utilitarianism (2) Flashcards
who defined utilitarianism as:
“the greatest happiness for the greatest number”
Francis Hutcheson
who said:
”ethics should be based in what is useful”
David Hume
what are the 7 ways of the hedonic calculus (pleasure seeker)
- intensity
- duration- how long it lasts
- certainty of pleasure
- fecundity- ‘productive’ if it leads to other pleasures
- propinquity- how near to pleasure
- purity
- extent- more people that experience it the better
3 weaknesses of the hedonic calculus
- Teleological- relies on accurately predicted consequences of an action
- pleasure and pain is subjective
- HC is hard to apply to immediate ethical dilemas (quantifier)
“it’s better to be a human being ______ than a pig satisfied, it’s better to be _____ dissatisfied than a fool satisfied”
- John stuart mill
“it’s better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied, it’s better to be socrates dissatisfied than a fool satisfied”
Quantifiers: Higher and lower pleasure
define and give examples
Lower: being gratification but if we overendulge can be painful e.g. drinking, sex, eating
Higher: stimulate the brain and experienced by humans e.g. art, intellectual conversations
what does mill acknowledge about Higher and lower pleasures
people don’t always opt for the higher pleasure out of ignorance
define competent judge
a person that’s experienced higher and lower pleasures
what are the three parts of mills principle of utility
- happiness is desirable
- happiness if the only thing desirable as an end to itself
- general happiness is all is desirable, increase happiness of others increases your own
define aitruism
the usefulness and love for others
philosophical critics of mill
W.D Ross
Mills POU is a ‘single factor’ that’s doesn’t account for complex lives or moral decisions
philosophical critics of mill
Henry sidwick
“how can we distinguish higher and lower pleasures from eachother… which higher pleasure takes priority in moral decisions”
3 strengths of benthams act utilitarianism
- Subjective- takes into account individaul acts
- Equality- HC is applied to all in every situation
3- HC provides clear guidelines on how to make moral decisions
2 weaknesses of benthams act utilitarianism
1.can be misused to make bad decisions
2.HC is impractical to apply to every situation
2 strengths of mills rule utilitarianism
1.interested in maximising happiness
2. univeral- based in natural human morality