Week 9: Species, Speciation and Extinction Flashcards
How many species are there?
2 million species described - estimate 5-10 million
Describe mosquito speciation in underground London
Culex pipiens - above and underground - morphologically similar but behaviourally different in feeding and breeding patterns - no gene flow in nature - in lab - hybrid cross produced no viable offspring.
What is the species problem?
1) how to define a species 2) how to identify species in nature and delineate boundaries between them?
What are the 5 main species concepts?
evolutionary, phenetic, biological, ecological, phylogenetic.
Describe evolutionary species concept
a lineage of populations which maintains its identity from other lineages and which has its own evolutionary tendencies and historical fate.
Describe phenetic species concept
delineates species based on phenotypic similarity. Pros - can be used on extinct species (using fossils), can use genetic data in similar way. Cons - doesnt include evolutionary history (traits could be same due to convergent evo and not due to shared evolutionary history), fails when within-species variation is high or between-species variation is low.
Describe biological species concept
delineates species based on reproductive isolation. Species are groups of actually or potentially interbreeding populations which are reproductively isolated from other such groups. If two individuals breed and produce fertile offspring - they are same species. identifies mechanism of speciation to be patterns of gene flow. Cons - extinct species, asexual species, hybridization events.
Describe ecological species concept
delineates species based on niche. Individuals of same species compete most closely with each other. Evolution is underlying mechanism (need to get away from competitor - evolve new niche). Pro - can be used for asexual species - possibly for extinct species. Con - doesnt work well on species with different morphs.
Describe phylogenetic species concept
based on shared evolutionary history - members of species share common evo history and common fate - distinct from other species. The smallest monophyletic group distinguished by a shared derived character. Puts a scale on species delineation - all mammals have fur and mammary glands but mammals are not all same species. Cannot use polymorphic traits - wont form a clade (ie. flower colour), can use shared derived traits (by definition). Concept may delineate too finely based on shared derived traits.
Describe Cattail case study
Broad-leaf (Native), Narrow-leaf (non-native), hybrid cattail (hybrid).
Biological SC - F1 hybrids readily formed, hybrids are fertile but it is reduced compared to parents. Once formed, hybrid has greater clonal growth than parents
Phenetic SC - They do delineate based on morphology of leaf width - also height, gap, spike width and spike length.
Ecological SC - share niche based on water depth
Phylogenetic SC - T. latifolia is monophyletic, T. angustifolia is paraphyletic or polyphyletic
Why do species concepts matter?
Why species concepts matter - use taxonomy to make conservation decisions, one of first criteria for COSEWIC is “is it taxonomically valid”, for eastern wolves, it is a public opinion, currently Canis Lycaon cf. - cf means things are complicated
What are modes of speciation based on?
Biological species concept - reproductive isolation; caused by genetic divergence
What are the 3 modes of speciation?
- Allopatric - speciation in different places - geographically isolated
- Parapatric - speciation in populations adjacent to each other
- Sympatric - speciation in same place.
What is the vicariance model of allopatric speciation?
one very large pop subdivided into two large populations. Drift unlikely due to large size of subpopulations - different selective pressures.
What is the peripheral isolate model of allopatric speciation?
division of populations that are diff sizes - one large and 1+ small. Founder effects and drift occur in small subpops - still different selective pressures.
What is an example of allopatric speciation?
Example: Vicariance in Alpheus shrimp - Isthmus of panama creates physical barrier between seas. Species from opposite sides formed sister species. Mating yielded 1% viable offspring between sister species vs. 60% within sister species.
What is parapatric speciation?
Speciation in absence of geographic barrier. Diverging populations form a cline - spatial gradient the frequency of phenotypes or genotypes. Different selective pressures along the cline. Gene flow between diverging populations results in hybrid zone. Hybrids usually selected against - not well suited to live anywhere on cline.
What is an example of parapatric speciation?
hybrid zone in sweet vernal grass - grows on mine - soil contaminated with lead and zinc - grows on adjacent pasture where soil is not contaminated. Some gene flow between pasture and mine - interpopulation hybrids - not much. Pasture plants outcross more, flower earlier. Mine plants highly selfing. Differences in reproductive traits greatest closest to pasture-mine boundary.