Transfer Pricing Flashcards
Associated Enterprise (92A)
Two or more enterprises are associated enterprises, if:
1. One enterprise holds 26% or more VP in other enterprise
2. Any person holds 26% or more VP in each of the two enterprises
3. Loan advanced by one enterprise constitutes 51% or more of Book Value of Total Assets of the other enterprise.
4. One enterprise guarantees 10% or more of the Total Borrowings of the other enterprise
5. One enterprise appoints more than half of the Board of Directors or at least one executive director in the other enterprise
6. Any person appoints more than half of the BOD or at least one Executive Director in each of the two enterprises
7. If one person controls one enterprise, the same person, or his relative, or jointly with his relative, controls the other enterprise
8. If one enterprise is controlled by an HUF, the other enterprise is controlled by a member or the relative of a member of the HUF
9. If one enterprise is a firm/AOP/BOI, the other enterprise holds at least 10% profit sharing ratio in such enterprise
10. The manufacturing or processing of one enterprise is wholly dependent upon the intangible asset of another enterprise
11. 90% or more of the raw material or consumables is supplied by other enterprise and the price and terms are decided by such other enterprise
12. One enterprise sells its manufactured goods to other enterprise at price and terms decided by such other enterprise
13. There exists any relationship of mutual interest between two enterprise
Sec 92A
Associated Enterprise
Sec 92B
International Transaction
Sec 92C
Arm’s Length Price
International Transaction
Transaction b/w 2 AEs where at least 1 is a Non Resident
Nature of Transaction for International Transactions
- Purchase, Sale or Lease of Property (eg. buying space for cafe)
- Provision of Service (supplying coffee)
- Lending or Borrowing money (selling coffee on credit)
- Allocation of Cost or Expense (splitting up amount of coffee and croissant in invoice)
- Any other transaction which affects profit
Deemed International Transaction
Transaction entered into with a third person (i.e. which is not an AE), AND a prior agreement exists b/w such third person and an AE of such enterprise.
(whether or not such 3rd person is an AE)
Methods for determining ALP
5 methods:
1. Comparable Uncontrolled Price Method (CUP)
2. Resale Price Method
3. Cost Plus Method
4. Profit Split Method
5. Transactional Net Margin Method
CUP Method
Comparing transaction with AE to a similar uncontrolled transaction.
Calculation:
Price charged/paid in uncontrolled trn +/- functional differences (FOB/CIF, warranty, quantity discount)
Resale Price Method
When goods purchased from AE and resold as is to outsider.
Calculation:
Resale price to outsider (-) Normal GP Margin (-) Additional Purchase Related Expenses
Cost Plus Method
Goods mfgd by Enterprise is sold to AE.
Calculation:
Direct & Indirect Cost of Production + Normal GP margin +/- Functional differences (technical support, quantity discount, credit period)
Profit Split Method
Used in Joint Ventures.
Calculation:
Cost incurred + Net Profit Share
Transactional Net Margin Method
Operating Profit Margin of other enterprise in similar industry shall be taken
Calculation:
Cost incurred + Operating Profit Mgn of other enterprise of similar industry
Arithmetic Mean Concept for determining ALP
If the most appropriate method gives more than 1 but less than 6 (ie upto 5) ALPs, use arithmetic mean i.e. average to choose the ALP.
If the difference between the Actual Transaction Price and Average ALP is upto 3% of the Average ALP, the Actual Transaction Price is considered to be ALP and no adjustment is required. If difference is more than 3% of the ALP, then the average ALP is considered as the ALP and according adjustment is made
Range Concept
NOT APPLICABLE IN CASE OF PROFIT SPLIT METHOD
> Applicable if the most appropriate method gives 6 or more ALPs.
1. Arrange all the ALPs in ascending order.
2. Calculate total number of values.
3. Calculate 35% and 65% of such total number of values. (if 35% and 65% results in decimal answer, ROUND IT UP eg. 2.44 and 2.65 both become 3 and take the corresponding value accordingly, but if it gives a whole number, ie not in decimals, then take the average of the value corresponding to such whole number and the value immediately succeeding it.)
4. Range of ALP is the value corresponding to such 35% and 65% place.
5. If the Actual Transaction Price falls within such range, no adjustment is required.
6. If the Actual Transaction Price does not fall within the range, then take the median, i.e. 50% of the total number of values, and the ALP is the value at the median place . (if 50% gives whole number, i.e. not in decimals, take the average of the value corresponding to the median place and immediately succeeding it.)