Transactions Requiring Shareholder Approval Flashcards
what transactions require prior shareholder approval?
- directors’ long term service contracts
- substantial property transactions
- loans and related transactions with directors
what voting threshold is needed to approve:
- long-term service contracts
- substantial property transactions
- loans etc to directors?
ordinary resolution
when is approval for LTSC, substantial property transactions, and loans etc. NOT required?
where a wholly owned subsidiary is making this arrangement for its own director = its single parent holding company does not need to approve the transaction
what should be done in this situation?
Y is the holding company of X. B is a director of Y.
X wants to contract with B for either:
- a long-term service contract
- substantial property transactions (eg. buy from B)
- loan/quasi-loan/credit transactions
the shareholders of Y must approve the arrangement by ordinary resolution not the shareholders of X (which is Y)
ths is because such transactions between a company and directors of its holding company requrie the approval of the shareholders of that holding company (not only the holding company itself)
What is a long-term service contract?
a contract of employment of a director with a guaranteed period of MORE THAN 2 YEARS
this includes where:
- the fixed contractual period is more than 2 years
- the fixed contractual period is less than 2 years but directors have the sole discretion to renew
- the notice period given by the company to terminate the contract guarantees a period of more than 2 years
what is the consequence of directors granting a long term service contract without shareholder approval?
- the provision on length will be void
- the contract will be deemed to contain a term entitling the company to terminate it at any time by the giving of reasonable notice.
and the directors will be in breach of their duty to act within their powers
when is shareholder approval needed for substantial property transactions?
for the acquisition or disposal of a substantial non-cash asset from or to the company by:
- a director of the company
- a director of the company’s holding company
- a person connected to the above directors
what is a substantial non-cash asset?
‘substantial’ =
- asset worth £5,000 or less is NOT substantial
- asset worth more than £100,000 is substantial
- asset is a substantial asset if it is worth more than £5,000 and worth more than 10% of the company’s net asset value based on its last accounts
who is a connected person for the purposes of a substantial property transaction and loans etc.?
- family (spouse, parent, children, stepchildren) but not brothers, sisters, grandparent, grandchild, uncles, aunts
- companies where director or a connected person hold 20% or more of shares
- business partner of director or of connected person
- trustees of a trust where director is a beneficiary
what is a:
- loan
- quasi loan
- credit transaction
- guarantee / security for the above?
- loan = company lends money to D or guarantees a loan given to D or gives a security for a loan given to D
- quasi loan = company pays a third party for D and D reimburses the company (or guarantees / securities in connection with this)
- credit transactions = company provides D with goods or services which D pays for later (or guarantees / securities in connection with this)
when is shareholder approval needed for loan/quasi-loan/credit transactions?
what are the exceptions?
SH approval by ordinary resolution is required for:
- loans to directors –> all companies
- loans to directors of holding companies –> all companies
- guarantee or security for a loan to a director or director of holding companies –> all companies
- any transaction involving connected persons –> public associated companies only
- quasi loans and securities/guarantees for anyone –> public associated companies only
- credit transactions and securities/guarantees for anyone –> public associated companies only
Exceptions:
- business expenditure max 50,000
- quasi loans up to 10,000
- loans up to 10,000
- credit transactions up to 15,000
- loans for defending proceedings
- wholly owned subsidiary exemption
public associated company = public company and company that is a parent/ subsidiary of a public company
when is SH approval needed (3) vs not needed (4) for loans?
SH approval needed for:
- loan / guarantee or security for a loan to director = all companies
- loan / guarantee or security for a loan to director of holding companies = all companies
- loan / guarantee or security for a loan to a connected person = only public and public associated companies
SH approval not needed for:
- loan / guarantee or security for a loan to connected person from a private company
- loans up to 10,000
- loans for defending proceedings
- business expenditure max 50,000
when is SH approval needed vs not needed for quasi loans or guarantees / securities given by company for quasi loans?
SH approval needed for:
- quasi loan to directors = by public and public associated companies
- quasi loans to directors of holding companies = by public and public associated companies
- quasi loans to persons connected to directors = by public and public associated companies
SH approval not needed for:
- quasi loans by private companies (to whoever)
- quasi loans of up to 10,000
when is SH approval needed vs not needed for credit transactions or guarantees / securities given by company for credit transactions?
SH approval needed for:
- credit transactions to directors = by public and public associated companies
- credit transactions to directors of holding companies = by public and public associated companies
- credit transactions to persons connected to directors = by public and public associated companies
SH approval not needed for:
- credit transactions by private companies (to whoever)
- credit transactions of up to 15,000
what are the options for shareholders if a company fails to get shareholder approval before entering a SPT or loans etc.? (4)
- transaction is VOIDABLE by the company - unless:
- restitution is no longer possible
- the company has been indemnified for its loss
- a third party acquired rights in good faith which would be affected by avoidance (e.g., lender granted security over it, someone else bought it)
- directors and connected persons involved are liable to:
- account to the company for profits made, and
- indemnify the company for loss it incurred (but if they indemnify then the transaction is not voidable)
- remedies for breach of directors duties
- affirm the transaction by ordinary resolution