Unit One Flashcards
What is the vague definition of Ethnicity?
Group or category often defined by culture, heritage or language
Collective Ethnic Identity
A certain consensus within the group about what constitutes it as such and differentiates it from other groups
Individual Ethnic Identity
The relationship of individuals to their own ethnic collectivity
Diachronic Elements include
Ancestry, homeland and cultures associated with one’s ethnic group
Synchronic Elements include
The ways in which an individual or ethnic collectivity is defined, evaluated and treated by others…what are the ways right NOW
Ethnic Identity Formation
The reciprocal process between individuals and groups
What are the three resources of ethnic groups
Expressive strengths, organizational strengths and instrumental strengths
What are examples of expressive strengths of an ethnic group
Folk customs, religion, beliefs and values
Ethnic Institutions
Sites or social spaces within which ethnic identity is produced and maintained overtime
Identities that are considered “US”, the protagonist are called our default because it is what we…
We expect people to be like us, it is what we understand and accept
Others/Them are defined by
not being like us. Unexpected.
Binary notions if Self/Other defines….
how society often thinks about race and ethnicity
Ascriptive Characteristics
Physical or genetic characteristics
“Racism is the doctrine that a mans behaviour is determined by stable inherited characteristics” was a quote from who, in what year?
Banton, 1970
The most popular example of scientific racism was by the
Nazis
Even today, race is still treated as…
a natural category
The Bell Curve was written by
Herrnstein and Murray in 1994
The Bell Curve argues what two main ideas?
1) General intelligence varies among ethnicity and “race” 2) Genetic and environmental factors explain variation among Asians, Whites and Blacks
“Social processes and practices whereby social relations among people are structured by the signification of human biological characteristics in such a was as to define and contract differentiated social collectives” is the definition of what? Who said this?
Miles and Brown (2003) on Racialization
Miles and Brown emphasize what about race?
The social constructedness of race
Why do some argue that social scientists ought to refuse to use the idea of “race”?
So as not to reify it
How does Statistics Canada define ethnicity?
By “objective” ancestry or roots
What is problematic about statistics canada and their use of ethnicity?
Tells us nothing about subjective, and cannot interpret individuals who identify with multiple ethnicities.
In 1991, what percentage of people reported “Canadian” as origin?
4%
In 2006, what ratio of people reported Canadian as origin?
1 in 3
In what year did the Canadian government stop attempting to measure the racial origin of Canadians?
1951
In 1996, why did the Canadian government re-introduce the race question?
Information need to better monitor the success of policies like the federal governments employment equity policy
Objective elements of ethnicity groups
presence of ethnic organizations/institutions, ancestry, customs and rituals
Subjective elements of ethnicity groups
ethnic boundaries: group inclusion and exclusion, solidarity and sympathy for other members, regional groups within ethnicity
External aspects of identity
speaking an ethnic language, practising ethnic traditions
Internal aspects of identity
Cognitive (self image, and image of group), moral obligation, affective (emotional attachments to group)
What happens in the deconstruction of ethnicity?
Some loss of meaning/use of some of the objective aspects of the ethnic identity. May result in alienation, negative views of the ethnic group
What happens in the reconstruction of ethnicity?
gaining of new meanings, new collective experiences often involved
What was the hypothesis for the Breton et al 1990 case?
that for each generation there would be a tendency to negotiate away the objective, external aspects of ethnicity as well as those subjective, internal aspects which may not be consonant with popular societal values and attitudes
What was the results for the Breton et al 1990 case?
The hypothesis was rejected as objectives measured suggested reconstruction more than the subjective ones (language, food, and friends)
What is considered the nonfactual element of empirical research?
A worldview or “lens”
How is theory considered a moral narrative?
It is an elaborate moral debate, allows multiple stakeholders to have a voice (‘own’ your moral and political concerns)
What are two top approaches in theory?
Primordial Approaches and Culture and Assimilation
What are three key components to the primordial theory approach?
Group membership (sharing genetic heritage), fixed and immutable ethnic and racial groups, and socio-biology
What is socio-biology in a a primordial theory context?
explains human behaviour through evolutionary pressures. Suggestions by Van den Berghe that to maximize the chances of survival, the individuals breed within their own kind, leading to in group bias
What did Van den Berghe suggest?
ethnicity is a population bounded by the tule or practice of endogamy
What three theorists resonate with the Culture and Assimilation theory?
W.I Thomas and F. Znaniecki as well as Robert Park
What did W.I Thomas and F. Znaniecki study?
Studied adjustment of recent immigrants to U.S and then studied peasants social reorganization
Who spoke of the race relations cycle?
Robert Park
The race relations cycle explained assimilation as
2 paths, several stages, all leading to assimilation
What were Milton Gordon’s 7 Processes of Assimilation?
Cultural or behavioural assimilation, structural assimilation, marital assimilation, identification assimilation, attitude receptional assimilation, behaviour reception assimilation, civic assimilation
Is Milton Gordon linear or inevitable?
Neither
Four criticisms against assimilation theories
1) Visible minority groups may not go through the same process 2) Assimilation may not be the end point of the process 3) Groups can end up in long lasting, irresolvable states of conflict 4) Gordon’s structural assimilation model has been criticized as too simplistic
What is Portes and Segmented Assimilation?
Immigrants can assimilate into different elements of society making different outcomes possible