Typologies Flashcards
What are typlogies?
Different religious organisations someone might belong to/believe in.
What are the 4 broad types of religious organisations throughout the world? (a.k.a 4 fold typology)
- The Church
- The Denomination
- The Sect
- The Cult / New Age Movement
Which religions are called ‘Churches’ by sociologists?
Christianity Islam Buddhism Judaism Hinduism Sikhism
What do the 6 world religions have in common?
- a holy text or texts
- places of worship / pilgrimage
- a leadership structure
- moral/ethical codes
Who identified the 7 key characteristics of a Church?
First undertaken by Weber then developed by Troeltsch
What are the 7 key characteristics of a Church?
- large, formal organisation
- a hierarchy of paid officials
- automatic recruitment
- tries to appeal to all members of society
- may have a close relationship with the state
- accepts wider society
- claims a monopoly of truth
How does Hinduism and Buddhism differ from Christianity, Islam, Sikhism and Judaism?
Hinduism is polytheistic and Buddhists don’t necessarily believe in God.
However the others are monotheistic.
Give 2 criticisms of Troeltsch’s typology (THE CHURCH)
- Doesn’t include the wide variety of religious groups present in modern societies.
- His classification of religious organisations was mainly limited to churches and sects due to his focus on 16th-century Europe.
Give a strength of Troeltsch’s typology
Although his definition was based on Western Christian organisations, it is still applicable to other societies and national faiths. E.g. in Iran there is a close relationship between the state and Islam.
What are denominations?
Denominations are generally Christian organisations that have left the Church of England, which itself split from the Catholic Church when Henry VIII wanted a divorce. They aren’t very different to the Church of England and have generally the same beliefs.
Give examples of denominations
The Methodist Church, Baptist Church and Quakers
Who provided the first analysis of denominations and what did they say?
Neibuhr - said they developed from sects that had originated as breakaway groups from the main church.
According to Neibuhr, which characteristics do denominations share with the church?
- large, formal organisations
- hierarchy of paid officials
- tries to appeal to all members of society
According to Neibuhr, how do denominations differ from the church?
- no claim to a monopoly of religious truth
- accept religious diversity
- no close relationship with the state
- may not fully accept wider society
How does Bruce evaluate denominations?
- argues that both churches and sects have drifted towards the characteristics of a denomination. Churches can no longer claim a monopoly and are no longer universal; therefore they are increasingly like denominations.
- groups such as Jehova Witnesses and Pentecostalists which used to be regarded as sects now tend to be seen as denomination!
What are sects?
Small religious organisations that demand high levels of commitment.
What are the different types of sect?
Established Sects
Short-lived/criminal/deviant Sects
Describe established sects and give examples
More established/not criminal or killer/ not suicidal/ less deviant. These don’t have a single leader and have been around much longer than the first type.
e.g. Jehova’s Witness, Seventh Day Adventists, Moonies, the Amish, Hare Krishna’s
You can be in these and still live in the ‘real’ world, apart from the Amish.
Describe deviant sects and give examples
They all have, or had, a single charismatic male leader and live away from society in compounds/remote estates.
E.g. Jonestown, Heaven’s Gate, Branch Davidians, Aum
Identify the 6 key characteristics of a sect
- small organisation, with no professional hierarchy
- headed by a charismatic leader
- exclusive membership
- no automatic recruitment
- requires total commitment of members
- opposed to the state and wider society
What do sects and churches have in common?
Both claim a monopoly of religious truth
Why are sects opposed to the state and wider society?
Sects draw membership from the lower classes, who may feel marginalised by society. Members are required to demonstrate their complete commitment to the sect, which often means withdrawal from society. This means the sect and charismatic leader enjoy a great deal of control over members.