VLE Flashcards
List 6 factors affecting values.
Morals, Beliefs, Empathy, Probity, Respect and Culture
Define ‘facts’.
Claims about the world that have been, or can be, verified by empirical methods.
What is meant by the term ‘values’?
Values are claims about, or expressions of, things like: • Preferences • Attitudes • Emotions • Aesthetic appreciation
What are ‘thick concepts’?
Claims that have both factual and evaluative content.
How can value claims be assessed?
Using moral theory.
What is ‘consequentialism’?
‘[C]onsequentialist theories assess the moral value of anything in terms of that thing’s outcomes or impact upon the world’
Consequentialist theories need to provide and defend…
- An account of the relevant good(s)
- An account and method of quantification (e.g., who counts? Can we aggregate? If so, how?)
- An explanation of how rightness is to be determined
What is the principal aim of utilitarianism?
- Aim for the best balance between benefit and harm
* This makes for the most effective use of resources
What are the principles of deontology?
- Rules govern actions and we have a duty to abide by them regardless of cost
- This is contrasted with emphasis on outcomes (as is the case with consequentialism)
- “The right is prior to the good”
What ethical principle is respected by deontology?
Autonomy - it is the only way of respecting an individual’s right to determine their own life.
What are the principles of virtue ethics?
- Focuses on the character of the person (the doctor/professional), not their actions
- A right act is the action a virtuous person would do in the same circumstances
- Not “what should I do?”, but “what kind of person should I be?”
What are the key concepts in virtue ethics?
- A move away from universal principles
- Virtue “lies in a mean”
- Eudaimonia – happiness or welfare
- Phronesis – wisdom or intelligence associated with practical action, implying good judgement or practical value
What 3 Ps are used in ethical reasoning in clinical practice?
- Principles
- Particulars (context/facts of the case)
- Perspectives (of all those involved in or affected by the case)
Define ‘autonomy’.
“Personal autonomy encompasses, at a minimum, self-rule that is free from both controlling interference by others and from certain limitations, such as an inadequate understanding that prevents meaningful choice”
What ethical principle underpins informed consent?
Autonomy.
Give 5 ethical justifications to support the duty to maintain confidentiality.
- Respect for patient autonomy means that they should be able to say what happens to their information
- The consequences of breaching confidentiality could harm the patient
- The consequences of breaching confidentiality could result in lost of trust in the medical profession
- There is an implied promise in the patient-doctor relationship that confidentiality will be maintained
- Trustworthiness is seen as a virtue that doctors should have and a trustworthy doctor would maintain confidentiality
When is it permissible to disclose information about a patient without their explicit consent?
- When required to by law
- If the patient lacks capacity
- When it is in the public interest due to the patient posing a public threat
- If there is a significant risk of serious harm to another person
- If the patient is a child and you have parental consent
- Sharing information in the healthcare team for the benefit of the patient’s care
In what areas of healthcare is consent required?
- Treatment
- Investigation
- Examination
- Disclosure of information
- Research
- Education
If a doctor were to perform a procedure without appropriate informed consent, what charge would they face?
Battery.
Valid consent comprises which 3 basic elements?
- Competence/capacity
- Information
- Voluntariness
A person is unable to make a decision if they cannot…
- Understand the information given to them that is relevant to the decision
- Retain that information long enough to be able to make the decision
- Use or weigh up the information as part of the decision-making process
- Communicate their decision (by any means)
What should be considered when providing patients with appropriate information?
The patient’s needs and wishes, their existing knowledge of the condition and treatment, the nature of their condition, complexity/nature of treatment and the associated risks.
How can coercion be avoided in patients giving consent?
Speaking to the patient alone to determine if there is any coercion.
When is oral consent appropriate?
For low-risk procedures and treatments.
When is written consent required?
- For high-risk procedures and treatments
- If there are significant consequences for the patient’s employment, social or personal life
- If clinical care is not the primary aim of investigation/treatment
- If treatment is part of a research study
- Specific treatments, such as fertility treatment
In what situations can written consent forms be invalidated?
If the patient lacked capacity, was not provided with sufficient information, or did not give consent voluntarily.
List 4 potential obstacles to informed consent.
- Poor information/time pressure during information being given
- Being rushed into making a decision
- Being pressured into making specific decisions by third parties
- Language barriers
Which act regulates the removal, storage and use of human tissue in England, Wales and Northern Ireland?
The Human Tissue Act (HTAct) 2004.
What are the 3 principal functions of the Human Tissue Authority?
- To issue Codes of Practice
- To issue licenses and inspect establishments
- To approve living organ and bone marrow donations
What ‘scheduled purposes’ are covered by the HTAct?
- Anatomical examination
- Determining cause of death
- Public display
- Transplantation
- Education or training relating to human health
On what 4 principles is the HTAct founded?
- Consent
- Dignity
- Quality
- Honesty and openness
What is criminal law?
- Offences usually against individuals but brought on behalf of the Crown (state/society) (e.g., R v Jones)
- Prosecution of a ‘defendant’
- Two elements mens rea (intention) and actus rea (act) – unless ‘strict liability’
- Innocent until proven guilty
- Standard of proof: ‘beyond reasonable doubt’
- Outcome: guilty or not guilty
- Remedy: punishment (fines, imprisonment etc.)
What is civil law?
- Protects rights of individuals against each other/the state
- ‘Claimant’ sues ‘defendant’
- Types of cases include breach of contract, employment rights, personal injury, breach of copyright and liability
- Standard of proof: balance of probabilities
- Outcome: court finds defendant liable (or not)
- Remedy: damages (or injunction)
- Also includes family law matters (divorce, arrangements for children etc.) and other kinds of non-adversarial hearings such as those concerning arrangements for adults without capacity
What type of law do medical negligence cases come under?
Civil.
What are the 3 elements of negligence actions?
- Duty of Care
- Breach of the duty
- Breach causes injury or loss (causation)
How is ‘criminal negligence’ defined?
Criminal negligence refers to gross negligence showing ‘such a disregard for the life and safety of others as to amount to a crime…deserving of punishment’.
What is common law?
Common law is made by judges, using the principles that are binding for all other like cases (precedence).
What is statutory law?
Statutes are made by government. A new statute trumps existing common law. They may reflect the political agenda of the current government, or responses to strong public opinion or scandal; statutes change to reflect EU law. New statutes are made to reflect changing moral views and technological advances.
What are the actions of the EU based on?
Treaties approved voluntarily and democratically by EU Member States.
What is ‘primary legislation’ under EU law?
The EU Treaties, which give the EU power to legislate in Member States.