Wills Flashcards
Will Formation Requirements
1) Testamentary Intent
2) Testamentary Capacity
3) The will must comply with the state’s Wills Act Formalities
Will Formation Requirement (1) Testamentary intent: What is it?
- An intention for the document to take effect after death.
- Did the testator believe the document would be their will?
Will Formation Requirement (2) Testamentary Capacity: What is it?
- 18 years old or older
- Of sound mind
Will Formation Requirement (3) Comply with the Wills Act Formalities: What is it?
- In a writing
- Signed by Testator
- Witnesses present (usually sign as well)
What are the 4 justifications of formalities?
1) Ritual
2) Evidentiary
3) Protective
4) Channeling
Ritual Justification: Why?
Ceremony shoes the weight and significance of the will.
Evidentiary Justification: Why?
A will provides evidence that you meant to do something.
Protective Justification: Why?
- If done properly, a will ensures someone is not easily taken advantage of.
Channeling Justification: Why?
- If all wills look alike, it makes it easier for courts to determine if wills are valid. (Same reason all checks look the same).
2 Occasional formalities in making a will:
- Publication Requirement: Testator must state that this will is their will.
- Subscription Requirement: Signature of the Testator must be at the VERY END of the WILL. (Best practice)
Presence: Line of Sight Test (Traditional)
Witness must be in a position that if they wanted to look at the will they could.
Presence: Conscious Presence Test (Modern)
Sight, hearing, general consciousness…The witness must know the testator is signing the will.
What is strict compliance with the Wills Act Formalities?
- Smallest error will put the estate out of probate, even with no evidence of fraud or lack of capacity.
- Enforcement is easy.
Covid and the Wills Act Formalities
Zoom/Remote was okay during Covid but not so much anymore.
Can different languages be used in Wills and still comply with the formalities?
-Yes, but it requires getting extra translators.
Will Formality: Signature: What does it establish (2 things)
1) Finality (signature authenticates document)
2) Genuineness
Will Formality: Signature: What works as a signature?
1) Any mark
2) In a writing
3) That the testator intended to be an authenticator.
(Preferably placed at the end of the will)
(An “X” could work no problem)
(Other people are allowed to sign for testator depending on jurisdiction)
Will Formality: What is Subscription?
- The signing of the will at the end of the will by the testator.
Will Formality: What if Subscription in wrong spot?
A court could deny probate if the will is signed in the wrong spot.
Will Formality: Writings
-Physical medium that allows marks.
-CDs, audios, videos don’t work.
- this protects rituals, protects form fraud and encourages use of a lawyer.
(THIS IS TYPICALLY NOT DEFINED IN STATUTE)
Will Formality: Witnesses: What if a will is contested?
Most witnesses will need to be called to testify if the will is contested.
Will Formality: Witnesses: What if witnesses die or lose mental capacity?
Prove Up the will: have to find the individuals to verify the witness’s signature.
Will Formality: What is an Attestation clause?
Boiler-Plate language placed after the testator’s signature and before witness signatures.
Will Formality: What is a self proving affidavit?
Separate document from the will attached to the back of the will.
Executed in front of a notary with a statement from the witnesses that the will was executed properly.
(This replaces sworn testimony of the witnesses.
Best practice for self-proving affidavit and attestation clause?
A good attorney should include both.
Will Formality: Witnesses: What should witnesses be?
Witness should be:
1) Competent
2) Of Age
3) A Disinterested Party
Will Formality: Witnesses: What happens if there is an interested witness under common law?
An interested witness would cause a full strike of the will.
Will Formality: Witnesses: What happens if there is an interested witness under modern law? 1st and 2nd Gen:
1st Gen Purging Statute: Complete purge, strikes out anything the witnesses was supposed to get.
2nd Gen Purging Statute: Partial Purge, purge to the extent it exceeds what would be taken in intestacy. (purged gift falls to residue, if no residue then intestacy).
Will Formality: Witnesses: What happens if there is an interested witness under UPC?
UPC says let the witnesses take, but it could be evidence of fraud or undue influence.
Will Formality: Witnesses: Can a lawyer be a witness?
Yes, lawyers can be witnesses.
Will Formality: Witnesses: What if a spouse is a witness?
Spouse should not be a witness because they are an interested party.
Will Formality: Witnesses: Can there be an interested witness at all?
No, ensure any potentially interested witnesses don’t take under the will.
Will Formality: Execution Ceremony: 2 things to do
1) Make a will good in any jurisdiction.
2) The amount of procedure is based off of how likely you believe the will might be contested.
Will Formality: Execution Ceremony: General things to do (best practice)
- Print out will with numbered pages and secured by 1 single staple.
- Get at least 2 disinterested witnesses.
- Bring everyone involved in the ceremony into the room (NO FAMILY)
- Clean table (with line of sight/conscious presence)
- Have testator sign.
- Testator asks witnesses to sign.
- Attestation clause read aloud.
- Witnesses sign.
- Will is valid.
- Then do the self proving affidavit (witnesses sign and notary notarizes).
Will Formality: Execution Ceremony: Who holds onto the validly executed will?
- Lawyer, in a lockbox or filed with the state.
Will Formality: Execution Ceremony: 2 Ways to handle a will mistake?
1) Substantial Compliance
2) Dispensing Power (Harmless Error) (UPC-503)
Will Formality: Execution Ceremony: How to fix a will mistake: Substantial Compliance
- Overlook formal defects if:
-The document expresses the decedent’s testamentary intent.
-It’s form sufficiently approximated the statutory formality and enable a court to conclude that the document serves the purposes of the Wills Act.
Will Formality: Execution Ceremony: How to fix a will mistake: Dispensing Power (Harmless Error) (UPC)
- Dispenses will formalities when there is a clear and convincing evidence that the testator intended their document to be their valid will.
- Strong evidence is handwritten notes with attorney testimony.
Will Formality: Do any states just use a notary?
Some do. Notaries meet all function of a will formality. Also, people hold notaries in high regard of formality so it meets testamentary function.
Will Formality: Fixing a will: (4) Issues with dispensing power
1) Do we know what clear and convincing evidence is?
2) How easy is it to determine testamentary intent?
3) People will care less about formalities.
4) More litigation.
Holographic Wills: How many jurisdictions recognize?
About half.
Holographic Wills: What is it?
A handwritten and signed will.
(slightly ritualistic, sort of evidentiary, not protective, does not serve channeling function).
Holographic Wills: Why have them?
- More people can have wills.
-Private
-Good for emergencies.
Holographic Wills: Worries
Deception (failing protective function), knowledge of regular people (failed evidentiary function), what really is a will what happens if what they make does not look like a will)
Holographic Wills: How does signature work?
- At the end is best, but a handwritten name at the top of the holograph has been held as a signature.
Holographic Wills: Can a lawyer handwritten will be a holograph?
Absolutely not.
Conditional Will: What is it?
Written as if the will becomes operative if death arises from a specific event or time frame.
Conditional Will: What do courts do?
- Ignore the conditional language.
- Uphold the rest because of clear intent.
- A specific enough event may be overcame.
Holographic Wills: 3 ways to handle preprinted Will forms?
1st Gen: Needs to be entirely handwritten and signed.
2nd Gen: (UPC “Material Provisions”): Important stiff must be handwritten like signature and material provisions.
3rd Gen: (Material Portions) All important stuff handwritten, the portions that show intent may be printed.
Holographic Wills: Preprinted Will forms what does AR use?
2nd Gen
3rd Gen
Will Revocation: How
1) intent to do so
2) Have capacity
3) Act or Affirmative Step
Will Revocation: Act or Affirmative Step: 2 things?
A) Physical act (tearing up a will)
B) Through a subsequent writing that meets the Wills Act formalities. (explicitly with a clause in a new will or through implication).
Will Revocation: What about partial revocation?
Partial revocation by physical act is recognized in most jurisdictions.
Will Revocation: Is Harmless error recognized by the UPC?
NO
Will Revocation: Harmless Error Requirements:
1) Intent
2) Affirmative Act (to s subsequent writing)
Will Revocation: Codicil: What is it?
- Subsequent Writing
- An amendment to an earlier will.
Will Revocation: Codicil: What about a holograph and a will together?
- A holograph and formal will won’t supersede each other but will work together.
Will Revocation: Codicil: 4 general rules
- Revoking a codicil does not revoke a will.
- If you revoke a will, the codicil for it is also revoked.
- If you revoke a will, you must perform the formalities to get it back.
- Revoking just one duplicate of a will revokes them all.
Will Revocation: Physical Act: What is it?
- Doing something to deface or destroy a will.
- Must be done by the testator or at their discretion.
- (If done with discretion it must be done in testator’s presence).
Will Revocation: Physical Act: UPC stance?
- UPC does not care if the physical act “touches the words” of the will for revocation.
Will Provisions: What if provisions conflict?
- The provision made closer to the time of death controls.
- This shows their intent.
- If the will is not completely replaced then the provision is just a codicil.
Will Revocation: Intent: What is the presumption?
If a will remains with a testator until death and is found mutilated, the court will rule the will was revoked.
Will Revocation: Intent: What if we can’t find the will?
If we know the testator had the will but can’t find it now, then the will is presumed to be destroyed.
Will Revocation: Intent: What if someone claims someone other than the testator destroyed the will?
If it is disputed the will is missing or destroyed by someone other than the testator there must either be clear and convincing evidence or preponderance of the evidence based off jurisdiction.
Will Revocation: Intent: What if the will is missing without testator fault?
There must be clear and convincing evidence of the will’s contents.
Will Revocation: Dependent Relevant Revocation (DRR): What is it?
-Testator gets 2nd best option.
- If you knew there was an issue with the 2nd WIll you would not have revoked the 1st.
- So pretend the revocation of the 1st will did not happen.
Will Revocation: Dependent Relevant Revocation (DRR): Rules
1) A valid will that is revoked as plan to get a new will.
2) A mistake of law or fact in the new will is present.
- MAJ: Shown in the will itself.
- MIN: Shown through extrinsic evidence.
3) DRR may be closer to what decedent wants compared to intestacy.
Will Revocation: Revival: Generally
- In general, revocation of a later will does not revive the older will.
- In states with revival, court can revive the will if the testator destroys 2nd will with the intent to revive the first will.
- NOT IN AR
Will Revocation: Revocation by Operation of Law: What is it?
- Revocation by divorce.
Will Revocation: Revocation by Operation of Law: What happens?
- Will remains, but
-Divorce instantly revokes any provisions in testator’s will that leave property to ex-spouse. (ex is treated as predeceasing the testator).
Will Revocation: Revocation by Operation of Law: What happens in AR?
- In AR there needs to be a final divorce decree.
Will Revocation: Revocation by Operation of Law: What are some issues?
- Does not auto revoke insurance, UPC cuts out relatives of spouse automatically.
Will Revocation: What happens when you get married or have child?
- A will is not automatically revoked if you get married or have a child.
Will Revocation: Revocation by Operation of Law: UPC
- UPC revoked gifts to relatives of ex upon divorce.
- UPC also prevents exes from taking non-probated assets.