Torts Flashcards
Who is owed a duty?
- ) Foreseeable Plaintiffs
- ) Majority (cardozo) view: plaintiffs within the zone of foreseeable harm
- ) Minority (Andrews) view - anyone who is harmed.
Is that an Affirmative Duty to Act?
Generally, there is no affirmative duty to aid or rescue someone.
What if a person assumes the duty to act? (Assumption of Duty)
If someone starts to air or rescue, they must act with reasonable ordinary care not to increase the risk of harm.
What is a psychotherapists’ duty to warn?
If a patient makes credible threats of physical violence, the therapist is under a duty to warn the intended victim.
What is the normal standard of care?
To act as a reasonably prudent person under the circumstances.
When do you apply the normal standard of care?
Apply the general standard of care unless a special standard applies (landowner, physician, etc) or there is a statute (negligence per se).
What is the Modern Rule regarding the standard of care for possessors of land?
Landowner must exercise reasonable care under the circumstances to all land entrants, except trespassers.
What is the traditional approach regarding standard of care for possessors of land?
First, categorize the plaintiff as a trespasser, invitee, or licensee. Then analyze the standard of care owed to that person.
What is a trespasser, and what duty does a landowner owe them?
- ) on the land without consent or permission
2. ) Duty to refrain from willful, wanton, reckless, or intentional misconduct.
What is an invitee, and what duty does a landowner owe them?
- ) Invited as member of the public or a business visitor
2. ) Duty: to inspect and discover unreasonably dangerous conditions and protect the invitees from them.
What is a licensee, and what duty does a landowner owe them?
- ) Enters with express or implied permission for a specific purpose.
- ) Duty: to warn of concealed dangers that are known or should be obvious and use reasonable care in conducting activities.
Upon what conditions will a landowner be liable for an attractive nuisance that causes injury?
- ) artificial condition exists in a place where the owner knows or should know that children are likely to trespass.
- ) the condition imposes an unreasonable risk of serious bodily injury.
- ) The children cannot appreciate the danger due to their youth;
- ) The burden of eliminating the danger is slight compared with the risk of harm; AND
- ) the land possessor failed to exercise reasonable care to protect the children.
Concerning negligence liability between landlord and tenants, what duty does a landlord owe?
To protect from foreseeable attacks by third parties.
What are the duties of children in a negligence scenario?
- ) Duty to act as a reasonable child of the same age.
2. )
How does a industry custom and the standard of care work together?
Evidence of an industry or community custom is admissible as evidence of the relevant standard of care, but that evidence of custom is not conclusive.
What standard of care do Professionals have?
Duty to perform at the same level as another practitioner in the same community.
What standard of care do doctors have?
Duty to perform as an average doctor based on a national standard.
When does a breach occur?
When the defendant fails to meet the applicable standard of care.
What are the factors for determining breach under the cost-benefit analysis?
- ) The foreseeability of harm;
- ) The severity of harm, AND
- ) The burden on the defendant to prevent the harm.
When does Res Ipsa Loquitor arise?
Arises when there is no direct evidence of the defendant’s negligent conduct.
Allows the trier of fact to infer that there was negligence conduct.
What must a plaintiff prove for Res Ipsa Loquitor?
- ) The type of accident would not normally occur absent negligence
- ) The injury was caused by an agent or instrumentality within the exclusive control of the defendant, AND
- ) The injury was not due to the plaintiff’s actions.
When does Negligence Per Se arise?
when there is a statute that imposes a specific duty.
Plaintiff must be within the class of persons the statute is meant to protect
Plaintiff must suffer the type of harm the statute was meant to protect against
Defendant’s violation of the statute must be the proximate cause of plaintiff’s harm.
What is “Actual Causation?”
Plaintiff must show that but-for the defendant’s actions plaintiffs injury would not have occurred.
What is the Substantial Factor Rule?
Arises when there are multiple causes of the harm and each alone would have been a factual cause of the injury.
The conduct of each defendant is a cause in fact if it was a substantial cause of the injury.