TORTS - GEORGIA DISTINCTIONS BARBRI Flashcards
What is the Georgia rule regarding incapacity defenses in intentional torts?
Infancy is a defense in tort actions for children under age 13
This contrasts with the multistate rule where young children or mentally incompetent individuals cannot claim incapacity as a defense.
What is required to make a claim for trespass to chattels under Georgia law?
Actual damages are not required; nominal damages may be awarded
Unlike the multistate rule, which requires actual damages.
Under what circumstances can deadly force be used in defense of habitation in Georgia?
Deadly force may be used if:
* Entry is violent and poses a serious threat to an occupant
* Force is used against a non-household member unlawfully entering
* Entry is for the purpose of committing a felony
This is more permissive than the general rule allowing only reasonable force.
What is the minimum age for a child to be found negligent in Georgia?
A child under 13 has an absolute defense in negligence actions
This differs from the multistate rule where no fixed age is set.
What is Georgia’s rule regarding statutory violations and negligence per se?
Tort actions cannot be implied from the violation of a criminal statute enacted after July 1, 2010
The right to a civil action must be expressly stated in the statute.
What does Georgia’s Good Samaritan Statute entail?
Exempts from liability for ordinary negligence those who voluntarily render emergency treatment
This includes members of the public, not just medical professionals.
Can bystanders recover damages for emotional distress in Georgia?
No, unless there is direct physical impact on them or conduct directed toward them
Georgia does not permit recovery of mental distress damages even in the zone of danger.
How does Georgia apply the doctrine of res ipsa loquitur?
It applies only to ordinary negligence cases, not in medical malpractice cases
Medical services are presumed to be performed skillfully.
What is the maximum amount of punitive damages recoverable in Georgia?
$250,000 in most cases, except in specific circumstances
This includes exceptions for products liability and specific intent cases.
What is the rule regarding contributory negligence by children in Georgia?
No minimum age; whether a child can be found contributorily negligent depends on their mental and physical capabilities
Most cases hold that a child under six cannot be found contributorily negligent.
What type of comparative negligence system does Georgia follow?
Partial comparative negligence; a plaintiff cannot recover if they are 50% or more responsible
This differs from pure comparative negligence systems.
What are the requirements for the last clear chance doctrine in Georgia?
Defendant must have actual knowledge of the plaintiff’s peril in helpless situations
It is not enough that the defendant should have known.
How does Georgia treat implied assumption of risk?
It is a separate defense that can completely exculpate the defendant
It does not apply to rescuers unless their actions are reckless.
What is Georgia’s rule regarding strict liability for domestic animals?
Owners are not strictly liable unless they knew of the animal’s dangerous propensities
The plaintiff must show prior knowledge of the animal’s vicious tendencies.
What is the status of strict products liability for distributors in Georgia?
Distributors are not strictly liable in tort under Georgia law
Strict liability is imposed only on manufacturers.
What protections do agricultural facilities have against nuisance actions in Georgia?
Not subject to nuisance actions if in operation for two years unless negligence is shown
This provides a defense for longstanding agricultural operations.
How does Georgia refer to vicarious liability?
Imputable negligence
This requires a relationship of principal and agent for liability to be imposed.
What is the family car doctrine in Georgia?
The owner is liable for negligent driving by a family member using a family car
Georgia has not enacted a permissive use statute.
What is the liability of parents for their children’s tortious conduct in Georgia?
Parents are liable up to $10,000 for willful or malicious acts of their minor child
This includes reasonable medical expenses and property damage.
What is the standard for Georgia’s Dramshop statute?
Actual knowledge of serving alcohol to a minor is not always required for liability
Reasonable care must be exercised to determine if the recipient is a minor.
What is the rule regarding joint and several liability in Georgia?
Georgia has eliminated joint liability for claims involving multiple tortfeasors
Fault must be apportioned among all contributing parties.
What can parents recover for loss of a child’s services in Georgia?
Parents can recover against someone providing intoxicating beverages to their minor child
This includes engaging the child in gambling without parental consent.
What is the measure of recovery for wrongful death actions in Georgia?
The full value of life of the decedent, including support and companionship
This is broader than the usual measure based on pecuniary injury.
What is the Georgia rule regarding the survival of libel actions?
Pending libel actions survive the death of the plaintiff
This is unlike most states where such actions expire upon death.
What is the status of intra-family immunity in Georgia?
Most states have abolished spousal immunity; Georgia’s status is not specified
The text indicates a general trend but does not clarify Georgia’s specific laws.
What is the purpose of wrongful death actions?
For the pecuniary injury resulting to the spouse and next of kin.
What is the measure of recovery for wrongful death in Georgia?
The full value of life of the decedent, including loss of support and loss of companionship.
In wrongful death cases, what additional expenses may be recovered?
Funeral, medical, and other expenses.
What has most states done regarding spousal immunity?
Most states have abolished spousal immunity.
What is Georgia’s stance on intra-family tort immunity?
Georgia still follows traditional views but may not apply the doctrine if certain policy reasons are absent.
How does Georgia view interspousal immunity in wrongful death actions?
It violates the constitutional right of equal protection.
What waiver does Georgia’s state tort claims act provide?
It waives sovereign immunity for torts of state officers and employees acting within official duties.
What activities retain sovereign immunity in Georgia?
- Conduct by a state officer exercising due care
- Performance of discretionary functions
- Legislative, judicial, quasi-judicial actions
- Failure to provide police or fire protection
- Various intentional and quasi-intentional torts
What is the limit for recovery for a single person for a loss in Georgia?
Limited to $1 million.
What is the state’s aggregate liability per occurrence in Georgia?
$3 million.
Are punitive damages allowed in Georgia’s tort claims?
No, punitive damages are not allowed.
What is the status of municipal tort immunity in Georgia?
Georgia retains municipal immunity to some extent.
Under what conditions can Georgia municipalities waive immunity?
- Purchasing liability insurance for motor vehicles
- Insurance coverage above statutory limits
- Ministerial duties
What must be proven for a city to be liable for police nonfeasance?
A special relationship exists between the person and the city.
What are the three elements determining a ‘special relationship’?
- Explicit assurance from the city
- Knowledge of potential harm from inaction
- Justifiable and detrimental reliance by the injured person
What immunity do public officials have in Georgia for discretionary acts?
They are immune from tort liability unless acting with malice or improper purpose.
Are municipal employees liable for negligent performance of their ministerial functions?
Yes, they may be liable.
In Georgia, what must a plaintiff prove for libel damages?
Actual injury for defamatory statements made in broadcasts.
What is the rule for presumed damages in Georgia for libel?
Presumed only for statements that are libel per se or published in newspapers/magazines.
What limits recovery for defamation in Georgia?
Actual damages if the defendant proves no malice and retraction conditions are met.
What must a plaintiff do to recover punitive damages for defamation in Georgia?
Request a retraction or be precluded from obtaining punitive damages.
What is the general rule for justifiable reliance in misrepresentation cases?
Reliance is justifiable only on representations of fact.
Under what condition can a plaintiff rely on a defendant’s opinion in Georgia?
If the defendant has superior knowledge of the subject matter.
What are the elements to establish a prima facie case for interference with business relations?
- Existence of a valid relationship
- Defendant’s knowledge
- Intentional interference
- Damages
What must a plaintiff prove for tortious interference in Georgia?
- Defendant acted improperly
- Purposeful and malicious intent
- Financial injury caused by the defendant’s actions
What is primarily covered in Title 51 of the Official Code of Georgia Annotated?
Georgia Tort law
This includes distinctions between general law and Georgia law.
What are the four established intentional torts involving personal injury?
- Battery
- Assault
- Intentional infliction of emotional distress
- False imprisonment
What are the three elements required for a prima facie case for any intentional tort?
- Tortious conduct
- Requisite mental state
- Causation
In the context of battery and assault, what must the defendant’s tortious conduct be?
An act that is voluntary
The defendant must have directed the physical muscular movement.
How is the requisite mental state for an intentional tort established?
If the defendant acts intentionally
This includes acting with purpose or knowing that the consequence is substantially certain to result.
What is a key distinction regarding children and intentional torts in Georgia?
Infancy is a defense if the defendant is less than 13 years old
Reference: Ga. Code Ann. §§ 51-11-6, 16-3-1.
What must a defendant intend to cause for a battery to occur?
Contact with the plaintiff’s person
The contact must also cause bodily harm or be offensive.
What types of damages may a plaintiff recover for battery?
- Physical injury
- Emotional distress
- Nominal damages
What is the standard for punitive damages in Georgia tort actions?
Proven by clear and convincing evidence that the defendant’s actions showed willful misconduct, malice, or conscious indifference
Reference: Ga. Code Ann. § 51-12-5.1.
What is required for a defendant to be liable for the intentional infliction of emotional distress?
Extreme and outrageous conduct that intentionally or recklessly causes severe emotional distress
Reference: Restatement (Third) of Torts: Liability for Physical and Emotional Harm § 46.
What is a Georgia distinction regarding intentional infliction of emotional distress?
The conduct must be directed at the plaintiff; no bystander recovery is allowed
The plaintiff must have a physical or pecuniary injury unless the conduct was willful, wanton, or malicious.
What is required for a defendant to be liable for false imprisonment?
- Intent to confine the plaintiff
- Conduct causing the confinement
- Plaintiff’s consciousness of confinement
In Georgia, how is false imprisonment defined?
Unlawful detention of another person for any length of time, depriving them of personal liberty
Reference: Ga. Code Ann. § 51-7-20.
What is the significance of the length of confinement in false imprisonment cases?
It is immaterial except for determining the extent of damages
Reference: Restatement (Third) of Torts: Intentional Torts to Persons § 8 cmt. c.
What privilege does a defendant have to use force for self-defense?
Use of force against the plaintiff if reasonably believed necessary and proportionate
Reference: Restatement (Third) of Torts: Intentional Torts to Persons § 21.
Under what conditions may a defendant use deadly force in Georgia?
- Necessary to prevent death or serious injury
- Necessary to prevent or terminate a trespass
- To prevent a forcible felony
What is the ‘merchant’s privilege’?
Privilege to use force to investigate theft, recapture property, or facilitate an arrest
Reference: Restatement (Third) of Torts: Intentional Torts to Persons § 37.
What are the conditions for a merchant’s reasonable belief in exercising privilege?
- Wrongfully taken merchandise
- Failed to pay for property or services
What constitutes a trespass to chattels?
Intentional interference with a plaintiff’s right of possession
This includes dispossessing or using/intermeddling with the chattel.
What additional remedy does Georgia provide for trespass to chattels?
Statutory civil remedy for damages from willful damage or theft of personal property
Damages can include compensatory and exemplary damages under certain conditions.
What is required for a plaintiff to recover damages for intermeddling with chattel?
Actual damages must be shown
Restatement (Second) of Torts §§ 217–219.
What distinguishes intermeddling from dispossession?
Intermeddling does not involve the intent to exercise dominion and control over the chattel
Restatement (Second) of Torts § 221.
What can a plaintiff be compensated for when determining damages?
Diminution in value or cost of repair
True or False: Nominal damages can be recovered even when no actual damages are shown.
True
Ambort v. Tarica, 258 S.E.2d 755 (Ga. App. 1979).
What is the rule for conversion regarding a defendant’s liability?
A defendant is liable if they intentionally deprive a plaintiff of possession or interfere with their chattel in a serious manner
What types of property can be converted?
Only personal property and intangibles reduced to physical form
Example: A promissory note.
How does Georgia define conversion?
A defendant converts property by wrongfully asserting control inconsistent with the plaintiff’s rights
Bromley v. Bromley, 127 S.E.2d 836 (Ga. App. 1962).
What constitutes a public nuisance?
An unreasonable interference with a right common to the general public
What is required for a private citizen to claim public nuisance?
The plaintiff must suffer harm that is different in kind from that suffered by the general public
Define ‘duty of care’ in negligence law.
A duty is owed to all persons who may foreseeably be injured by a defendant’s failure to act reasonably
Who is considered a foreseeable plaintiff?
A rescuer who comes to the aid of another
What is the ‘firefighter’s rule’?
Emergency professionals cannot recover damages for injuries resulting from risks inherent in their job
What is the general rule regarding affirmative duty to act?
There is generally no duty to act affirmatively
Fill in the blank: A person who voluntarily aids another has a duty to act with _______.
reasonable ordinary care
What is Georgia’s Good Samaritan statute?
It protects any person who renders emergency care in good faith
Ga. Code Ann. § 51-1-29.
What duty does a person have if they place another in peril?
A duty to exercise reasonable care to prevent further harm
What is the standard of care typically imposed in negligence cases?
That of a reasonably prudent person under the circumstances
How is the standard of care defined in Georgia?
A ‘reasonable person’ is defined as a person exercising ordinary diligence
Ga. Code Ann. § 51-1-2.
What is the traditional standard of care for common carriers?
Common carriers are held to the highest duty of care consistent with the practical operation of the business