Trusts Flashcards
Trust
Legal relationship in which the holder of a right gives it to another person or entity who must keep and use it solely for another’s benefit
How did trusts begin?
O “to T for the use of B” enforced by the Chancellor
After 1535, operated on the use and eliminated the legal owner component, but some courts ignored it therefore creating a TRUST
Foreign law on trusts
A number of countries that did not
have trusts for wealth transfer have added them to their
law
These statutes might not have the same requirements
that we have in the USA
Voluntary trust
For creating wealth, business trusts (alternative to corporate form used to create monopolies before anti-trust laws)
For sharing/trasnferring wealth and for protecting those who might bot manage it well
Testamentary, intervivos, revocable, and irrevocable
Involuntary trusts
Constructive trust imposed for fairness
What does it take to make a trust? (8)
1) Capacity to make a transfer in the trust (varies on trust type)
2) Intent to create trust (UI, mistake, coercion, and fraud can negate)
3) Manifestation of intent
4) A res
5) A definite beneficiary (non-charitable)
6) A trustee
7) Active duty for the trustee to perform
8) Writing (sometimes)
Capacity to make a testamentary trust?
Capacity needed to execute a will
Capacity needed to make an inter vivos trust?
Capacity to execute a deed/make a gift
Capacity to make a revocable trust?
Uniform Trust Code: capacity to execute a will
In re Estate of Maliszewski
No special magic words are needed to create a trust
Res
Property in the trust that needs to be identified with reasonable certainty
Must have a pre-existing legal right for the res to work
Brainard v. Commissioner
Profits from FUTURE trading of specified stocks CANNOT be the res of a trust
Speelman v. Pascal
Gift of profits of My Fair Lady is not a res - this is just a gift of a legal right
Charitable trusts: definite beneficiary
No definite beneficiary is needed
Noncharitable trust: definite beneficiary
Someone capable of holding title
Can a dog be a definite beneficiary?
Common law: no
UTC 408: Yes for those animals alive during the life of the settlor
UPC 2-907: trusts for pets are allowed
What attributes must a definite beneficiary have?
1) Someone capable of holding title
2) Hold the trustee accountable
3) Different from the trstee
Grantor Trust
If the beneficiary is the grantor
Income tax is payable to the grantor
Trustee
Legal title holder
Can be the settlor or another person
Trustee
Legal title holder
Can be the settlor or another person
Does the trust fail if no trustee is listed?
No - most courts will appoint one in nearly all cases
Active duty for a trustee to perform
A trust WILL FAIL if this does not exist
Allows the trust to take advantage of the active-duties expectations created by the Statute of Uses
Passive (Dry) Trust
Trust where the trustee has no active duty to perform
Estate of Heggstad
Decedent/testator/settlor named himself and his son a trustee of a trust, then he was married to Nancy (who takes 1/3 of his estate as a pretermitted spouse)
The process for transferring property to the settlor as trustee is more informal because the settlor already owns full title to that property
T/C belongs in the TRUST
Does a testamentary will require a writing?
Yes
Does an intervivos trust to a 3rd party require a writing?
Personalty: no
Realty: deed is needed
Does an intervivos trust to the settlor as a trustee need a writing
Personalty: oral declaraction is fine (not a good idea, though)
Realty: Some jurisdiction are under SoF, signed by the grantor / UTC 401: oral is fine
Closest trust to a will?
Revocable trust (testamentary in nature, ambulatory)
DO NOT COMPLY WITH THE WILLS ACT
Does an intervivos trust to the settlor as a trustee need a writing
Personalty: oral declaration is fine (not a good idea, though)
Realty: Some jurisdiction are under SoF, signed by the grantor / UTC 401: oral is fine
Scalfaro
If there is more than one settlor, need to make sure there is clarity on who can revoke and when
Revocable trusts: revocation + amendments (traditional rule)
Right to revoke/amend had to be retained in the trust instrument and settlor had to follow the specified method