Torts Flashcards
Malice (defamation)
To establish a reckless disregard for the truthfulness of a statement, the defendant must have entertained serious doubts about its truthfulness; mere failure to check facts is not sufficient.
Assault/Battery damages
nominal OK absent actual damages
- punitive if malice involved
NY Intentional Torts SOL
1 year after injury
IIED NY distinction
Intentional mishandling of a corpse
Assault
- reasonable apprehension of
- imminent harm
- caused by D’s action/threat
- D’s intent to cause such harm/apprehension
IIED
- Extreme and Outrageous behavior
- exceeds all bounds of human decency - Intentionally or R
- Results in severe emotional distress
IIED 3rd parties
- Immediate family
- D aware - Bystander
- D aware
- physical injury
False Imprisonment
i) Intending to confine or restrain another within boundaries fixed by the actor;
ii) Those actions directly or indirectly result in such confinement; and
iii) The other is conscious of the confinement or is harmed by it
Shopkeeper’s privilege
- reasonable grounds to suspect theft
- may detain for reasonable time
- reasonable manner
Consent by mistake
Valid unless:
- D caused mistake
- D knew of mistake and took advantage
NY Duty to Retreat
Retreat
- if can do so safely
- home
- w/n curtilage (enclosed area surrounding home)
Self Defense injury to 3rd parties
Not liable so long as not negligent
Defense of property
- cannot use deadly force
- may use reasonable non-deadly force if reasonable believe that necessary to protect tortious harm to property
Recapture of chattel
- can use reasonable force
- but must be peaceful if initial taking was lawful
Trespass to chattel
Intentionally
- dispossess P of chattel
- or intermeddles and damages chattel
*Mistake of fact not a defense
Conversion
Intentionally commits act - Deprives P of possession - OR interferes w/ P's possession So serious that - deprives P of use of her chattel
Conversion remedy
Full value of chattel at time of conversion
Conversion Defenses
- NOT OK: mistake of law/fact
- OK NY: good faith purchaser unless informed and refuses to comply
Necessity defense
right to use other’s property to save lives or more valuable property
- trespass to land/chattels and conversion
Public necessity vs Private necessity
If public necessity, not liable for any damage
Private Nuisance
- substantial (to reasonable person)
- unreasonable (injury > usefulness)
- interference
- use and enjoyment of land
Nuisance self-help (abatement)
may enter another’s land to abate nuisance after:
- notice
- refusal to comply
Standard of care (negligence)
Most courts: Reasonably prudent person under the circumstances
Modern approach: cost-benefit approach
- foreseeability of harm, severity of harm and burden of precautions
Duty
Duty to all foreseeable persons who may be injured by failure to show reasonable care
- Zone of danger
- If any P foreseeable, then duty to all harmed as result
Special class of foreseeable Ps
- if D negligently put the rescuer or the rescued party in danger
Firefighter Rule
- cannot recover against negligent party if inherent in the job
- NY does not recognize
Standard of care for children
reasonable child of similar age, intelligence, and experience
- unless involved in adult activities
Standard of care (physicians)
Traditionally, same or similar locale standard
- Modern trend: national standard
Informed consent exception (MBE)
- risk commonly known
- patient unconscious
- disclosure would be harmful
Common Carriers and Innkeepers
highest standard of care consistent w/ practical operation
Bailees
- Exclusive benny of bailee –> bound to use great care
- Mutual benny –> ordinary negligence
- Bailor benny –> gross negligence
Negligence Per Se
- Criminal or regulatory statute
- Against class of persons protected by statute
- Respecting the harm contemplated by statute
Defenses to neg per se
- Impossible under the circumstances
2. An emergency justified violation
Duty to Trespassers
Undiscovered: refrain from willful, wanton, reckless, or intentional misconduct
Discovered: Duty to warn/protect from concealed, dangerous, artificial harms
*does not apply to natural conditions or artificial harms absent risk of SBI
Attractive Nuisance
Liable to injuries to children if:
- artificial condition
- knows/should know children are likely to trespass
- knows/should know poses risk of death/SBI
- kids cannot discover/appreciate risk
- utility of maintaining the condition and burden of eliminating risk are slight
- fails to exercise reasonable care to protect kids
Invitees
- inspect property
- discover unreasonably dangerous conditions
- protect visitor from them
*Non-delegable
Licensees
Duty to correct or warn of concealed dangers that are known or should be obvious
*No duty to inspect
Landlord tort liability
common areas w/r/t hidden dangers which LL failed to warn or hazard caused by LL's negligent repairs or hazard LL agreed to fix