Week 3 Flashcards
What does accounting analysis involve
- Assess the reliability of the financial statements for the prediction of future performance
– Recast and adjust final statements to enhance comparability across firms / time
– Adjust firm’s reported profit to arrive at a measure that is more useful for valuing the company
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 1
Identify Key Accounting Policies
– Key policies and estimates used to measure risks and critical factors for success must be identified.
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 2
assess Accounting Flexibility
– Accounting information is more open to distortion if managers have a high degree of flexibility in choosing policies and estimates.
– Largely a function of industry membership
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 3
Evaluate Accounting Strategy
• Flexibility in accounting choices allows managers to strategically communicate economic information or distort performance
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 3
Issues to consider
Issues to consider include:
- Typical accounting policies of industry peers
- Incentives for managers to manage earnings
- Changes in policies and estimates and the rationale for doing so
- Whether transactions are structured to achieve financial reporting objectives
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 4
– Whether there is sufficient disclosure to identify the nature of key transactions
– Whether management discussion and analysis (MD&A) sufficiently explains and is consistent with current performance
– Whether GAAP reflects or restricts the appropriate measurement of key measures of success
– Adequacy of segment disclosures
• Segments may be defined geographically or by the nature of the different business areas in which a firm operates.
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 5: Identify Potential Red Flags
-Issues that warrant gathering more information include:
– Unexplained transactions that boost profits
– Unusual increases in inventory or receivables in relation to sales revenue
– Increases in the gap between net income and cash flows or taxable income
– Use of R&D partnerships, Special Purpose Entities or the sale of receivables to finance operations.
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 5: Identify Potential Red Flags
-Issues that warrant gathering more information continued
– Unexpected large asset write-offs
– Large fourth-quarter adjustments (US firms)
– Qualified or modified audit opinions or auditor changes
– Large related-party transactions.
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 6: Undo Accounting Distortions
-Financial statement footnotes often provide information from which the analyst can undo accounting distortions or make the financial statements more comparable.
Steps in performing accounting analysis
Step 6: Undo Accounting Distortions
-Financial statement footnotes often provide information from which the analyst can undo accounting distortions or make the financial statements more comparable.
Potential Sources of Noise and Bias in Published Financial Statements
Rigidity in accounting rules
Bias in Accounting Rules
Random managerial forecast errors
Abuse of manager’s accounting discretion, or discretion relating to the timing and structuring of transactions
Potential Sources of Noise and Bias in Published Financial Statements
Rigidity of Accounting Rules
What do many accounting decisions allow
Many accounting decisions allow or require a degree of discretion in the recognition and measurement of items
Potential Sources of Noise and Bias in Published Financial Statements
Rigidity of Accounting Rules
Many accounting decisions allow or require a degree of discretion in the recognition and measurement of items
Why?
allow management to signal their private information regarding the future profitability of the firm to outsiders
• However, because managers may have incentives to abuse this discretion, many accounting rules limit the manager’s reporting choices
Potential sources of noise and bias
Rigidity of accounting rules
Impact of accounting rules which limit the manager’s reporting choices
Limiting the range of accounting choices may impair a manager’s ability to reflect the economics of a firm’s transactions in the financial statements, for e.g.
– Cannot use LIFO inventory method, even if it is the method that best reflects the order in which inventories are sold
– Mandatory revaluations of financial assets not intended to be sold
Bias in accounting standards
describe conservative bias
bad news is typically reflected in the accounts more swiftly than good news.
Random (Honest) Managerial Forecast Errors
Estimating the ‘correct’ accounting value for most assets (except cash) requires the manager/accountant to predict the future
Random (Honest) Managerial Forecast Errors
What assets require prediction of the future
– Net receivables requires prediction of future collections of amounts owed to firm
– Inventories require prediction of whether goods are likely to be sold, and if so at what price (must record at lower of historic cost or market value of inventories)
– Machinery requires prediction as to the remaining service potential associated with the asse
Random (Honest) Managerial Forecast Errors
‘errors’ in predicting the future will affect the
errors’ in predicting the future will affect the usefulness of current earnings for predicting future earnings, and thus future cash flows, and thus the ‘true’ fair value of the firm
What can we do about random (Honest) Managerial Forecast Errors
We can observe the quality of a firm’s prior accounting estimates
– Large write-offs of receivables
– Large write-downs of inventory
– Large asset impairments
Many Accounting Estimation Errors Reflect
Inherent Uncertainty
• Firms differ in terms of the risks they face:
– Operating risk (what transactions do you engage in?)
– Financial risk (how much debt have you got?)
Many Accounting Estimation Errors Reflect Inherent Uncertainty
Operating risk in particular will
Operating risk in particular will naturally affect the reliability of accruals such as inventory and receivables
– Where cash flows from customers / to suppliers are very volatile….it’s harder to make judgements re receivables / inventories
Manager’s Accounting Discretion
Companies reporting practices are
Companies reporting practices are determined most directly by senior management (e.g. CEO / CFO)
Manager’s accounting discretion
Agency Theory
managers act in pursuit of their own interest, and not necessarily in the interest of shareholders (owners)
incentives for managers to deliberately abuse the discretion afforded in measuring profit, relate to either:
1) Purely self-interested reporting decisions
2) Decisions which may increase the value of the firm
incentives for managers to deliberately abuse the discretion afforded in measuring profit, relate to either:
Purely self-interested reporting decisions
maximising management compensation or the probability of keeping job, with no apparent benefit to shareholders
incentives for managers to deliberately abuse the discretion afforded in measuring profit, relate to either:
Decisions which may increase the value of the firm
increase management wealth (because mgmt. compensation may be linked to firm value)
– Increase in firm value may only be temporary, AND/OR
– Increase in firm value may result from transferring wealth from creditors (i.e. making shareholders better off / creditors worse-off)
Managers’ Accounting Discretion and Reporting Quality
Managers have a number of incentives to make accounting choices that bias measured profit and financial position
Managers have a number of incentives to make accounting choices that bias measured profit and financial position including, but not limited to
– Capital Market Incentives
– Contracting Incentives
– Political Incentives
Managers’ Accounting Discretion and Reporting Quality
Capital Market Incentives
Incentives to manipulate earnings to influence capital market perception of firms’ profitability and/or risk
Managers’ Accounting Discretion and Reporting Quality
Capital Market Incentives
including:
– Incentives meet / beat market earnings expectations
– Incentives to inflate earnings prior to issuing equity / debt
– Broad incentives to appear more profitable in the long-run, maintaining a higher stock price for several months or years (maybe)
Managers’ Accounting Discretion and Reporting Quality
Capital Market Incentives – Meet/Beat Earnings Expectations
what evidence is there
a stock market penalty (i.e. stock price fall) for firms whose reported earnings fall short of analyst consensus earning forecasts
managers of firms who fail to meet or beat consensus forecasts are more likely to be fired in the short- medium term
Managers’ Accounting Discretion and Reporting Quality
Capital Market Incentives – Meet/Beat Earnings Expectations
Creates incentive for managers to manipulate either reported earnings, or of the analyst forecasts (‘talking analysts down’) to avoid reporting earnings below the consensus forecast
i.e. manipulate reported earnings to meet or just beat consensus
Managers’ Accounting Discretion and Reporting Quality
Capital Market Incentives – Meet/Beat Earnings Expectations
limitation to manipulating earnings to meet or just beat consensus
they may not want to manipulate earnings to beat consensus by a long distance, as this may make it harder to beat next year’s consensus