War and Peace Flashcards
Name a religious pacifist
Dr. Martin Luther King Jr, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, Mahatma Gandhi, Jesus….
Explain Christian Realist beliefs about War and Peace
Human Nature is inherently selfish and so the government may need to take military action in order ensure a stable society.
Who is the main thinker behind the ideas of Christian Realism?
Reinhold Niebuhr
What are the 6 ‘jus ad bellum’ critreria of the Just War Theory?
Just cause, Right reason, Legitimate authority, Last resort, Proportionality, Likelihood of success
Explain ‘legitimate authority’
War should be declared by the proper authority. For most western countries this used to be the government (Prime Minister or President) but post WWII this now rest with the UN.
Explain ‘Just Cause’
A nation should have a justifiable reason for declaring war.
Explain ‘Right Intention’
The outcome being sought should be noble, generally to bring about peace. it should not be for greed or self interest.
Explain ‘Last Resort’
Every effort should have been made to resolve a conflict diplomatically, without the use of force. For example peace talks or economic sanctions
Explain ‘proportionality’ (before war)
The damage caused by going to war must not be greater than the good achieved.
Explain ‘likelihood of sucess
There should be a good chance of success (however the idea of ‘success’ is a debated one)
Name other criteria of the Just War Theory (not the main 6)
Do not harm civilians or use extreme force, treat POW’s with respect, restore justice after war,
Which type of pacifist is Bertrand Russell
Nuclear and/or Contingent
What made Dietrich Bonhoeffer convert from a religious pacifist to a contingent pacifist?
Bonhoeffer thought that it was impossible to stop Hitler using pacifist ideas and so resorted to violence. His failed attempt to assassinate Hitler resulted in his imprisonment in a concentration camp.
Was the Iraq War started by a Legitimate Authority?
No - It was started by George W Bush and Tony Blair without permission from the UN.
Was World War II started by a Legitimate Authority?
Yes - It was declared by Neville Chamberlain the Prime Minister of the UK (the UN was only established after WWII)
Was the Iraq war a last resort?
No - the UN wanted to send in even more weapons inspectors in order to establish whether or not Saddam Hussein did have WOMD’s
Was WWII a last resort?
Yes - There had already been failed peace talks and it is generally agreed that no peaceful methods would have stopped Adolf Hilter
Did the Iraq war have a just cause?
Yes - Saddam Hussein was reportedly torturing some of his people. In addition to this it was argued that he was also developing WOMD to use against either his own people or other countries (this was never proven)
Did WWII have a just cause?
Yes - Hitler invaded Poland, and as an ally of Poland we had a duty declare war on Germany.
Did the Iraq war have a right intention?
???? - Although they claim to have been fighting for the liberation of the Iraqi people, Bush and Blair are criticised that their main motivation throughout the war was to claim oil.