Unit Five Flashcards
Which ONE of the following statements is CORRECT?
(A) When trustees exercise a discretion, they must take account of the beneficiaries’ wishes.
(B) Trustees must give the beneficiaries reasons if they refuse to exercise a discretion.
(C) Beneficiaries can compel trustees to carry out duties but not to exercise a discretion.
(D) Trustees do not have to exercise a discretion nor consider whether to exercise it.
The answer is C. While beneficiaries can compel trustees to carry out duties (usually by obtaining a court order), they have little or no control over the exercise of trustee powers or discretions.
A is not correct because, while trustees may choose to discuss matters with the beneficiaries as a matter of good trust administration, they do not have to. They do, however, have to act in the beneficiaries’ best interests when exercising their discretions.
B is not correct because trustees do not have to give reasons for their decisions. [The exception to this might be where a beneficiary has a legitimate expectation that a discretion will be exercised in their favour and the trustees decide differently.]
D is not correct because trustees must consider from time to time whether to exercise their discretions. Having done so, they are free not to exercise them if they wish (although trustees of a discretionary trust do have a duty to distribute the trust property to the beneficiaries; at some point, they will need to make a choice as to who is to benefit from the trust).
Lionel (an accountant) and Stephen (an artist) are trustees of the Parker family trust. The trust is held for Diana for life, remainder to Martin and Sandra.
Which ONE of the following statements is CORRECT?
(A) The trustees will be subject to the same duty of care when making investment decisions.
(B) The trustees must review the trust investments from time to time and take advice unless they reasonably conclude that it is unnecessary or inappropriate to do so.
(C) The trustees can invest the trust fund in accordance with their own ethical views and preferences about investments.
(D) Because there is a life tenant, the trustees must only produce income from their investment of the trust fund; they do not have to consider capital growth until Diana dies.
The answer is B. Trustees have to take professional advice when investing and reviewing investments unless they reasonably conclude that it is unnecessary or inappropriate (e.g. because the trust fund is small and is being invested in very safe investments or the trustees are investment experts). This may apply here as Lionel is an accountant, but this will very much depend on Lionel’s qualifications and area of expertise.
Under Grandmother’s will, trust assets worth£90,000 producing £4,500 per annum income are being held for such of three grandchildren Angela (aged 18), Barry (16) and Cathy (14) as attain 21. The will does not vary any of the trustees’ statutory powers. Grandmother died in 2013.
Which one of the following statements is CORRECT?
(A) Angela should be receiving £1,500 per annum income.
(B) Angela ought to have been paid half her entitlement, i.e., £ 15,000, on her 18th birthday
(C) Angela should be receiving £4,500 per annum income.
(D) Angela gets nothing until she reaches 21 .
The answer is A. Under s31 Trustee Act 1925, once Angela reached 18, she should be paid the current income from her share of the trust income i.e., one third of £4,500 (not all the income earned by the trust, so C is not correct). The trustees have no discretion over this.
B is not correct because while the trustees could make an advancement of capital to Angela under s32 Trustee Act 1925, this is entirely a matter for their discretion.
D is not correct because while she will only obtain a vested interest in the capital at 21, statute provides for advancements before she is actually entitled.
Vikram and Zara are trustees of the Begum family trust. Vikram wants to retire. There are no relevant provisions in the trust instrument.
Which ONE of the following statements is CORRECT?
(A) Vikram could retire under s39 Trustee Act 1925.
(B) Vikram could retire under s36 Trustee Act 1925 and there would be no need to appoint a replacement trustee.
(C) Vikram could retire under s36 Trustee Act 1925. Zara, as a continuing trustee, and Vikram, if he is willing, would have to appoint a replacement.
(D) Vikram could retire under s36 Trustee Act 1925. Vikram would have to appoint a replacement.
The answer is C. S36 lists various grounds on which trustees can be replaced and retirement is one such ground. If the trust instrument does not nominate the person who should make the appointment, it will be the ‘continuing trustees’ who, in this case would be Zara (and Vikram if he is willing to join in).
A is not correct because s39 does not apply because, after retiring, Vikram would not leave two trustees.
B is not correct because s36 requires the outgoing trustee to be replaced by the appointment of a new trustee.
D is not correct because Vikram cannot appoint the new trustee on his own.
Trustees are holding on trust for Mina for life, remainder to Chadni.
Is the following statement TRUE or FALSE?
Under s. 32 of the Trustee Act 1925, the trustees may make an advancement of capital to Mina if Chadni consents.
The statement is FALSE. The trustees may not make an advancement of capital to the life tenant under s.32 of the Trustee Act 1925 because life tenants are not ‘entitled to the capital of the trust property’ as required by the section.
Trustees have decided to delegate their investment duties to a financial adviser. They seek your advice on whether they will be liable if the value of the trust fund declines because the adviser is negligent.
Which ONE of the following statements is CORRECT?
(A) The trustees will not be liable for the loss caused by the adviser under any circumstance
(B) The trustees will be vicariously liable for the adviser’s negligence.
(C) The trustees will be liable for any loss caused by the adviser because they are not allowed to delegate their investment duties.
(D) The trustees will be liable for the advisor’s negligence if they fail to review the advisor’s work and this failure causes loss to the trust fund.
The answer is D. Trustees will not be liable for the defaults of an agent unless the trustees have breached their own duties in relation to the appointment of that agent and these breaches have caused loss to the trust. These duties include, inter alia, the appointment being made in writing, the agent being given details of the trust and written guidance from the trustees on how to undertake their investment role, and the trustees regularly reviewing the arrangement and the work of the agent in compliance with the arrangement.
Beneficiaries are entitled to see “trust documents”.
Which ONE of the following statements is NOT CORRECT?
(A) Beneficiaries are entitled to see the document which created the trust
(B) Beneficiaries are entitled to see documents which show how the trust fund is invested.
(C) The trustees are not required to disclose a settlor’s letter of wishes to the beneficiaries.
(D) Beneficiaries are never entitled to see documents which record the trustees’ deliberations about whether to exercise a power or not.
The answer is D (you were asked to identify the incorrect statement). The statement is not correct because, while beneficiaries are not entitled, as of right, to see documents which show the details of the trustees’ decision-making process, they can apply to the court for an order for disclosure (see Schmidt v Rosewood). The court may order the disclosure of the relevant documents if they believe it is in the interest of the proper administration of the trust (for instance, where there is evidence that the trustees are acting in breach of trust).
Which ONE of the following statements is TRUE?
(A) The settlor is always the person who appoints replacement trustees.
(B) There is no theoretical maximum limit to the number of acting trustees of a private trust of land.
(C) A trustee who remains out of the UK for 10 months can be retired from the trust against their will.
(D) If all the beneficiaries are legally competent, in agreement and collectively absolutely entitled, they can require a trustee to retire.
The answer is D. S19 of the Trust of Land and Appointments of Trustees Act 1996 (“TOLATA”) provides that if these specific circumstances exist, the beneficiaries can direct that an existing trustee retire (and that a replacement trustee be appointed).
A is not correct because while the settlor may have reserved power to appoint replacement trustees going forward, more often than not the settlor does not do so. The appointment is normally made by the “continuing trustees” under s36 Trustee Act 1925.
B is not correct because there is a maximum of four trustees of a trust of land. (There is no theoretical maximum for a trust of personalty, but practically more than two or three trustees will make administration of the trust rather unwieldy.)
C is not correct because a trustee has to remain out of the UK for 12 months before being retired from the trust against their will.
Which ONE of the following is NOT a duty imposed on trustees under general law in relation to their investment of the trust fund?
(A) A duty to consider the suitability of investments and the diversification of those investments.
(B) A duty to ensure that the value of the trust fund does not decrease.
(C) A duty to seek professional advice before investing unless it is reasonable not to do so.
D) A duty to review investments held in the trust from time to time.
The answer is B. Trustees have to ensure the best financial return in the investment of the trust fund. However, as with all investment, it is possible that the trust investments could fall in value due to market events. The standard of care in relation to investment is such care and skill as is reasonable on the circumstances (s1 Trustee Act 2000). Provided trustees have met this standard of care and complied with their other investment duties under the Trustee Act 2000 in their decision-making process, they will not be held liable for such market fluctuations.
A and D are duties imposed on the trustees under s4 Trustee Act 2000.
C is a duty imposed on the trustees under s5 Trustee Act 2000.
Tracy and Tommy are trustees of a family trust. Tracy is going abroad for six months and wants Jenny to take over the trusteeship for that period. Jenny agrees to do the job.
Is the following statement TRUE or FALSE?
Tracy will have to resign her trusteeship, and Jenny will have to be appointed trustee in her place. When Tracy returns, the reverse will be done.
The statement is FALSE. S25 Trustee Act 1925 enables a trustee to delegate the entire trusteeship role to an attorney for a period not exceeding 12 months. Tracy will continue to be a trustee, but Jenny can act as her attorney while Tracy is abroad. Tracy will remain liable to the beneficiaries if Jenny breaches any duty which causes loss to the trust.
Samuel created a trust in 2017 in which he gave £325,000 to trustees to hold on trust for Timothy, Ursula, and Victoria provided they attain the age of 25. The trust did not vary the trustees’ statutory powers. Timothy is currently 26, Ursula 21, and Victoria 17.
Which ONE of the following statements is CORRECT?
(A) The trustees have a discretion to apply the trust income and advance trust capital to Timothy.
(B) The trustees must accumulate all the trust income.
(C) The trustees can give Ursula the whole of her share of the trust capital now.
(D) The trustees have a discretion to apply the income for the maintenance, education or benefit of Ursula and Victoria.
The answer is C. S.32 Trustee Act 1925 applies as there is no variation of the statute in the trust. The trust was created after 2014 so the whole of Ursula’s share of the trust could be advanced to her (for a purpose that was for her advancement or benefit).
A is not correct because Timothy satisfied the contingency when he attained the age of 25. He is now absolutely entitled to one third of the capital of the trust and any income arising from it. The trustees must pay both to him if he asks for it; they no longer have a discretion.
B is not correct because under s31 Trustee Act 1925, both Timothy and Ursula have a right to the income on their respective shares of the trust fund. This income cannot be accumulated. Only the income from Victoria’s share of the trust, which is not applied for her maintenance, education of benefit must be accumulated.
D is not correct because although the trustees have a discretion under s31 Trustee Act 1925 to apply income for Victoria’s maintenance, education, or benefit while she is a minor, the trustees must pay income to Ursula as she is over the age of 18.
Trustees are holding on trust for “such of Christopher and Aurora Ridgway who attain the age of 25”. Christopher and Aurora are twins. The trust fund comprises company shares and money in bank and building society accounts. The trust instrument contains no administrative powers relevant to this question.
Which ONE of the following would be a breach of trust by the Trustees?
(A) The trustees buy a house in York for Christopher and Aurora to live in.
(B) The trustees buy a house in Leeds to let to students.
(C) The trustees buy a house in Spain to let to tourists.
(D) The trustees buy a shop in Sheffield for Christopher and Aurora to run their coffee shop business.
The answer is C. S8 Trustee Act 2000 allows trustees to buy land as a home for beneficiaries (A), as an investment (B) and for any other purpose (D). However, the land must be situated in the UK. Therefore, (unless permitted by the trust instrument) investing in land in Spain is not an authorised investment, would be unauthorised and therefore a breach by the trustees.
Is the following statement TRUE or FALSE?
In conducting the administration of the trust, the trustees must exercise such care as objectively comparable to how an ordinary, careful businessperson would manage their affairs.
The statement is TRUE. This is the principle derived from the case of Speight v Gaunt which details the standard of care which will be applied to trustees in the general administration of the trust. Although it is an objective standard, paid trustees with professional expertise will be judged by a higher standard. This standard of care sits alongside the duty of care in relation to investment activities detailed in s1 Trustee Act 2000.
An independent financial adviser has been appointed a trustee for a management consultant for life and a student in remainder. The trust fund has been valued at more than £900,000. The trustee uses all of the trust fund to purchase shares in a large international company headquartered in India whose shares trade on the Dow Jones (New York stock exchange). The company’s share-value has recently posted significant growth and the company has a reputation for paying significant dividends to its shareholders.
Which of the following statements best describes why the trustee is likely to be in breach of trust?
(A) The trustee is only permitted to purchase shares in UK companies.
(B) Shares are not an authorised form of investment.
(C) The shares are not a suitable form of investment.
(D) The shares do not represent a diverse form of investment.
(E) The trustee failed to take proper investment advice before purchasing the shares.
Option D is correct. When purchasing investments, trustees must have regard to the standard investment criteria – suitability and the need for diversification. In this case, using the entire trust fund to purchase shares in one company does not respect the need for diversification. If the company gets into financial difficulties, the value of the trust fund may be materially and adversely affected.
A grandmother died five years ago. In her valid will, she left her entire estate to trustees on trust “for my son for life, remainder to such of my grandchildren who attain the age of 25 and if more than one equally.” Her son is now aged 55 years, her grandson and granddaughter are 23 years and 18 years respectively. The trustees have been asked whether they can give some trust income to the granddaughter to pay for dancing lessons. The grandson has consented to the payment being made.
Can the trustees pay this income to the daughter?
(A) Yes, because it is for her maintenance, education, or benefit.
(B) Yes, because she is old enough to give a good receipt.
(C) Yes, because the grandson has consented.
(D) No, because she has no interest in the income.
(E) No, because she is under 25 years of age.
Option D is correct. While the son, the life tenant, is alive, all the income must be paid to him. S31 Trustee Act 1925 does not apply to the granddaughter at the moment because she is not entitled to the trust income (so Option A, Option B, and Option C are all wrong).
Option E is wrong because her age is not the reason that the trustee cannot pay the income to the granddaughter at the moment.