Week 5: Positivist Criminology Flashcards
What is Positivism Criminology?
- Not a theory but a philosophy related to the use of science in regulating the world around us
What are the Basic Features of Positivism?
- Systematic observation
- Accumulation of evidence
- Objective fact
- Deductive framework
What is the Focus of Trait Theories?
- Focus on characteristics of the offender rather than to his/her circumstances
Who is Cesare Lombroso?
- Published work between 1876 to 1910
- Considered the father Italian positivist criminology (the “Italian school”)
- Most lasting contribution was in relation to the criminal justice system
- Lombroso said punishment should fit the criminal
- Born criminals should be incarcerated to protect society
What are Sociological Theories?
- Differences in the social environment explain crime (Family, school, peer group, community, etc.)
- Argue there are no individual differences between criminals and non-criminals
What are Modern Biological Theories?
- Focus on individual differences and the influence of these difference on the likelihood of crime
What is Sociobiological and Criminology?
- Biology, environment, and learning are mutually interdependent
- Personal traits separate deviant from non-deviant
- Personal traits account for different responses to similar conditions
What is Contemporary Trait Theory?
Criminality can be explained by individual differences:
- Both biological and psychological
- May be genetic, neurological, or chemical
Focus on basic human drives, not legal definitions
- Ex. Aggression, impulsivity
Traits work in combination with environmental and social factors
- Focus on chronic offenders, criminal careers
What are the two Main Reasons to Examine Biological Factors?
- Interact with the social environment to produce crime
- Influence the social environment in ways that increase the likelihood of crime
What is Bio Criminology?
- The study of the physical aspects of psychological disorders (Brain waves, disturbed nervous system functioning, biochemical abnormalities)
- Human beings are products of an interaction between environmental and genetic factors
What three Arguments do Biocriminology make?
- Biological and environmental factors influence the development of traits conducive to crime
- Traits that produce crime influence the social environment in ways that increase the likelihood of crime
- Crime is most likely among individuals who possess traits that produce crime and are in aversive environments
What did Sheldon & Eleanor Glueck Study?
- Sought to explain why people respond to different environments in different ways
- Took a life-course approach examining how the causes of crime develop from childhood to adulthood
Who were the Participants in Glueck & Glueck’s Study?
- Sample of five hundred delinquent and five hundred non-delinquent boys
- White males ages ten to seventeen matched on age, race, neighbourhood characteristics, and intelligence
- Delinquents from two juvenile reformatories in Massachusetts and non-delinquents from Boston public schools
- The Glueck’s followed up with the boys at ages twenty-five and thirty-two
What were the Critiques of Glueck and Glueck’s Study?
- Sutherland attacked this work, saying it was atheoretical and downplayed sociological factors
- Sociologists rejected the work, saying it was flawed
What did Glueck and Glueck Argue?
- Area studies are not universal
- We need multidisciplinary studies of crime
- Theorists only focus on singular factors