Topic 5 Flashcards
how did the first world war change the structure of the international economy?
abandonment of gold standard
international financial relations changed
altering of trade patterns
war demand for materials stimulated the worldwide expansion in their production
how did international financial relations change after the first world war
US emerged as major creditor nation
British position weakened by war debts to the US
France also had large debts
Germany forced to pay reparations
disintegration of Austro-Hungarian and Ottoman Empires
altering of trade patterns after WW1
european countries were making war materials and military equipment instead of civilian goods
stimulated industrialisation in countries like Australia, Canada, Brazil, India and Japan
Main powers position on reparations for germany
France advocated for tough reparations as they were the largest recipient of reparations
Britain was concerned about the effects on the European economy of harsh reparations
US argued against reparations (Woodrow’s 14 point plan)
treaty of versailles
28 June 1919
Surrender its naval forces, army was restricted to 100,000 and not allowed an air force
Lost 13% of pre-war territory and 7 million people (12% of population)
Took coal, agricultural and manufacturing resources
Give up overseas colonies
Admit Liability for war damage - War Guilt Clause
Pay reparations (132 billion gold marks) final payment made in October 2010
Keynes position on reparations
opposed tough reparations arguing that destabilising germany would undermine post-war economic recovery in Europe, instead arguing for war debts to be forgiven
total european debt owing to America by 1922
US$ 9.4 billion
german rates of hyperinflation in 1923
over 100 million percent
main causes of inflation
persistent shortages in civilian products, considerably worsened in 1923 by the French occupation of the German Ruhr and closure of its industries
the government’s monetary funding of its ballooning budget deficits and war reparations
german government monetary funding war and post-war
the german government relied entirely on borrowing to fund military spending rather than raising taxation
war inflation amplified the budget deficits and made it increasingly difficult to effect funding through long-term borrowing
German military government rationale for its war debt funding
on winning the war, the war debt would be paid for by annexing resource rich industrial territory to the west and east and imposing massive reparations on defeated Allies
position of weimar republic in 1919
inherited a massive war debt that could not be service by raising tax revenue in the debilitated post-war state of the economy
the public refused to take up Government securities, so the government was compelled to issue short term treasury bills to finance its deficits
German fiscal position by 1921
by 1921, as production of civilian goods began to recover, the German fiscal position deteriorated with the first reparation payments in june of that year
devaluation of the mark and the first reparation repayment
first reparation payment marked the beginning of an increasingly rapid devaluation of the mark
mark fell in value from 90 to about 330 marks per USD
impact of the devaluation
contributed to higher inflation via rising import costs
government began to issue money to buy foreign currency in equivalent gold marks to make reparations repayments
impact of the devaluation on reparations
germany could not purchase gold to make reparation repayments
reparations were instead paid in goods such as coal
january 1923, French and Belgium troops occupied the Ruhr industrial region to appropriate coal
this led to a general strike supported by the government printing money that crippled national production and induced hyperinflation
consequence of hyperinflation
led to price inflation outrunning the growth in the quantity of paper which eventually created a shortage of money for transactions
shortage of money for transactions impact
gave the government an opportunity to bring the inflation under control by the issuance of a new revalued currency called the Rentenmark in October 1923
Dawes Plan year
1924
What did the Dawes Plan do?
ultimately facilitated currency stabilisation by the rescheduling of reparation payments and floating an international loan to make the first payment and enabled Germany to return to the gold standard with a new currency, the Reichsmark, at the old pre-war parity
What did the Dawes Plan consist of?
Ruhr Area to be evacuated by foreign troops
Reparation payments would begin at one billion marks the first year, increasing annually to two and half billion marks after five years
the Reichsbank to be reorganised under Allied supervision
the sources for the reparation money would include transportation taxes, excise and custom duties
Germany would be loaned 800 million marks from the US through a consortium of American investment banks
Impact of foreign lending on German economy
heavy reliance on mainly american loans left the economy vulnerable to the Wall Street Crash of 1929 and directly spread the Great Depression to Germany
political impact of hyperinflation
many people’s savings were wiped out, and many of those who lost their savings, commonly small businessmen and public servants, joined the Nazi Party in the early 1920s
desire for restoration of the Gold Standard
after the exhaustion of WW1, the major nations wanted to return to the pre-war stability of the gold standard - prior to the war, the international monetary system under the gold standard provided a conducive environment for the growth of foreign trade and foreign investment
when does a bimetallic standard work
works smoothly whilst the ratio between the values at which silver and gold was freely minted into coins approximated to the ratio of values in the international bullion market
what happens if silver and gold ratios diverge?
the metal with the higher international market value will flow out of a country in return for the lower value metal, eventually leaving it with only he lower value metal in circulation
major catalyst for the international adoption of the gold standard pre-war
the decision by a unified Germany to change from a silver to a gold standard
this was made possible by the larger war indemnity that France was forced to pay Germany on its defeat in the Franco-Prussian War
additionally decline in the value of silver
1878 gold standard
Belgium, Holland, France, Switzerland and Scandinavian countries joined Britain on the gold standard
US adoption of gold standard pre-war
the US did not officially adopt the gold standard until 1900, however, the resumption of convertibility of paper in 1879 meant it effectively operated on the gold standard via its bimetallic standard
external adjustment under the gold standard
called price-specie-flow mechanism
when the external account is in surplus, specie will flow in as net foreign payments and specie reserves will increase, inducing a lowering of interest rates, greater lending and a monetary expansion that will, in turn, raise income and prices of tradable goods. the higher prices relative to foreign goods will thereby lead to a turnaround in trade flows and a tendency toward external balance.
external adjustment in reality
relied on central bank management, especially by the Bank of England, with most foreign trade financed through London, its market providing international liquidity to smooth out external adjustments
crucial factor to the re-establishment of the pre-war international monetary policy
Britain’s return to the gold standard and London’s capital market resumes its central role in international finance
what happened to the british exchange rate in 1919
the wartime peg of the USD/pound exchange rate was abandoned so that it could fluctuate as a measure of progress
impact of abandonment of wartime peg
post-war boom caused a global price inflation that was quickly arrested by US Fed raising interest rates in 1920
1920 to 1923 value of pound to USD
By 1923 the pound had recovered from its low of US $3.60 in 1920 to reach US $4.60 but Britain had still not achieved parity on price competitiveness with the US
Keynes Opposition to Britain’s Return to the Gold Standard
argued that a return to the pre-war gold standard would require a persistent deflationary policy that would worsen the already high 10% unemployment
according to keynes, how much would unemployment need to fall by to bring about partity with the us
12%
Keynes’ alternative proposition
thought it would be wise to delay the return to gold until wage and price inflation in the US increased toward that existing in Britain
Keynes argued instead for a stimulatory monetary policy to revive British industry and reduce unemployment, which was incompatible with a return to the pre-war standard
British Treasury Argument
argued that unemployment could only be reduced by a worldwide recovery in trade for which stabilisation of the exchanges was a necessary precondition
further argued that Britain’s repayment of foreign creditors in full value pounds was necessary if London’s position as world’s premier capital and money market was to be restored
later commentators opinions on British return to gold standard
later commentators have asked why Britain did not seek to return to the gold standard at a lower exchange rate e.g. US$ 4.40
this may not have made much difference given that after Britain’s return to gold, France and Belgium deliberately fixed their franc currencies in 1926 at lower rates to advantage their export industries
implications of Britain’s return to the gold standard
Keynes was proved correct
continued deflationary policy to keep Britain on an over-valued currency led to persistent economic stagnation and unemployment until the Great Depression
Led to general strike
Britain failed to return to its dominant role in the international monetary system
when did Britain return to gold standard?
1925
Britain General Strike
1926 - British trade union movements resisted the attempt by employers to reduce the money wages of workers in established industries (beginning with coal mining)
British abandonment of gold standard
In 1931, in the midst of the Great Depression, Britain abandoned the gold standard as policymakers sought to independently stimulate the economy. This led to the collapse of the gold standard
restoration of gold standard post-war
by 1928 most nations returned to the gold standard so in appearance the international monetary system had been restored
what enabled post war recovery
the stabilisation of exchange rates and prices via, crucially, American loans
when did weimar germany reach its pre-war production?
by 1925, then proceeded to expand in the following years on the basis of a building construction boom
european economic boom
late 1920s up to 1929, started by building construction boom in germany
commodity prices in 1920s
decline in price as a result of the growth in global production outstripping its demand
1920s progress in agriculture
rapid technological progress with increased use of chemical fertilisers, mechanisation and improved methods for breeding plants and animals. development of combustion-powered tractor with ancillary apparatuses
raw material prices during war and immediately post-war
price rose considerably due to the strong demand for war materials and food, together with the loss of agricultural production in areas of europe devastated by conflict and occupation especially in France, Belgium and in central and eastern europe
impact of wartime prices on economies not directly involved in conflict
naturally encouraged global agricultural production
post-war impact on raw materials and agricultural prices
war-time demand for primary products declined at the same time as European supplies recovered and appeared on the market.
weak industrial expansion also contributed to low agricultural prices, rising farm debt and general distress for producers in the 1920s
led to increased protectionist measures for agriculture by primary producing countries
post-war impact on commodity exporting nations
By mid-1929 a number of commodity exporting nations that relied on capital inflow began to experience considerable foreign debt problems as international credit conditions tightened
- largely a result of the US Fed raising interest rates in 1928 and 1929
most defining event of the interwar period
great depression
when is great depression commonly understood to have started
1929
what marked the start of the great depression
collapse of stock prices on New York’s Wall street on Black Tuesday 29 October
how much did world gdp contract between 1929 and 1932
15%
peak unemployment in germany during great depression
30% in 1932
peak unemployment in US during great depression
25% by 1933
peak unemployment in Britain during great depression
15% in 1932
peak unemployment in Australia during great depression
29% in 1932
peak unemployment in Canada during great depression
27% in 1933
summary of impact of great depression in one sentence
had far-reaching implications for social, political and policymaking institutions and for international relations in the 1930s and beyond