Torts Flashcards
To show a prima facie case of intentional tort, the plaintiff must first prove what?
A volitional act by the defendant.
May an initial aggressor claim the defense of self-defense?
Yes.
For a plaintiff to prove intentional infliction of emotional distress from a defendant’s intentional commission of physical harm to a third party, the defendant must have known what?
That the plaintiff was present when the harm was inflicted by the defendant on the third party.
May a property owner use force against someone who has a privilege to be on the property to prevent that person from being there?
No.
To what circumstances does the doctrine of transferred intent apply?
A different tort against the same party; the same tort against a different party; and a different tort against a different person.
Transferred intent may be invoked only if both the tort intended and the tort that results are . . .
Assault; battery; false imprisonment; trespass to land; or trespass to chattel. (FABTT)
Proof of intentional infliction of emotional distress requires proof of what?
Actual damage.
How must a shopkeeper perform a detention of a suspected shoplifter under the shopkeeper doctrine?
The shopkeeper must conduct the detention 1) in a reasonable manner; and 2) detain the suspect only for a reasonable time.
In order to claim defense of property, a landowner must first do what?
Request the trespasser to desist.
What kind of damages must be proven to prove false imprisonment?
None. False imprisonment requires no proof of damages.
What is “intermeddling” for the purpose of proving trespass to chattels?
Conduct which directly damages the plaintiff’s chattels.
When is the defense of consent not available to a defendant?
When the consent was gained by mistake induced by the defendant.
What kind of crime must be committed for a citizen to make a citizen’s arrest without a warrant and being liable for false imprisonment?
A felony.
What must a citizen know before they can make a warrantless citizen’s arrest?
That a felony has in fact been committed.
What kind of intent must the defendant have to be found liable for conversion?
General intent—the intent to perform the act which interfered with the plaintiff’s right of possession.
What must a defender believe in order to claim the defense of defense of others?
The defender must reasonably believe that there is a right to receive assistance on the part of the one in need of defense.
May a landowner who has been tortiously dispossessed of his property use force to regain it?
No, he must use legal remedies.
If A threatens force against B’s property, may B claim false imprisonment?
Yes. A threat of force against another’s property is enough to claim false imprisonment.
Defenses to intentional torts generally allow use of reasonable force except for when?
When the plaintiff has been dispossessed of their land.
A citizen’s arrest without an arrest warrant is permitted without being liable for false imprisonment if what?
1) a felony has in fact been committed; and 2) the citizen has reasonable grounds to believe the person arrested committed the felony.
A prima facie case of assault requires what on the part of the plaintiff?
Awareness of the force set in motion by the defendant.
Defense of others is available to a defender if the defender has what?
A reasonable belief that the person being aided has the right to self-defense.
Trespass to land requires some form of ____________.
physical entry onto the land of another.
If there is no entry onto the land of another, but there is nonetheless damage caused by another, what other torts might that person be liable for?
Nuisance; Strict Liability
When will a common law negligence duty of care be replaced by another level of duty?
When there is a statute providing for a different duty of care than the general common law rule.
Liability for conditions on the premises of land hinges on what?
Who occupies and controls the premises.
Does a landowner owe a duty to discovered trespassers?
Yes.
Does a landowner owe a duty to anticipated trespassers?
Yes.
What kind of duty does a landowner owe when conditions on his land create a danger to those off the premises?
A duty to passersby to take reasonable precautions.
Of what must a landowner inform an anticipated trespasser?
Any highly dangerous conditions known to the landowner.
When a medical provider was negligent before or during a plaintiff’s pregnancy, the plaintiff may be able to collect what kind of damages in a wrongful birth suit?
Damages for additional medical expenses.
When might an invitee lose her status as an invitee?
When she exceeds the scope of the invitation.
A lessor who voluntarily decides to make repairs to the premises his liable for any damages he causes if . . .
he is negligent in performing the repairs.
What duty of care does a driver owe to a passenger?
An duty of ordinary care.
When does a rescuee owe a duty of care to her rescuer?
When she negligently put herself or a third party in harm’s way.
When does one have an affirmative duty to act or assist another?
When the person puts the other in peril by her *innocent conduct.
A enters onto the land of B with B’s permission to conduct business with B. Is a licensee or lessee?
Licensee
What determines whether a child will be treated as an adult in civil litigation?
Whether the child was involved in an adult activity.
What kind of duty does a landowner owe to a licensee operating on that person’s land?
To warn the licensee or make safe a dangerous condition known to him which creates an unreasonable risk of harm to the licensee and that the licensee is unlikely to discover.
What is a violation of a statute requiring non-negligent conduct?
Negligence per se.
In order to successfully claim negligence per se, the plaintiff must show what?
1) that the plaintiff was among the class of individuals intended to be protected by the statute; and 2) the violation was within the class of risk intended to be protected against by the statute.
One who acts for the benefit of another has what kind of duty?
A duty to continue the assistance.
What kind of duty does a landowner owe to an invitee?
To make reasonable inspections of their land.
A plaintiff can make a claim of intentional infliction of emotional distress from the threat of physical impact to her if what?
If the plaintiff is within the zone of danger from the defendant’s conduct.
Does a statutory standard of care require a provision creating a civil penalty in order to apply to a negligence case?
No.
When may a direct verdict be granted by a judge?
When there is no triable issue of law or fact.
When the extent or severity of harm to the plaintiff is unforeseeable, the defendant is liable for what?
For all the aggravation of an existing physical or mental illness. This is known as the eggshell plaintiff doctrine.
What theory of proving negligence liability establishes a prima facie case of negligence?
Res ipsa loquitor.
The “but for” test for establishing actual cause applies to what kind of causes?
Concurrent.
In a partial comparative negligence jurisdiction, can the plaintiff be barred from recovery? If so, when?
Yes; if the plaintiff’s negligence was greater than 50 percent.
Under the last clear chance doctrine, the defendant must have been able to avoid harming the plaintiff . . .
at the time of the incident.
Can a plaintiff in a negligence claim recover damages for future harm?
Yes
The concept of imputed contributory negligence allows what?
A defendant to use the contributory negligence of a third party as a defense against the plaintiff when the plaintiff and the third party stand in a particular relationship, such as an employer-employee relationship.
Plaintiff is hurt by the defendant’s actions. The plaintiff chooses not to take steps to treat their injuries, and as a result, the injuries get worse. The defendant can claim what as a defense?
Doctrine of avoidable consequences.
What are nominal damages?
Damages awarded simply because a legal wrong has taken place. These are usually $1.
Can nominal damages be awarded in negligence?
No, because negligence is only a viable claim when there has been actual damage, and actual damage justifies the replacing of nominal damages with actual damages.
If a plaintiff fails to mitigate their damages, what is the likely result?
A reduced damage award.
What must a defendant prove in order to claim implied assumption of risk by the plaintiff?
That the plaintiff 1) know of the risk; and 2) voluntarily proceeded in the face of the risk.
When there are several defendants in a partial comparative negligence jurisdiction, the plaintiff’s negligence is calculated how?
The plaintiff’s negligence is compared to the total negligence of all the defendants combined.
What is the Collateral Source Rule?
A plaintiff’s damages are not considered as being mitigated by the plaintiff’s receipt of money from outside sources under the collateral source rule.
What is an example of prospective damages?
Compensation for impaired future earnings capacity.
May a plaintiff recover damages for unproven damages in negligence?
No. A plaintiff must show actual damage in negligence.
Most comparative negligence jurisdictions have abolished what as a separate defense?
The implied assumption of risk.
What does the doctrine of imputed contributory negligence require?
A special relationship between the plaintiff and a third party.
Negligence per se usually leads to what by the defendant?
A motion for a direct verdict.
A motion for a directed verdict will not be granted if . . .
there is any triable issue of fact regarding the four elements of negligence.
In negligence, if an intervening force is ______________, it will not cut off the defendant’s liability for the negligent conduct.
foreseeable
What is the general test for establishing proximate cause in negligence?
Was the harm caused within the risk created by the defendant’s conduct?
When is the alternative causes approach applied to find cause in fact?
When several acts could have caused the plaintiff’s harm, but it is not known which act actually caused the plaintiff’s harm.
What is the substantial factor test for cause in fact?
When several causes are present, and any one of them by itself is sufficient to cause the harm.
When is the “but for” test used to determine cause in fact?
When there are several acts which, when combined, were sufficient to cause injury to the plaintiff.
What are the three tests used for determining cause in fact?
but for test; substantial factor test; alternative causes test.
If there is any triable issue of _________, a motion for a directed verdict must be denied.
fact
Res ipsa is a theory of proving ___________.
negligence
What does res ipsa loquitor create?
a prima facie case of negligence for the plaintiff.
A duty to control the conduct of a third party arises when:
1) one has the authority and ability to control the conduct of the third party; and 2) one knows or has reason to know of the need to exercise such control.
Battery —
the intentional causing of contact to the person of another which is harmful or offensive to a reasonable person.
Assault —
the intentional causing of a reasonable fear or apprehension of an impending physical contact.
False Imprisonment —
intent to confine to a bounded space.
Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress —
an intentional or reckless act which is extreme or outrageous and which causes severe emotional distress.
Trespass to Land —
the intentional physical invasion of another’s real property.
Trespass to Chattels —
the intentional interfering with another’s right of possession in a chattel which causes damage.
Conversion —
the intentional interference with another’s right of possession in a chattel.
What kind of tort is nuisance?
It is not a tort. Nuisance is a type of harm caused by tortious conduct.
Intent —
a person acts with intent if it was their purpose to bring about the consequence, or if they were substantially certain of the consequences.
Baseball bat example: the batter was substantially certain of the consequences of throwing the bat into the stands.
When are a plaintiff’s super-sensitivities taken into consideration in intentional tort?
Only when the defendant knew of them before committing the tort.
What are the two ways intent can be transferred under the transferred intent doctrine?
1) from intended to actual tort; and 2) from intended victim to actual victim.
In battery, a contact must be offensive; i.e. ____________.
unpermitted
In assault, the apprehension by the plaintiff must have been what?
reasonable.
What creates a reasonable apprehension of physical contact in regards to assault?
apparent ability
Homer makes a statement about how he is going to hurt someone if they do not do something. He makes no conduct with the speech. Is there an assault?
No, words without conduct are not enough to constitute assault.
For false imprisonment, inaction by the defendant is sufficient if . . .
there was an understanding that the defendant would act.
A mere ______________ is not enough to claim false imprisonment.
inconvenience
An area is not bounded for purposes of false imprisonment if . . .
there is a reasonable means of escape of which the plaintiff is aware.
When the facts of a case do not support a finding of any other tort, you should try what tort?
Intentional infliction of emotional distress.
When there is some damage to another’s property, the most appropriate tort to sue on is . . .
trespass to chattels
When there is a lot of damage to another’s property, the most appropriate tort to sue on is . . .
conversion
What are the two kinds of consent?
Implied; express
Is custom a defense to tort if the plaintiff was not aware of the custom?
Yes.