W10 - personality assessment methods Flashcards
Methods of measuring personality
- objective
- projective
- behavioural
Projective methods of personality measurement
- indirect methods of personality assessment
- projective hypothesis
- “the most important things about an individual are what he cannot or will not say”
Inkblots as projective stimuli
Rorschach inkblots – Psychodiagnostik, Hermann Rorschach (1921)
- 10 bilaterally symmetrical inkblots on separate cards
- > 5 are achromatic (black and white)
- > 5 in colour
Classification debate
Inkblot test phases
3 distinct phases
- > Percept – “What do you see in this picture?”
- > Inquiry - “what made it look like ….” or “How do you see …”
- > Testing the limits – “Sometimes people use a part of the blot to see something” or “What does this look like”
Interpretation of the Rorschach test
Rorschach protocols are scored according to several categories
- Location
- Determinants
- Content
- Popularity
-> Rorschach died before he could finish a scoring manual
Validity and reliability of Rorschach test
- John Exner Jr. developed a comprehensive system for administering, scoring, and interpreting the Rorschach inkblots
- Exner’s system brought uniformity to Rorschach use, but despite the improvements, the psychometric properties of the Rorschach are still debated.
- Test-retest reliability is of little value to the Rorschach because of the very nature of the measurement; inter-rater reliability may be a more appropriate.
- > Does it seem to actually predict anything?
Thematic Apperception Test
Christiana Morgan and Henry Murray (1953)
30 picture cards contain a variety of scenes that present the test-taker with “certain classical human situations”
-> The administering clinician selects the cards that are believed to elicit responses pertinent to the objective of testing.
1 blank card
Interpretation of thematic apperceptive test
The material used in deriving conclusions includes:
- The stories
- The clinician’s notes
- > The way or manner of responding
- > extra-test behaviour and verbalisations
Interpretive systems incorporate or are based on Henry Murray’s concepts of:
-> Need, Press, Thema
Criticisms: implicit motives
Other tests using pictures
Pictures as Projective Stimuli (Projective Story-Telling)
-> make up a story to go with a picture
Apperceptive Personality Test (APT)
-> 8 stimulus cards
Hand test
-> 9+1 stimulus cards
Rosenzweig Picture-Frustration Study
- > Fill in the blank
- > Inquiry afterwards
Words as projective stimuli
Word Association Tests (WAT)
- semi structured, individually administered
- assessee is expected to respond with whatever comes to mind first upon exposure to the stimulus word
The Rapaport et al (1945) WAT (based on Jung, 1910)
- 60 items categorised into neutral and traumatic words
- normative data is provided regarding the percentage of occurrence of certain responses for college students and groups with schizophrenia
EX. for the word “mouth”
-> college group 20% kiss, 11% tongue, 11% lips, 11% eat
-> schizophrenia group 19% teeth, 10% eat
Sentence completion test
- fill in the blank spaces at the end of a sentence
- may be relatively atheoretical or linked closely to some theory
-> sentence completion stems may be developed for use in specific settings or for specific purposes
Sounds as projective stimuli
- not very widely used, redundant compared to TAT
Verbal summator
-> developed by BF Skinner “like auditory inkblots” (1979)
Figure drawing test
Assessee produces a drawing that is analysed on the basis of its content and related variables
- draw a person (DAP) test
- house-tree-person test
- kinetic family drawing (KFD)
Projective stimuli assumptions
- ambiguous stimuli = more insight into a subjects personality
- test-takers are unaware of what they are disclosing
- parallel with behaviour displayed in social situations