Torts Flashcards
To establish a prima facie case for any intentional tort, the plaintiff must prove:
- An act by the defendant
- Intent by the defendant
- Causation of the result to the plaintiff from the defendant’s act
What is considered an “act” by a defendant to satisfy an intentional tort?
A volitional movement
What is the required “intent” to satisfy an intentional tort?
Intent to bring about the forbidden consequences that are the basis of the tort.
What is transferred intent?
When the defendant intends to commit a tort against one person but instead:
1. Commits a different tort against that person
2. Commit the same tort as intended but against a different person
3. Commits a different tort against a different person
Transferred intent may be invoked if the tort that results are one of the following:
- Assault
- Battery
- False Imprisonment
- Trespass to Land
- Trespass to Chattels
What is required “causation” to satisfy an intentional tort?
The defendant’s conduct must be a substantial factor in bringing about the injury.
Is incapacity a defense to intentional torts?
No
What are the elements of battery?
- Harmful or offensive contact
- With the plaintiff’s person
- Intent
- Causation
What is “harmful or offensive contact” under the tort of battery?
Harmful = actual injury, pain, or disfigurement
Offensive = offensive to a reasonable person
Note: May be direct (e.g., striking the plaintiff) or indirect (e.g., poison)
What are the elements of assault?
- An act by the defendant creating a reasonable apprehension in the plaintiff
- Of an immediate battery
- Intent
- Causation
What satisfies a “reasonable apprehension” under the tort of assault?
- For apprehension to be shown, the plaintiff must have been aware of the threat from the defendant’s act
- The apprehension must be reasonable
- The plaintiff need not be aware of the defendant’s identity
- The plaintiff must believe the defendant had the apparent ability to commit a battery, even if the defendant did not actually have the ability
What are the elements of false imprisonment?
- An act or omission on the part of the defendant that confines or restrains the plaintiff
- The plaintiff must be confined to a bounded area
- Intent
- Causation
What are sufficient acts of restraint under the tort of false imprisonment?
- Physical barriers
- Physical force directed at the plaintiff, immediate family, or personal property
- Direct threats of force
- Indirecrt or implied threats of force
- Failure to release the plaintiff when under a legal duty to do so
- Invalid use of legal authority
What are insufficient acts of restraint under the tort of false imprisonment?
- Moral pressure
- Future threats
Must a plaintiff know they are being confined under the tort of false imprisonment?
Yes
What is a “bounded area” under the tort of false imprisonment?
- For an area to be “bounded,” freedom of movement must be limited in all directions
- There must be no reasonable means of escape known to the plaintiff
What are the elements of intentional infliction of emotional distress?
- An act by the defendant amounting to extreme and outrageous conduct
- The plaintiff must suffer severe emotional distress
- Intent (Recklessness)
- Causation
Conduct that is not normally outrageous may become so if:
- It is continuous in nature
- It is committed by a certain type of defendant; or
- It is directed toward a certain type of defendant
When the defedant’s conduct is directed at a third person, and the plaintiff suffers severe emtional distress because of it, the plaintiff may recover by showing either:
- The prima facie case elements of emotional distress; or
- The plaintiff:
a. Was present when the injury occurred
b. The distress resulted in bodily harm or the plaintiff is a close relative of the 3rd person; and
c. The defendant knew these facts
What are the elements to trespass to land?
- Physical invasion
- Of the plaintiff’s real property
- Intent to enter land (knowledge is not required)
- Causation)
What are the elements of trespass to chattels?
- Act by the defendant that interferes with the plaintiff’s right of possession in a chattel
- Intent to interefere
- Causation
What are the elements of conversion?
- Act by the defendant that interferes with the plaintiff’s right of possession in a chattel
- Interference is serious enough in nature or consequence to warrant that the defendant pay the chattel’s full value
- Intent to interfere
- Causation
Is mistake of ownership a defense to conversion or trespass to chattels?
No
What are the remedies to conversion?
- Damages (fair market value at the time of conversion); or
- Replevin (possession)