week 9 Flashcards
What does natural selection require?
- There is variation amongst individuals
- Some of that variation is heritable
- Variation effects survival and reproduction
What is an adaptation?
a trait currently favoured by natural selection, and previously shaped by natural selection. traits that allow individuals to leave more offspring than individuals without that trait
What other forces affect evolution of traits? do they lead to adaptation?
- other forces affect the evolution of traits (e.g. genetic drift, allele frequencies change upon chance which affects the traits)
- but only natural selection leads to adaptation
Adaptive vs Maladaptive
Adaptive: A trait that enhances fitness
Maladaptive: A trait that reduces fitness
What is adaptionist program and what are the dangers of uncritical adaptionist program?
- create and test hypotheses based on these questions
- adaptive story telling = providing a plausible story for the adaptive significance of a trait without demonstrating adaptation.
What is exaptation? Give an example.
when a trait evolves for one purpose but is later co-opted for another.
Example: Feathers initially evolved for heat retention, not flight.
Why is blood red, and how does this illustrate a non-adaptive explanation?
Blood is red because hemoglobin uses iron to bind oxygen, a physical/chemical property. This is not necessarily an adaptation.
Chance is also not an adaptive trait. give an example.
Why can some humans roll their tongues
This ability likely arose by chance through genetic variation, not as an adaptive trait.
Why does the flu virus make us sneeze, and what alternative explanation exists?
Adaptive Explanation: Sneezing spreads the flu virus.
Alternative: Sneezing expels foreign objects, a side-effect of immune defenses.
Not all traits are adaptations. list the alternatives.
- exaptation
- chance
- side-effect of other adaptation
- historical constraint
What are some methods to tell us about the heritability of a trait
- Trait correlation between parents and offspring
- Comparing monozygotic and dizygotic twins, if mono> di then it tells us smt abt heritability
- Looking at associations between phenotypes and genotypes
In a low-starch diet population, why do individuals have fewer copies of the amylase gene?
Low selective pressure for increased starch digestion results in fewer copies of the gene.
How do we determine if variation in the amylase gene affects fitness?
Feed individuals with different genotypes high-starch diets.
Measure offspring production as a fitness indicator.
What was biology’s main focus before phylogenetics?
Systematics, the classification of organisms into fixed categories (e.g., Linnaean taxonomy).
Why are fixed taxonomic ranks considered arbitrary?
They imply a simple tree structure, but molecular phylogeny reveals more detailed evolutionary relationships.
What is the significance of Darwin’s idea of phylogenetic trees?
They model evolutionary ancestry and genetic inheritance over time, replacing fixed hierarchical systems.
How are phylogenies reconstructed from trait data?
matrix fo pair wise distance of sequences
how to perform UPGMA
Create a distance matrix of pairwise distances.
Merge the pair with the smallest distance.
Update the matrix by averaging distances to the new cluster.
Repeat until all taxa are clustered.
What is UPGMA (unweighted pair group method with arithmetic mean)
combining taxas with most similar average to construct tree
4 amino acids in the sodium potassium pump has changed.. leading to…
changes evolved independently
What is the principle of maximum parsimony in phylogenetics?
Focuses on reconstructing evolution rather than using similarity measures.
Assumes traits arise on the simplest path (fewest evolutionary events).
A parsimonious explanation minimizes repeated or independent trait evolution.
What are the 2 problems regarding parsimony reconstruction?
- not all changes are equally likely
- we could have to check a frightening large number of trees to be sure we have found the best one
A phylogeny is a hypothesis about…
shared ancestry
Why are all changes not equally likely?
diff mutation rates, diff substitution rates
Which is more frequent? transitions or transversions?
transitions
Which codon is the one that diverges fastest?
3rd codon substitution is most likely synonymous so it diverged fastest (2nd is non-synonymous)
What is the solution for ‘not all changes are equally likely’?
use a substitution model, find tree that maximises probability (maximum likelihood tree)
assuming rate of 0.3 substitutions per million years allows maximum likelihood reconstruction