Torts Flashcards
What is necessary to make a prima facie case for intentional tort?
(1) Act by the defendant (2) done with intent (3) causing harm to plaintiff as a substantial factor.
What types of intent are required for tort?
(1) General: acting with substantial certainty can cause harm(2) Specific: acting with actual intent to cause harm(3) Transferred: any harm resulting to another person from a specific intent tort.
What are the torts eligible for transferred intent?
(1) Assault, (2) Battery, (3) Trespass and (4) False imprisonment
What damages are available for intentional torts?
(1) General (2) Specific (aka economic) (3) Punitive
What are the elements of assault?
(1) An act by the defendant creating a reasonable apprehension in the plaintiff (2) of immediate harmful or offensive contact to P’s person(3) Intent(4) Causation
What is a “reasonable apprehension “?
(1) Plaintiff perceives or knows defendants act and (2) the act has an apparent ability to result in harmful or offensive contact.
What is insufficient for immediate apprehension of harm?
Words alone.
What are the elements of battery?
(1) Any harmful or offensive contact by the defendant(2) to the plaintiff’s person(2) with intent(3) causing injury.
What is the test for “offensive” contact?
(1) Any inappropriate contact a reasonable person would take offense to and (2) without consent.E.g. Hypersensitivity is ignored.
What counts as a “contact of person” for battery and assault?
(1) The body and anything(2) anything directly connected to the body.E.g. clothes.
What is sufficient causation in battery or assault?
(1) Any direct harm or (2) indirect harm through instruments or other forces.
What are the elements of false imprisonment?
(1) Any (a) act or (b) omission resulting in the plaintiffs restraint or confinement (2) to a bounded area (3) intended and(4) caused by defendant.
What are the types of acts producing restraint or confinement?
(1) Physical(2) threats(3) commands of apparent authority.
What is necessary in confinement to be actionable?
(1) Awareness or (2) harm by confinement (3) limitation to freedom of movement (4) ignorance of any reasonable means of escape.
What are the elements of Intentional Infliction of Emotional Distress? (IIED)?
(1) Extreme, outrageous, or targeted conduct(2) eliciting severe emotional distress in Plaintiff(3) intended or with reckless disregard (4) caused by the Defendant.
What is extreme and outrageous conduct?
(1) Exceeding bounds of decency and (2) beyond mere insults.
What types of non-outrageous conduct may be liable?
(1) Targeting known sensitivities, phobias, or weaknesses.(2) Continuous or repetitive obnoxious conduct. (3) Directed at a member of a fragile class such as children, elderly, or pregnant women.(4) by an innkeeper or common carrier.
What are the elements of bystander IIED
(1) Defendant’s conduct seriously injured or killed a 3rd person, (2) plaintiff is close to the injured person, (3) plaintiff was present for injury, (4) defendant knew of plaintiff’s relationship and presence, (5) plaintiff suffers distress
What is required for severe emotional distress from bystander IIED?
No physical manifestation required if a family member, otherwise physical manifestation is required.
What are the elements of trespass to land?
(1) Physical invasion into the plaintiff’s real property by the defendant (2) Intent (3) Caused by plaintiffs conduct
What suffices for “invasion” of property?
(1) Bodily intrusion or(2) projectiles or placement of tangible object onto (3) land surface, reasonable subsurface or airspace. Light & sound are insufficient.
When does a plaintiff qualify for trespass of land?
When they have actual or constructive possession. No ownership required.
What type of intent is required to suffice for trespass of land?
Just the intent to enter the property, intent to trespass is not required.
What damages are available for Trespass to Land?
General and specific damages. Specific is sufficient, but not necessary.
What are the elements to trespass to chattle & conversion?
(1) An intentional (2) interference with the possession of personal property, (3) causing (4) damages.
What is the distinction between trespass & conversion?
Trespass is a minor interferance. Conversion is a significant or substnatial interference or damage justifying a remedy of the entire value of the chattel. If the interference is a prolonged use that may also qualify.
What kind of damages must be proven for trespass & conversion?
(1) For trespass, a plaintiff may recover cost of repair or rental value when chattel is unavailable. (2) Conversion requires showing a loss of the FMV at time of conversion or repossession. (3) Replevin or repossession for property out of possession.
What are the types of consent defense for intentional torts?
(1) Express and (2) Implied
What forms of express consent are permissible?
(1) Verbal and (2) Written
When is express consent void?
If there is (1) Durress, (2) Fraud, or (3) Mistake
When can implied consent to a battery be infrered?
(1) Participation in an activity where minor torts are common, (2) entering area where minor torts are common, (3) ordinary contacts of daily life, (4) plaintiff’s conduct allows a reasonable inference.
What is the scope of consent?
Both implied and express consent are always limited in scope and may be exceeded giving rise to liability.
What are the elements to defenses of self, others, or property?
(1) A reasonable belief of an imminent or actual tort, (2) properly timed during the threat, (3) reasonable and proportional force in response.
What are the conditions of self-defense?
(1) No duty to retreat in many jurisdictions, (2) proportional to the threat, (3) may be deployed by the initial agressor if the defendant responding to non-deadly force escalates to deadly force.
What are the conditions of defense of others?
(1) The defendant must have a reasonable belief the third-party victim has the right to self-defense, (2) same level of force permissible as if for self.
What are the elements for defense of property?
(1) Reasonable non-lethal or severe force, (2) on an unprivileged intruder, (3) aand reasonable mistake only if intrusion occured, not if privilege existed.
What are the types of necessity?
(1) Private and (2) Public
What are the elements of necessity?
(1) Defendant’s interferance with plaintiff’s property must be reasonably necessary to avoid an immediate threatened injury, and (2) Threatened injury must be greater or more serious than the interferance to avoid it.
What are the elements of public necessity defense?
(1) Invasion or interference or trespass (2) to protect the community or a large group of people, (3) based on a reasonable necessity to protect.
What are some examples of public necessity?
Stealing a fire extinguisher to put out a spreading fire. Driving a runaway truck off the highway to prevent a major accident.
What are the conditions on private necessity?
(1) Defendant invades plaintiffi’s property to protect the self or a small group, (2) based on a reasonable necessity.
What is the scope of necessity defenses?
(1) Public is absolute, (2) Private is limited to actual damages, not punitive or nominal unless defendant’s act benefitted plaintiff
What are the liabilities upon the property owner for necessity?
If an owner repels or expels a trespasser who interferes or invades out of a valid necessity, the owner will be liable for damages to the party with a valid necessity.
What are the elements to recapture of chattels defense?
(1) Defendant owner must make a timely demand for return unless futile or dangerous, (2) intrude the property in a reasonable time and manner, (3) use of force must be reasonable, non-lethal or seriously dangerous.
When may a defendant capture from third-parties?
(1) Any time the third-party knows the property was wrongfully obtained, (2) if innocent after first giving notice.
When is a recapture privilege unavailable?
If the property to be recaptured is on an innocent person’s property because of the defendant’s fault.
What may a defendant do if an innocent landowner refuses entry for replevin?
The defendant may enter at a reasonable time and in a peaceful manner.
What are the elements of defamation?
(1) A defamatory statement, (2) concerning the plaintiff, (3) published, (4) harmful to reputation, (5) that is false, (6) if a public figure, actually malicious, (7) damages.
What is a defamatory statement?
Adversely affects the reputation based on specific facts and not mere opinion.
When does a statement concern the plaintiff?
Either (1) expressly, of (2) implicitly through a reasonable inference.
What is sufficient for publication?
Intentionally or negligently communicated or received to a third person.
When is a statement harmful to reputation?
If it lowers the esteem, trustworthyness, or opinion of the plaintiff in a community whether public or minority.
What is the scope of liability for a publisher who republishes?
To the same extent as the original publisher.
When must a plaintiff show actual malice in defamation?
When the plaintiff is: (1) A public figure, (2) public official, (3) private individual speaking for a matter of public concern?
What is a public figure?
A person with pervasive fame or notoriety or who voluntarily assumes a central role in a public matter.
Who is a public official?
Anyone who holds a public office.
What is necessary to prove “actual malice”?
(1) Falsity of the statement, (2) Fault in so far as the publisher knew the statement was false or acted with reckless disregard.
What is the standard for public figures?
(1) Falsity, and (2) Negligence
When is it unnecessary to show actual malice?
(1) Private figure and (2) private matters.
What are the distinctions between the forms of defamation?
(1) Libel is written or recorded (2) Slander is spoken.
What damages are available for libel?
(1) General without special, (2) Special
What damages are available for slander?
(1) General only with (2) Special economic loss [e.g. losing a job] unless slander per se
When is slander slander per se?
(1) professional or business reputaion, (2) loathsome disease, (3) crime or moral turpitude, (4) unchaste lady
What are the defenses to defamation?
(1) Consent, (2) Truth, (3) Privilege
What are the types of privilege for defamation?
(1) Absolute for government officials acting in an official capacity, and (2) Qualified.
What are the types of qualified privileges for defamation?
(1) Invites the statement or recipient has an interest. (2) Statement is in the public interest. (3) Public hearing.
What are the elements of Appropriation?
(1) Unauthorized use of (2) plaintiff’s name or likeness for (3) commercial purposes other than news reporting.
What are the elements of False Light?
(1) A widespread publication of (2) a falsehood or material misrepresentaion (3) about the plaintiff, (4) that would be highly offensive to a reasonable person.
What are the defenses to false light & appropriation?
(1) Consent, (2) Privilege for false light. Truth is not a defense for privacy claims.
What are the elements of intrusion upon seclusion?
(1) Plaintiff must have a reasonable expectation of privacy, (2) Intrusion by defendant must be highly offensive.
What are the elements of disclosure of private facts?
(1) High offensive to a reasonable person, (2) Publicized, (3) Not newsworthy
What are the elements of malicious prosecution?
(1) Defendant brings a frivlous charge or claim after a prior criminal or civil litigation against plaintiff, (2) plaintiff won prior suit, (3) no probable cause for the cases, (4) defendant had an improper purpose for bringing suits, (5) damages.
What are the elements of abuse of process?
(1) Wrongful use of process for an ulterior motive, (2) Definite act or threat against plaintiff to accomplish an ulterior purpose.
What are the six elements of Intentional Misrepresentation?
(1) False past or present material fact, (2) known or believed false, (3) intended to induce action or reliance, (5) victim justifiably relies, (6) and incurs specific monetary damages as a result.
What are the elements of Negligent Misrepresentation?
(1) Defendant misrepresents a material fact in a business setting, (2) Breach of duty of care owed to a particular plaintiff, (3) Actual and justifiable reliance by plaintiff, (4) Plaintiff has actual monetary damages
What are other names for “misrepresentation”?
Fraud or deceit
What are the elements of intentional interference with business relations?
(1) Plaintiff has a valid contract or business expectation with a third party, (2) Defendant knows of the relationship or expectation, (3) Defendant intentionally interferes with that relationship, (4) Defendant’s interference causes a breach or termination in plaintiff’s contract or expectancy, (5) Damages to plaintiff.
What defenses are available for intentional interference with business relations?
Privilege if the defendants conduct is a proper attempt to obtain business or protect his interests.
What is another term for intentional interference with business relation?
A “tortious interference with contract.”
What are the elements of negligence?
(1) Duty of care, (2) Breach of Duty, (3) Causation [actual and proximate], (4) Damages
What is the standard for negligence?
A reasonable person under similar circumstances.
What is the duty standard for negligence?
Outside of special standards of care that of a Reasonably Prudent Person (RPP)
What are other terms for actual cause?
A “cause-in-fact” or “factual cause.”
What are other terms for proximate cause?
“Legal cause”