Trusts Flashcards
Definition of Trust
a trust is a legal arrangement where a settlor conveys property to a trustee to hold as a fiduciary for one or more beneficiaries
Trust law that applies
a) Testamentary trust: domicile
b) Inter vivos: nexus with a state
parties to a trust
1) Settlor – creator
2) Trustee – hold legal title, fiduciary duties, active role, functions
3) Beneficiary – benefit of property / trust. Hold equitable title to trust property
Third party rights
trustee and beneficiary
a) A trustee is both the trustee and an individual
(i) If sued in capacity as trustee
* Claim on trust propertypay from trust property
(ii) If sued in capacity as individual
* Claim on individual cannot touch trust property
* Pay from individual property
b) Beneficiary can sue trustee for breach of trust duty and distributions
trustee functions
4
custodial
administrative
distributive
investment
custodain function
taking the property and safeguarding it
administrative function
record keeping, paying taxes, accounting, filings
investment function
reviewing trust assets, prudent investment program reasonable in the circumstances
prudent man crap
distribution function
disbursement of income or principal to beneficiaries as outlined in trust terms
creating trust
5-6
parties
capacity of settlor and trustee
intent by settlor to create
ascertainable beneficiaries to enforce trust
specific property to be held in trust
sometimes - writing
trust party triangle
- Settlor gives property up for benefit of B – donative or commercial transfer
- Trustee receives property and has fiduciary duties attaches / distribute to B
- B has right to sue T and hold him accountable and gets benefit
title split in trust
legal title and burden to trustee
equitable title and benefit to beneficiary
intent to create issues
- Issue of precatory language: not clear direction of what intent is. Use strong direct language
- “Trust” is not needed to create
ascertainable benficiary rule
trust must have one or more ascertainable beneficiaries to whom the trustee owes fiduciary duties and who can call the trustee to account
UTC a trust is created only if trust has a definite beneficiary unless
a. Charitable trust
b. Trust for care of animal
c. Or trust for a noncharitable purpose in Sec409
indefinite benficiary rule
C/l v. UTC
- In general: must be an ascertainable beneficiary within RAP
- If indefinite class
a. Traditional rule: trust fails “my friends”
b. UTC 402 modern rule
i. Allows trustee to define from an indefinite class if done so in a reasonable time
ii. Allows trustee to appoint friends
iii. If not a reasonable time property passes as if trust not created. Will or intestate
rule against perpeuities issue
ask: can know who the beneficiary is within 21 years?
- beneficiaries need not be ascertained when the trust is created– they just must be ascertainable within the period of applicable rules against perpetuities
- RAP: no interest in land is good unless it must vest, if at all, not later than twenty-one years after some life in being at the creation of the interest.
1. If everyone alive at time of creation of trust instrument and dies, then we wait 21 years and don’t know who takes - the trust dissolves
2. If everyone alive at time of creation of trust instrument and dies, then we wait 21 years and we do know who goes to - the trust stands
charitable trust - no RAP
specific property to be held in trust
- Must identify specific property (res) to be held
1. Unless it is a pour over will where residue forms trust – catch all property - Property generally must be in existence at time of creation and ascertainable
- Trust arises when the res is delivered and attained/accepted by trustee
writing for a trust
(optional) - can be oral if CC
* Writing is required if the trust is testamentary or the property is land
1. Wills act purpose and statute of frauds reqs. (Deed to land)
declaration of trust
when settlor declares himself to be trustee of certain property or beneficiary. Trustee must owe fiduciary duties to someone other than herself.
(i) Incomplete delivery alone doesn’t turn a gift into a trust
categories of trusts
9
private
charitable
business
oral
statutory purpose
honorary trust
pour over
constructive
sham
private trust generally
purpose, modfification, enforcement
(i) Purpose: by a person for the benefit of an ascertainable individual
(ii) Subject to the rule against perpetuities
(iii) Modification: claflin, equitable deviation, decanting
(iv) Beneficiaries enforces
charitable trust generally
purpose, modification, enforcement
(i) Purpose: by an individual for the benefit of the public good
(ii) May exist in perpetuity – no RAP rule
(iii) Modification: cy pres, deviation
(iv) No RAP
(v) AG enforces
oral trust reqs
a trust need not be evidenced by a trust instrument, but the creation of an oral trust and its terms may be established only by clear and convincing evidence.
a) Fear of fraud so C&C req.
NEVER testamentary or land
semisecret trust
no beneficiary designated
* Intent to create trust appears on face of will
* Terms are unstated
* Extrinsic evidence not needed to prevent unjust enrichment of trustee
* Trust is invalid not enforceable
secret trust
will doesn’t indicate trust
* Devise is absolute on face, but nothing in will saying create a trust. Based on understanding
* Extrinsic necessary to prevent unjust enrichment of promisor or trustee
* Court will impose constructive trust on trustee-promisor
semisecret and secret trust
secret used to be enforceable through constructive trust
(i) Defining: there is intent to create a trust but not put in public view restatement says that it doesn’t matter if secret and semisecret trust if don’t give as intended then unjustly enriched to donee. Secret trustee unjustly enriched in the secret. Decedent’s remaining heirs in semi-secret are unjustly enriched.
(ii) Restatement now: collapse distinction; both are an unjust enrichment to the donee.
honorary trust (pets)
elements
(i) Intent
(ii) Non capricious
(iii) Specific
(iv) No beneficiary to enforce so the court will impose an honor trust on the trustee
* Binds the conscience of the trustee because no beneficiary to enforce the trust
(v) Transferee is not obligated to carry out the settlor’s purpose
(vi) If transferee declines, she holds the property on resulting trust and property reverts to settlor or settlors’ successors
statutory purpose trust
(i) Statutory trust for pet animal or other noncharitable purpose
(ii) Authorizes the court to
* reduce excessive trust property if capricious for intended use and
* provide for enforcement by settlor or court appointee / appoint one to enforce the trust
pour over trust
created from residue of estate; irrevocable
in writing
sham trust
when trust has settlor as trustee and only beneficiary, can’t do, not accountable to anyone
nature of trust
revocabily v irrevocability
revocable trust: creation of
a) Creation of intervivos trust
(i) Presumptively revocable unless terms provide otherwise or in a will
(ii) Created by declaration of trust or **deed of trust **
(iii) Transfer is non-probate –will substitute
* substitutes for conveying property at death outside of probate
* Can be oral, spendthrift but not SPAT
revocable trust: amending or revoking
CL v. UTC
(i) Settlor retains power to amend or revoke at anytime
(ii) Common law rule: must revoke in the way outlined by terms of the trust
(iii) UTC ways to revoke
* By substantial compliance with method provided in terms of trust OR
- If terms not expressly exclusive or no terms:
1. Later codicil or will expressly referring to trust OR devises property that would otherwise pass in terms of trust
2. Any other method expressing C&C of settlor intent - Problems: make sure trustee knows about revocation! Trustee will deliver property after revoke
revocable trust: subsidiary law of wills
restatment rule and creditors rights
(i) Restatement: although need not have formalities of a will, to the extent appropriate a will **substitute should be subject to substantive restrictions on testation and rules of construction **
* Spousal shares, construction reading of wills, slayer rules, divorce, creditors rights, abatement and ademption
(ii) Creditors: can reach into trust to reach funds if revocable intervivos trust – settlor could’ve paid then so can pay now. Settlors right to revoke trust is regarded as equivalent to ownership. Not protected.
* Cannot reach things settlor could not reach during life: life insurance, retirement, joint property
revocable trust: creditors rights
(ii) Creditors: can reach into trust to reach funds if revocable intervivos trust – settlor could’ve paid then so can pay now. Settlors right to revoke trust is regarded as equivalent to ownership. Not protected.
* Cannot reach things settlor could not reach during life: life insurance, retirement, joint property