides- look at diagram

A
  • primarily driven not by sun (does contribute) but by the moon and gravitational pull/ force of moon
  • so when moon is sitting next to earth, it will have a gravitational pull that distorts the surface of the water and causes a high tide.
  • can look at juxtaposition of sun& moon and identify that when they are acting together as sun also has a gravitational force, when they’re inline with eachother, get a spring tide (particularly high tide).
  • when they’re set against eachother at 90oc get a neap tide (low tide) & cycle of tide goes through every 14 days get a spring tide or a neap tide in line of passage of moon.
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Tidal range

A
  • sitting in the middle of the ocean (alantic) tidal range the difference is only 1/2 a meter but as tide comes across Atlantic, it starts to enter shallower water and you start to get an amplification so by the time it hits UK coasts average tidal range is about 3m
  • as well as a general amplification , we also get turning by landscape features& 7 estuary is best example in UK & best site for tidal range power in the whole world as the tide moves through & into estuary it gets amplified up & so by the time it hits to of 7 estuary have a tidal range of about 12m (wall of water mounts up at end of estuary).
  • commercially to get £ differences between high & low tide should be 5m.
17
Q

What is tidal range?

A

difference between high and low tide

18
Q

How to tap off energy from this source

A
  • look at diagram
  • most common way to tap off energy is to tap off barrage
  • gates open as tides come in, at point of high tide you close them & trap water behind barrage, wait for tide to go out creating a difference in height between high body & low body water (gives pressure)
  • release water, all potential energy turns into kinetic energy, rapidly moving the water, moves turbines to generate electricity.
19
Q

Mean spring tidal range in UK Estuaries

A
  • spring tidal ranges in UK need 5m for it to be commercially viable tidal system feeding electricity grid
    (particularly around Bristol and Kent.
20
Q

UK Tidal range resources

A
  • look at table
  • Severn can provide 7-10% of energy requirements for UK.
  • can get large amounts of potential from the Humber region with a mean tidal range of 4.1 and a predicted annual energy output of 1,650 GWh
  • 50% of all tidal range capacity in Europe is sitting in the UK, yet our utilisation of that range is 0 at the moment
21
Q

Power generation for different tidal range schemes

A

look at diagram!!!!!!!!

  • can generate on low-tide, hold back tide and release through barrage
  • also systems that try to generate in both directions better as you get more even electricity generation but loose lots of efficiency out of system eg. La Rance
  • tides that occur twice a day, trap tides when you open gates+ allow turbine to run, water flows out and level decreases.

2 implications;

1) COMPLETELY CHANGE HYDROLOGY of estuary so 7 estuary 150 squared km of mudflaps would be permanently lost and is inundated with water the whole time.
2) PERIODS- get electricity for 2 big periods of the day for 4-6 hours depending on the system

22
Q

Severn Estuary with possible double-basin schemes (Boyle, 2004)

A
  • v good part of tidal is tidal range is extremely predicatable, know when there will be both high and low tides, spring& neap
  • so can predict how much electricity you can get at any given time
  • looked at a double- basin system for 7 system , split bit behind barrage into 2 and allow one to generate at 1 time, hold back water and use the other to generate at another time.
  • if you have excess electricity at dam at certain point you can have a lagune in middle of estuary& pump water behind lagune with excess electricity & let it out when u need it so use the system as pump& storage.So can use these systems to back up indeterminacy of wind systems.
23
Q

Environmental impact of tidal energy

A
  • mudflaps
  • disruptions of birds
  • sedimentation ( can be good or bad)
  • migratory fish eg. salmon or eal (big part of EIA for 7 estuary)
  • shipping activity (commercial disrupted)
  • whole system modified a lot
  • communication improved creating dam provides opportunity to have a road across it or a rail with it.
24
Q

Why has tidal not taken off?

A
  • hard to put into system as its intermittent
  • very expensive, cost for the 7 estuary were in the excess of 30 billion
  • ecological impacts
25
Q

Severn barrage: 2010 feasibility study

A
  • SEA
  • Up to 5% of UK electricity
  • Capital cost up to £34 billion- pay back to get economic return was more than 20 years
  • High-risk, high cost compared to other low carbon
  • “Unprecedented” impacts in an environmentally designated area
  • Loss of mudflats, changes in water level and tidal characteristics
  • Economic boost for area, infrastructure, flooding
  • carbon pay back costs of putting it back are about 3 years
  • main reasons we don’t have tidal in UK, depsite all our resources is that its v difficult to invest, overtime sclaes with that amount of money also ecological impacts come in - & estuary were environmental concerns.
26
Q

Swansea Bay tidal lagoon

A
  • lagoons differ from barrages in that they create a small basin of water, act in the same way
  • high tide traps water inside lagoon and releases at low tide to drive the turbines BUT rather than going across estuary, you would build it out from shoreline and just take part of estuary so in theory ecological impacts= smaller, total investment is £1.3bn
  • in principle lagoon development approved by gov
  • would be a pilot for demonstrating how they could work
  • creates a tourist feature& visiting center so in 10 years may have sorted tidal exploration.
27
Q

Tidal stream energy

A
  • using the fact that tides move
  • tides come across alantic when it hits the UK, it splits, one bit goes to North through Scotland, one South through the channel & water is flowing around UK & we can tap into that flow so put large turbines on the floor the sea, 6GW near Scotland.
  • more attractive system as way of harvesting power of tides as less of a visual impact, less ecological impact (fish tend to avoid and turbines spin slowly)- would take off as its scale-able can go from turbine too a set of 2,000 generating electricity so barriers to investment come down.
28
Q

Double basins

A

double basins are a solution to the problem of indeterminacy on tidal range also if you were very serious about tidal range would need connections as they generate at different times eg. waves at cornwall to kent are 6 hours apart, so tune them so they all connect.

29
Q

hydraulic rams

A
  • as waves hit, it rotates back and forwards driving hydraulic rams, which generate electricity.
  • one problem with wave power, why its so difficult to exploit is that wave power is lost as it hits the shore, closer to shoreline it is, it loses 60% of energy waves.
  • so ideal if you have a deep platform so you can exploit wave power but requires an anchor
  • difficult to use this technology as its out at sea so systems have to be designed to generate electricity but to withstand storm and corrosive nature of sea & distribute to national grid.
30
Q

Environmental impacts of wave energy

A
  • almost none
  • out of all technology has the least environmental impacts but will take some energy from waves
  • no impact on ecology eg. fish
  • only 30% efficient never covers a whole shoreline with wave systems but impacts almost none.
31
Q

Wind and marine energy in the UK

A
  • we have a great abundance of resources but havent invested because of factors such as economic, scalibilty etc
  • see almost no development & requirements for renewables is ahead of wave power, is some research is going into it but it will be micro-scale eg. Scottish islands may be able to use wave power
  • tidal range won’t be the way, national level decided not to go with 7 barriage BUT over next 10/20 years tidal stream will be developed, UK well resourced in terms of that & low impacts + more permanent that tidal range.
  • UK leading nation for offshore wind- total capacity is around 14/15GW globally of that 5GW in uk, 4GW in Germany and 2 in Denmarl
32
Q

Wind and marine energy in the UK

A
  • we have a great abundance of resources but havent invested because of factors such as economic, scalibilty etc
  • see almost no development & requirements for renewables is ahead of wave power, is some research is going into it but it will be micro-scale eg. Scottish islands may be able to use wave power
  • tidal range won’t be the way, national level decided not to go with 7 barriage BUT over next 10/20 years tidal stream will be developed, UK well resourced in terms of that & low impacts + more permanent that tidal range.
  • UK leading nation for offshore wind- total capacity is around 14/15GW globally of that 5GW in uk, 4GW in Germany and 2 in Denmark