Week 10 - Observational Studies (FLIPPED CLASSROOM) Flashcards
STUDY DESIGN SUMMARY
What are the characteristics of Cross-sectional studies?
-Random sample recruited from source population
-At specific time point
-Exposure and outcome assessed simultaneously
What are the two types of cross-sectional studies?
1.Descriptive = assessment of only one variable at a time
2. Analytic = assessment of associations between 2 variables
At what time is exposure and outcome assessed?
- At a specific time point
-THUS simultaneously
What do you call cross-sectional studies done annually or biannually by countries?
-Surveys
What are the 3 descriptive measures of observational studies?
-Proportions (categorical variables)
-Prevalence (binary categorical variables)
-Mean/Median (numeric variables)
What are three measures of association in cross-sectional studies?
-Odds ratio (binary categorical outcomes)
-Mean diff (categorical exposure vs numeric outcome)
-Regression/ correlation coefficient (numeric exposure vs numeric outcome)
What are the advantages of cross-sectional studies?
- Easy to perform
- Less costly
- Opportunity to readily assess prevalence of disease in population THUS results are of high relevance to public
What are the disadvantages of cross-sectional studies?
- Observational study THUS self-reports THUS information bias
-Observational study THUS prone to confounding - Impossible to assess risk (incidence)
-Impossible to assess temporality in association (BECAUSE TESTED SIMULTANEOUSLY)
-Not appropriate for inferring causality (HIGH LIKELIHOOD OF REVERSE CAUSATION)
CASE CONTROL STUDIES SCHEMATIC DIAGRAMs
What are the characteristics of case-control studies?
- A group of patients with specific disease is recruited (CASE GROUP)
- Recruit a random sample of individuals NOT suffering from specific disease (CONTROL GROUP)
- Control group must be recruited from same source population as case group
- Control group can be recruited from general population (preferred) OR hospital patients not suffering from this specific disease
- Case and control group is usually matched for key characteristics (age, gender, etc) = ELIMINATES CONFOUNDING
- Matching restricted factors should be limited to 2-3. Overmatching = avoided. INSTEAD other confounders should be adjusted in analysis
- Assessment of a series of exposures in cases and controls that occurred in the past
RETROSPECTIVE (start with disease and look back in time for identification of exposures)
What are the measures of association of case-control studies?
-Odds ratio (categorical exposures)
-Mean diff (numeric exposures)
ALWAYS BINARY OUTCOMES FOR CASE CONTROL STUDIES
What are the descriptive measures for case-control studies?
NEVER CALCULATED FOR CONTROL_CASE
ONLY ANALYTIC!
What are the advantages of case-control studies?
-Possible to investigate rare diseases
-Easy to perform (not as much as cross-sectional studies)
-Cheap (not as much as cross-sectional studies)
- Possible to assess several exposures and potential confounders for a single outcome
-Possible to investigate early exposures in life in relation to disease outcomes later in life.
What are the disadvantages of case-control studies?
-It’s an observational study THUS information bias (measurements based off self-reports)
-Prone to recall bias (based on self-reports of events from years back)
-Observational study THUS confounding
-If control group is not a representative sample of source population = selection bias
-Impossible to assess risk (incidence) of disease
-Difficult to prove causality due to bias and confounding