Week 4 - Positive Identification Flashcards
DNA
most conclusive way to identify
unique
need comparison DNA - from parents or siblings
types of dna
nuclear - almost all cells, from both parents
mitochondrial - from mother
problem with dna
parents who have two children that are missing - cannot differentiate between them
only way is if the child had children themselves
sources of dna - live person
nuclear - any nucleated cells - white blood cells, buccal smear, hair follicle
mtDNA - all above and hair shaft
bone marrow transplant - bloods dna will be different
sources of DNA - dead person
fresh body - blood, tissue, hair root
decomposed or skeletonized - bone marrow, teeth (dentine under enamel)
mtDNA - hair shafts
DNA comparison
unknown body gives DNA profile
compare DNA from body with premorten record of tentative ID person
DNA databank
certain offenders - rape, murder
finger prick or buccal swab
DNA taken in investigation not used in bank - second sample taken after - investigation samples destroyed (fingerprints not unless asked)
Other premortem dna
most women have DNA on record - pap smears
positive ID
can only be one person
done after tentative ID to confirm
methods of positive ID
Visual identification, fingerprints, dental records, x-rays, medical x-rays, dna, video superimposition, circumstantial
visual identification
most common, least scientific
family and friends
only used with fresh bodies unless there is a specific feature
fingerprints
old technique
unique
environmentally determined in utero
fingerprints at scene
latent prints
individualization - its your fingerprint
identification - its A fingerprint
three principles of fingerprints
individual characteristics are unique
unchanged throughout life
ridge patterns can be classified
what are prints made from
oils and sweat on skin
fingerprint individualization
examination of minutiae ridge characteristics - 150 per print
suspect print may be partial
no specific number of characteristics needed
officer making final say is subjective
levels of detail
pattern - whorl, arch, loop (classification)
minutiae - fine lines on print used for comparison
sweat pores within minutiae
quality depends on - surface, sweat, recovery time, technique used
problems with fingerprints
must have premortem record
can get prints from home - but difficult
decomposing remains and prints
if skin comes off - wear as glove
fingers can be rehydrated
dental records and x-rays
considered unique
differences in wear, rotation, root shape, fillings, extractions
used as signature in old days
dental evidence
compare premortum with postmortum record
may not be accurate because teeth can fall out..
teeth preserve well
problems with dental evidence
need premortum records
no centralized database
dentist dont keep records forever
medical x-rays
broken bones, fracture records, healing patterns
implanted devices - serial numbers
sinus shape is unique
medical records
written details, height, weight, surgeries, scars
video superimposition
match photo of tentative ID to skull
done by anthropologists
angle must be identical
easier to eliminate than ID
circumstantial
may be only method available
if a male, age 70, 150cm tall found dead in home, and apartment is owned by someone of this description, its likely him