Turning points: Wave Particle Duality Flashcards
What did Newton do in 1672?
- Published paper reporting experiments using glass prism to split light into colour spectrum
- Continuous colour spectrum into red, orange, yellow, green, blue, indigo violet
- Proposed that colour is a property of light and that white light is a mixture of all different colours
- Implied that light made up of particles
What did Robert Hooke suggest in 1672?
- Reported on experiments with diffraction
- Suggested on a wave theory of light could account for his results
What did Huygens hypothesise in 1678?
- He hypothesises that light was a longitudinal wave that propagated through an ‘ether; an invisible medium, which pervaded all space including a vacuum
- He produces a geometrical construction that allowed a given future wave front to be located if its present position was known (the wave front is the line or survive on which a wave disturbance has the same phase at all points)
What does Huygen’s principle state?
- All points on a wave front serve as point sources of spherical secondary wavelets that spread out in the forward direction at the speed of the wave
- The new wave front position is the surface that is tangential to all of these secondary wavelets
What could Huygen’s wave theory account for?
- The laws of reflection and refraction
- Also suggested that light slowed down when entering a denser medium
What could his wave theory predict?
- The wave theory could correctly reduced the diffraction of light through a narrow slot
- But did not explain why light formed sharp shadows when passing everyday objects whereas water wave and sound waves clearly diffraction around objects
What did Newton do in 1704?
- Published ‘Optiks’
- Theory of light in which light is composed of tiny weightless particles that travelled in straight line from the sources
- Particles called ‘corpuscles’ and his corpuscular theory
What did the corpuscular theory do?
- Account for the formation of sharp shadows when an opaque object intercepted a beam of sunlight, stating that sharp shadows were formed because the corpuscles that hit the object were stopped
- Concluded that corpuscles of light were colours and that different colours moved through a glass prisms at different speeds but could be made to recombine by a second prisms and appear white
How did Fizeau in 1849 determine the speed of light?
- Shone a light beam at a partially reflecting mirror, which directed the beam between the teeth of a rotating toothed wheel towards a distant mirror several km away
- The distant mirror reflected the be a back towards the wheel and the observer
- Used a clockwork mechanism with a series of gears to rotate the toothed wheel so that he was able to determine the wheel’s frequency of rotation
What happened when the toothed wheel was stationary?
-The light beam passed through a gap in the wheel’s teeth was incident in the distant mirror M and was reflected back, passing through the same gap between the teeth, enabling him to observe continuous light
What happened when he rotated the toothed wheel?
- The teeth broke up the light beam into pulses and flashes of light were observed
- When he continued to increase the frequency of rotation of the wheel, a speed was reached at which the pulse of light leaving through one gap retuned to the wheel at the instant that the next tooth blocked its passes through the wheel
- At this speed, he was no longer able to see nay light pulses returning from the mirror
How did he mathematically show the speed of light?
- Suppose there are N teeth and therefore N gaps equally spaced on the wheel
- The time t for the wheel to turn through a distance equal to the width of one tooth is given by t=T/2N
where T is the time for the wheel to complete one rotation - Since frequency of rotation of the wheel, f is given by f=1/T then t can be written as
t=1/2Nf - Since the light travels a distance 2D in time t the speed of light c is given by
c=2D/t - Where D is the distance from the wheel to the distant mirror and therefore:
c=4DNf
What did Newton propose?
- Light was formed from corpuscles that were continuously given out in all directions by luminous objects
- One consequence was that luminous objects should be constantly losing mass
- Could explain reflection, refraction and dispersion
How could the corpuscular theory explain reflection?
- Treated light as solid elastic ball
1. Change in velocity as ball bounces, and as ball hits surface its vertical component of velocity is reversed but the hormonal component remains unchanged
2. Ball reflected at same angle at which hit surface
3. The change in the vertical component of velocity means that the law of reflection can be explained
4. The angle of incidence is equal to the angle of reflection
How could the corpuscular theory explain refraction?
- Assumed force of attraction between matter and light
- When light corpuscles were in the middle of air or a transparent medium such as glass or water the forces acting on the corpuscles aged on all sides of them and there was no resultant force
- But when boundary between air and a medium forces were unbalances and greater force of attraction on the corpuscle
- Therefore vertical component of velocity increased
- Horizontal component not altered as were equal numbers of air and medium particles on either side so the horizontal forces were still balanced
What did the change in the vertical component explain in refraction?
- Explained why light ray changed direction towards the normal on entering the medium
- Could also explain the increase in the angle of the light when leaving the medium
What did corpuscular theory require?
-The speed of light to be faster in a medium than in air
How could corpuscular theory explain dispersion?
- Dispersion occurs when different colours of light are refracted by different amounts as they travel through a medium
- Newton explain by assuming different coloured light corpuscles had different mass, with red being most massive
- So velocities affecting slightly differently when entering the material (red least affected so change direction least)
What was Huygen’s wave theory of light?
- Proposed light was a longitudinal wave similar to sound
- Longitudinal waves require a medium to travel through
- Proposed space filled with substance called æther which was transparent and had no inertia (or mass)
- Could be used to explain reflection and refraction of light
How do waves travel?
- Waves travelled though different material by the propagation of wave fronts
- Each point on the wavefront acts as a new point source and wavelets spread out from them
- These wavelets then combined to form a new wavefront
How did Huygen’s wave theory of light explain reflection?
- When a wavefront was incident on a reflective surface, the point at which the wavefront is reflected acts as a secondary source and new wavelets are formed
- NOTES
How did Huygen’s wave theory of light explain refraction?
- As wavefront reaches the boundary it acts as a secondary source of waves
- The wavefront is travelling at an angle to the boundary so it takes the wavefront a finite amount of time to pass over the boundary
- The wavelets formed as each point of the wave is incident on the boundary spread out in the medium and from a new wavefront inside the material
- Predicted the speed of light would be slower inside a medium compared with air
What could Newton’s corpuscular theory explain?
reflection, refraction, dispersion
What could Newton’s corpuscular theory not explain?
diffraction, interference, polarisation
What could Huygen’s wave theory of light explain?
reflection, refraction, (dispersion) , diffraction, interference
What could Huygen’s wave theory of light not explain?
polarisation
Why could neither theory be confirmed?
- No way to test evidence of æther
- No way to test speed of light at time
What did Young find that the spacing of the fringes depend on?
- Separation of the double slits
- Distance from the double slits to the screen
- The colour (wavelength) of the light
What was Huygen’s theory accepted over Newton’s?
- Corpuscular theory could not explain interference pattern
- Corpuscular would go through each slight and only tow bright finger would be seen
What else meant that Huygen’s theory was accepted over Newton’s
- Fresnel and Arago, realised that light was transverse not longitudinal then could explain polarisation
- Wave theory of light finally widely accepted
What was the set up of Fizeau’s speed of light experiment?
- Lens L1, light from a source focused onto edge of toothed wheel with 720 teeth
- Wheel had regular notches cut into circumference
- Light shone through one of the gaps on the edge of the wheel and passed through another lens L2, to form parallel beam of light
- Light then travelled into another lens, L3, where it was focused onto a curved mirror, M and reflected back towards L2 and through toothed wheel
- Light them observed using eyepiece E
What was the scale of F’s experiment?
Two ends of experiment 8km apart and light source travelled over 16km
In what way was Fizeau’s speed of light experiment set up?
- Light correctly focused and could be seen on eyepiece
- Wheel rotated and speed of rotation increased
- Intensity of light seen in eyepiece varied
What was the light intensity and maximum or minimum?
- Minimum: when gap had moved and a tooth in its place
- Max: when returning light passed through a gap