UNIT 1: Core : Law, Society and political involvement Flashcards
Reasons for Laws
* Rules are essential for maintaining order and preventing chaos.
* Each country has its own laws, enforced by courts.
* Laws vary based on beliefs, attitudes, and culture.
* In Australia, federal and state parliaments are the main makers of laws.
Rules and Laws in Australia
- Laws are integral to every aspect of life in Australia, controlling crowd behavior and regulating activities.
- Non-legal rules, such as crowd surfing, are imposed by schools, families, sporting associations, or clubs and apply only to individuals directly involved.
- Laws, on the other hand, are legal rules imposed by the community, requiring obedience from all members.
- Examples of laws include traffic laws and prohibitions on certain age groups from entering premises where alcohol is served.
- The difference between a rule and a law is that the police and courts can enforce laws, while laws carry more serious penalties.
- The absence of laws could lead to chaos, anarchy, and the dominance of the strongest.
- Laws create order, promoting peaceful living in society.
Roles of Laws: Establishing Boundaries, Protection, Freedom, and Resolving Disputes
- Establishing boundaries: Laws determine acceptable behavior and actions, such as drink-driving laws.
- Protection: Laws provide safety for individuals by limiting actions like assault, murder, and robbery.
- Freedom to do many things: Laws dictate what individuals can do, such as owning a business, driving a car, getting married, or leaving school.
- Resolving disputes: Law enforcement and administration are provided by the police force, court system, and correctional centres.
- Balance: Too many laws restrict freedoms, while too few laws lead to chaos and unhappiness.
Values, Morals, and Ethics
- Moral and ethical values shape our understanding of right and wrong.
- Examples include the seriousness of crimes like murder, reflecting religious beliefs and attitudes.
- Australia’s laws vary significantly from other countries, such as compulsory bicycle helmet wearing and strict anti-smoking legislation.
- Singapore’s laws, like importing chewing gum and failing to flush a public toilet, are unique to Australia.
Australia’s Court System Overview
- Court hierarchy: Minor rules are decided by teachers, serious offenses by Year coordinator or deputy principal, and very serious offences by the principal.
- Higher courts: Hear the most serious matters, higher courts handle less serious matters.
- Lower courts: Hear less serious matters, lower courts handle less serious matters.
- Courts become experts in specific areas of law.
- Trial costs increase if trial is held in a higher-up court.
- Laws: Society has rules that everyone is expected to obey, such as traffic laws and alcohol laws.
- Difference between rules and laws: Laws carry more serious penalties, and breaking a law may lead to court proceedings.
- Reasons for laws: Without laws, chaos could occur, and in extreme cases, anarchy could develop.
- Laws create order, allowing peaceful living.
Roles of Laws: Establishing Boundaries, Protection, Freedom, and Resolving Disputes
- Establishing boundaries: Laws determine acceptable behavior and actions, such as drink-driving laws.
- Protection: Laws provide safety for individuals by limiting actions like assault, murder, and robbery.
- Freedom to do many things: Laws dictate what individuals can do, such as owning a business, driving a car, getting married, or leaving school.
- Resolving disputes: Law enforcement and administration are provided by the police force, court system, and correctional centres.
- Balance: Too many laws restrict freedoms, while too few laws lead to chaos and unhappiness.
District Court Overview
* The’middle court’ in the state legal system, located in Sydney and regional centres.
* Handles serious civil cases for claims over $100,000 to $750,000 and all motor vehicle accident cases.
* Criminal jurisdiction includes serious criminal matters like armed robbery and manslaughter.
* Hears appeals from the Local Court.
Supreme Court Overview
* The highest court in NSW, dealing with most serious criminal cases and civil cases involving over $750,000.
* Headed by the Chief Justice, located in Sydney.
* Judges hold sessions in major regional centres, known as ‘going on circuit’.
* Deals with appeals from the two lower courts.
* Judgments of the Supreme Court are binding on all lower courts.
High Court of Australia Overview
* Located in Canberra, handles appeals from state or territory Supreme Courts.
* Interprets and applies the Constitution, creating laws that affect the powers of parliaments.
* Shifts power balance from states to Commonwealth through its interpretation of the Constitution.
* Decisions are final as it is the highest court in Australia.
* Comprises seven judges: the Chief Justice and six Justices.
* Most important cases are determined by a full bench, while others are handled by at least two justices.
* No jury is used in the High Court.
Children’s Court
* Deals with cases involving the care and protection of children and young people.
* Closed to the public and media, with personnel specifically trained to deal with young people.
Coroner’s Court in NSW
* Investigates unnatural deaths to determine identity, date, place, circumstances, and medical cause.
* Investigates approximately 6000 reportable deaths annually.
* Investigates cause and origin of fires or explosions.
Family Court of Australia
* Assists in resolving complex family law matters like divorce, parenting disputes, and property division.
* Only grounds for divorce are irretrievably broken marriages.
The Drug Court of NSW
* Provides long-term solutions for offenders involved in drug use and crime cycles.
* Encourages substance abuse, employment, and reduced crime to support drug habit.
* Eligibility for the Drug Court Program requires assessment and detoxification, individualized plan creation, and regular drug tests.
Roles of Laws: Establishing Boundaries, Protection, Freedom, and Resolving Disputes
- Establishing boundaries: Laws determine acceptable behavior and actions, such as drink-driving laws.
- Protection: Laws provide safety for individuals by limiting actions like assault, murder, and robbery.
- Freedom to do many things: Laws dictate what individuals can do, such as owning a business, driving a car, getting married, or leaving school.
- Resolving disputes: Law enforcement and administration are provided by the police force, court system, and correctional centres.
- Balance: Too many laws restrict freedoms, while too few laws lead to chaos and unhappiness.
Roles of Court Personnel in Australia
Magistrate as Umpire
* In Australia, a magistrate is the lowest court, responsible for deciding if a person is guilty or innocent.
* The magistrate is a qualified legal practitioner and is referred to as ‘Your Honor’.
* The magistrate decides the punishment or damages awarded in civil cases.
Judge as Umpire
* The judge’s associate manages the paperwork.
* Members of the public and media observe court proceedings.
* Sheriff’s Officers serve summonses and provide security.
Accused
* Anyone whose name is on the electoral roll can be called as a juror.
* In a criminal case, the jury consists of 12 people.
* In a civil matter, only six people decide how much money should be paid for damages.
Court Officer
* In criminal cases, the counsel for the defense represents the accused.
* In civil cases, the counsel for the defense attempts to convince the judge or jury that no wrong has been committed.
Prosecutor
* In criminal cases, the prosecutor convinces the jury that a person is guilty.
* In civil cases, a barrister acts on behalf of the plaintiff.
Witness Box
* The witness box is where people give evidence.
* The tipstaff helps keep order in the court.
* The judge listens to arguments presented by the prosecutor and the counsel for the defense.
* If a jury announces a guilty verdict, the judge decides the sentence or punishment.
Role and Selection of Juries
- Juries are used in less than 5% of all legal cases, but they are often the most intriguing aspect of the law.
- Jurors are made up of ordinary people who decide on the facts of the case.
- Jurors must be able to listen to all the facts of the evidence, decide what they believe happened according to the evidence, put aside their own prejudices or bias, be fair and impartial, understand points of law the judge explains, and deliver a verdict on the guilt or innocence of the accused in a criminal trial or decide if a party is liable in a civil trial.
- Some people can be exempt from jury duty because of their occupation, financial hardship, personal opinions or knowledge of the case, family issues, or physical or mental disabilities.
- Having a criminal record could also make one ineligible for jury duty.
Jury Duty and Sleeping Habits
- Jury duty can be a source of distraction, leading to potential errors.
- An assault trial was aborted due to a juror’s sleepiness, causing concerns about the jury’s ability to give a proper verdict.
- A similar incident occurred in the NSW Supreme Court, where a juror was discharged after falling asleep in the jury box.
- Empanelling a jury involves selecting potential jurors, who must walk past the accused, their counsel, and the prosecution.
- Arguments for and against the jury system exist, with some arguing for the use of judge-only trials or professional, specialist jurors.
Arguments for and Against Jury System
* Jury system reflects societal values and attitudes.
* Exemptions from serving make it a non-true cross-section of society.
* Wide acceptance of jury system.
* Jury decisions are made by multiple individuals.
* Juries are independent, impartial decision makers not controlled by the government.
* Jury skills can influence decisions.
* Ordinary citizens can actively participate in justice administration.
* Media coverage can influence impartiality.
* Community understanding of final decision provided.
* Operation costs and time-consuming jury selection process.
* Reduces potential for bribery or corruption.
* Jurors could be biased due to personal prejudices.
Law Making: Common Law
Beginnings of Common Law
* Laws can be written down or developed by judges as they encounter new problems in cases.
* In Australia, common law is a combination of both common and statute law.
Trial by Ordeal
* The justice system in England and Australia is based on common law.
* Henry II’s decision to allow all people to have the opportunity for royal justice led to the creation of a king’s court.
Common Law
* Common law refers to the decisions made by judges, often in cases where there is no existing law.
* Legal precedents are records of these decisions, which are referred to in Law Reports.
Precedent in Law
* Precedent in law refers to the same treatment of similar cases as in the legal system.
* Judges can create new rules if there is no existing relevant law.
The Evolution of Parliamentary Laws in Australia
The Origins of Parliament
* The parliamentary system originated in England in 1215 with King John signing the Magna Carta.
* Parliaments were first referred to as ‘parliaments’ in 1236, usually held to discuss the king’s need for extra taxes.
* By 1350, parliaments were divided into two groups: lords and elected community members.
* In 1407, Henry IV decided that community members had to approve requests for grants of money before the lords.
Statute Law in Australia
* In Australia, laws created by parliament have the highest status and must be obeyed by all people.
* The Federal or Commonwealth Parliament in Canberra makes laws on issues affecting the whole country.
* Each state and territory has its own parliament.
* The New South Wales Parliament makes laws applicable to New South Wales only.
* The State Parliament delegates some of its law-making power to local councils.
* Once passed, each law is binding on all courts and judges.
Federal and State Constitutions
* Each parliament has a constitution outlining the powers of the parliament and any restrictions to its law-making authority.
* The Australian Constitution limits the powers of the Federal Parliament.
* State governments retain the power to make laws unless the Constitution hands this power to the Australian government.
* Inconsistencies between Commonwealth and state legislation will apply if there are any inconsistencies.
Arguments for and Against Jury System
* Jury system reflects societal values and attitudes.
* Exemptions from serving make it a non-true cross-section of society.
* Wide acceptance of jury system.
* Jury decisions are made by multiple individuals.
* Juries are independent, impartial decision makers not controlled by the government.
* Jury skills can influence decisions.
* Ordinary citizens can actively participate in justice administration.
* Media coverage can influence impartiality.
* Community understanding of final decision provided.
* Operation costs and time-consuming jury selection process.
* Reduces potential for bribery or corruption.
* Jurors could be biased due to personal prejudices.
Common Law: An Overview
The Beginnings of Common Law
* Laws can be written down or developed by judges as they encounter new problems in cases.
* In Australia, common law is a combination of both common and statute law.
* The justice system in England and Australia is based on common law.
Common Law Today
* Common law refers to the decisions made by judges, often in cases where there is no existing law.
* Legal precedents are records of these decisions, which are referred to in Law Reports.
* Judges do not deliberately attempt to change or make a law, but may attempt to resolve the dispute.
Precedent in Law
* Precedent in law refers to the same treatment in similar cases, aiming for fairness and justice.
* Judges traditionally give similar decisions in similar cases.
Statutory Interpretation
* Judges interpret the meaning of words in statutes using various methods.
* Parliament can change the wording of a law, but the new meaning applies as law from then on.