Week 8: medieval religious thought Flashcards
what was scholastic theology?
a systemic approach to theology making use of rhetoric and logic, was now taught in most academic settings
why was Berengar of Tours (999-1088) regarded with suspicion?
criticised for reducing eucharistic mystery to some kind of dialectical puzzle
why was scholastic theology such a difficult approach?
hard to maintain academic rigour and theological orthodoxy
What did Anselm (died 1117) propose
that early christians had different ways of reading biblical stories and offered the means in which we should resolve divergences, producing a synthesis of dialect
who carried on Anselm dialectic tradition?
Peter Abelard (1079-1142) in ‘Sic et Non’ (yes and no), where he discussed 150 debated theological points, and in the 12th century text book ‘The Four Books of the Sentences’ set out multiple issues and left readers to resolve them
by the beginning of the twelfth century what was there an appetite for?
systematic articulation of theological positions, justified through rationality but, formed upon a biblical basis
Aquinas’ famous work
‘Summa Theologiae’ c.1265
what did Summa Theologiae weave together?
the reconciliation of competing biblical and patristic statements within the rational framework needed to defend the christian faith sufficiently
in 529 what did Byzantine emperor Justine order?
the closing of the philosophical school in Constantinople
after the philosophical school of Constantinople was closed, where did people continue work on Plato and Aristotle?
Edessa in Syria
what lead to a new interest in Aristotle?
The Islamic conquest of the Middle East
what was Aristotles work first translated into?
Syrian, then Arabic
what made Aristotles texts more widely available?
a major school of translation established by the bishops of Toledo in Spain in the mid- twelfth century. With increased contact with islamic scholarship in Spain, many texts were translated from Arabic to latin
how was philosophy regarded in relation to Theology?
in the Middle Ages it was regarded as useful as scaffolding to theological ideas but wholly inferior
why was the theological use of Aristotle’s work seem controversial?
his ideas didn’t always fit easily with christian orthodoxy and at times completely contradicted it - eg his views on the eternity of the world, if the world had no beginning it could not be created
which of Aristotles works were admired and came to be basic texts for many medieval universities, including Paris during the thirteenth century
his logical works yet his scientific works were seen as misleading and erroneous.
what did a local church declare in 1210?
that Aristotles works or commentaries should not be read in Paris in public or private
what did the bishop of Paris list in 1277?
two hundred errors in Aristotles writings
after the declaration of the bishop of Paris in 1277, how did theologians begin to consider Aristotles work?
more critically, scrutinised them before accepting them
how many lines of argument did Aquinas draw up in support of the existence of God?
five
what did Aquinas’ ‘five ways’ highlight?
how it was reasonable to find pointers towards the existence of God drawn from general experiences of the world
according to Aquinas, what does the world mirror?
God, as it is his creation
Aquinas- why can be observe things in the world e.g. natural order, and explain it using God?
because he believed that because god was the creator of the world he impressed his divine likeness and divine image upon it
according to Aquinas where should we look for evidence for the existence of God?
in the order within the world, this is the most convincing
what is the first of Aquinas’ five ways?
‘argument from motion’ why is the world not static? everything that moves had to have been moved by something in the first place, so for every motion their is a cause. each cause of motion has a cause. there cannot be an infinite number of causes tho. there must be one original cause of the great chain of motion which reflects the way the world behaves this is God as everything has motion