Utilitarianism Flashcards
What type of theory is utilitarianism
- teleological
- concerned with consequences of an action
What is the claim of utilitarianism
The claim of utilitarianism is to provide one single principle which and can be applied to all ethical and moral dilemmas
Who is Jeremy Bentham
Seen as the father of modern utilitarianism
- believed we can explain human nature as we are psychological hedonists -> seek our own pleasure
How does the hedonist claim link to utilitarianism
- the hedonist idea that we are pleasure seeking creatures means that the good is maximising pleausre and minimising palin
What is the principle of utility
“Seek the greatest balance of good over evil”
What is Bentham quote for the principle of utility
“ create all the happiness that you can create, remove all the misery you are able to remove”
What is a problem with the principle of utility
- the principle of utility needs to supplemented with a universal idea of what “good” is
- good is different for many people. E.g Benthams good is pleasure and mills good is happiness
- good for a serial killer is much different to the good of a charity worker
What is the hedonic calculus
A system created by Bentham which can help us decide whether an act should be conducted or not
What are the 7 criteria of the hedonic calculus
- intensity
- duration
- certainty
- propinquity
- purity
- extent
What was benthams aim with the hedonic calculus
To reduce moral decisions to something which can be calculated
What is a problem with the hedonic calculus
- there are too many variables when calculating pleasure
- if someone loves chocolate and they were to eat one chocolate, say if one chocolate was worth 10 pleasure points by extension this would mean that by eating 10 chocolates a person will get 10x the pleasure
- in reality this is not true as even the most avid chocolate eaters would start to feel sickly after a whole
- furthermore some pleasures are more pleasure able at different times kf the day
What was mill unhappy with (benthams idea)
- mills as unhappy with benthams idea that there are no types of pleasure rather what matters Is the amount of pleasure
- mil argues that there are higher an lower pleasures
Mills quote supporting higher and lower pleasures
“ it is better to be a human dissatisfied than a pig satisfied”
What is a problem with benthams form of utilitarianism
- a probelm which occurs with benthams form of utilitarianism is that it has been attributed to the idea of “ the greatest good for the greatest number”
- this is a mistake as it goes against the soul purpose of utilitarianism as it adds a second principle.
- the first principle is to do good, this idea brings in the principle of justice, good needs to be done and needs to be distributed
What is act utilitarianism
- act utilitarianism is benthams form of utilitarianism
- it argues that we should do the act which leads it the Greta test balance of good over pleasure, to do this we should use the hedonic calculus to calculate which act should be done