utilitarianism Flashcards
main scholars (U)
Act - Jeremy Bentham
Rule - John Stuart Mill
Influences - David Hume (links ethics to utility), Epicureus (links pleasure to happiness)
What is the principle of utility
seeking the greatest balance of good over evil, pleasure over pain
religious or secular (U)
secular
absolutist or relativist (U)
good is relative
deontological or teleological (U)
teleological
What is the hedonic calculus
method of applying the utility principle to potential ecisions to work out which will promote the most pleasure
What are the seven questions of the hedonic calculus
Purity, Remotenness, Richness, Intensity, Certainty, Extent, Duration
Purity
will this pain lead to another pain?
remoteness
is the pleasure/pain in the distant or near future?
richness/fecundity
will this pleasure lead to another pleasure?
certainty
how certain are you that the pleasure/pain will happen?
extent
the number of people who would be effected by the pleasure/pain
duration
will the pleaure/pain last for a short time or long time
Act utilitarianism (Bentham)
Calculating the consequences of each situation on its own merits
Rule utilitarianism (Mill)
Following the accepted laws that lead to the greatest balance of good over evil and pleasure over pain
Mill’s qualititive approach to pleasure
Some pleasures (higher, intellectual/social) are better than others (lower, bodily/physical), so are more valuable
What is the harm/non-harm/liberty principle?
an action is wrong if it involves harming another person
What did mill say when accusing Act utilitarianism of being a swine ethic?
“it is better to be a human being dissatisfied than a pig satisfied” (higher/lower pleasures)