Topic 3, 4, 5, 6: Singapore Legal System Flashcards
Regulation No. 3 provided for the setting up of a Magistracy and for legal administration. However, this Magistracy was never really constituted by Raffles. T/F?
True
Raffles formulated the Raffles Regulations in 1823. Why were these Regulations considered to be illegal today?
Raffles (who was Lieutenant-Governor of Bencoolen) only had powers to place the factory under Bencoolen’s control, not the entire island. His Treaty with the Sultan and Temenggong only permitted the establishment of a trading factory. Bencoolen was subordinate to the Bengal presidency, and the power to legislate resided with Calcutta (capital of Bengal).
If not for the Raffles Regulations, civil and criminal actions in Singapore would have to be dealt with in Calcutta. T/F?
True.
What was the main purpose of the Second Charter of Justice in 1826?
It extended the jurisdiction of the Recorder’s Court at Penang to Malacca, Singapore and all future dependencies of the Straits Government.
Recorder’s Court was now a circuit court.
The capital of the Straits government, Penang was also known as the Prince of Wales Island. T/F?
True
The Court in civil proceedings were to “give and pass Judgement and Sentence according to Justice and Right”. How were these words interpreted by the Recorder, Sir Peter Maxwell in the landmark case of Regina v Williams?
An instruction to apply English common law
What were the significant changes when the Straits Settlements became a Crown colony from 1867 onwards?
Supreme Court of the Straits Settlements replaced the individual courts of judicature
Legislative Council, a fully nominated and non-elected body was established
Executive Committee was created to advise the Governor
What were the roles within the Legislative Council?
Governor Chief Justice Officer commanding troops Colonial Secretary/General Colonial Engineer Attorney General Four unofficial Europeans
What was the very first legal system in Singapore?
The Raffles Regulations of 1823. Appointed Residents administered English law.
According to the Second Charter of Justice, in both civil and criminal proceedings, English law is applied. T/F?
True
According to the Second Charter of Justice what is the one caveat in applying English law in criminal proceedings?
The Second Charter stated that the court was ‘to administer criminal justice…due attention being had to the several religions, manners, and usages of the native inhabitants.”
In criminal proceedings the law can be amended to accommodate local customs. For example, some customs that would be illegal in England may not be found illegal in Singapore.
There were some laws passed in India that applied to Singapore in the past. T/F
True. From 1833 to 1867, the Governor-General in India (previously based in Bengal) in Council was the source of SG law. The British Parliament was also another source of law during this period.
What did the 3rd Charter of Justice of 1855 do?
The Court of Judicature now comprised of two divisions.
One consisted of the Recorder of Singapore and the Governor and Resident Councilor having jurisdiction over Singapore and Malacca.
The other consisted of the Recorder of Penang and the Governor or Resident Councillor of Penang and had jurisdiction over Penang and Province Wellesley.
In what year did the Japanese Occupation take place?
1942
Where was the law-making body that created SG laws between 1833 to 1867 located?
It was once in the city Bengal (Bengal Presidency), then later it was in India (Governor-General of India).
Who was the first Recorder of the Court of Judicature?
Sir John Claridge
Why was the Court of Judicature considered a circuit court?
The Recorder was based in Penang and he travelled on circuit to Malacca and Singapore to hear cases. He was assisted by the Resident Councilors and the Governor.
Why was English law applied in Singapore after the Second Charter of Justice?
The Second Charter was to ‘give and pass Judgement and Sentence according to Justice and Right’.
R v Williams interpreted the words to mean that it was English law to be applied.
When was the Second Charter of Justice implemented?
1826 / 1827
Note: From 1826 - 1833 (the year the Government of India Act was passed), the British Parliament was likely the only source of any legislation.)
When was the Third Charter of Justice implemented?
1855
What were the reasons for implementing the Third Charter?
People were unhappy because:
The Recorders did not come frequently enough to Singapore.
The judgements of the lay judges were bad.
What happened to law in Singapore during the Japanese Occupation.
The civil courts closed shortly, and they reopened. They implemented English law as long as it did not interfere with Japanese military administration.
If the President decided to veto a Supply Bill which drew on past reserves, what could Parliament do?
They could veto the veto with a 2/3 parliamentary majority
What are the qualifications for becoming a President?
- Singapore citizen
- At least 45 y/o
- Has been a resident no less than 10 years prior to the date of nomination for election
- Must not be disqualified to be a MP (cannot hold office of profit, be a bankrupt, have unsound mind, or been convicted of an offence and sentenced to imprisonment for not less than one year or to a fine not less than $2000)
- Satisfies the Presidential Elections Committee to be of integrity, good character and reputation
- Is not a member of any political party on the date of his nomination for election
- Has met either the private or public sector requirement
Singapore’s first elected President was…
Ong Teng Cheong
In most Westminister governments, the head of state is just a figurehead and acts on the advice of the PM. T/F
True
The elected President has more power than the traditional head of state. But the elected President has less power than the President in the US system.
True
In the Westminister system, the head of the Executive is the Prime Minister. T/F
True
In the US system, the head of the Executive is the President. T/F
True
What are the qualifications of an Attorney-General?
- Qualified for appointment as a Supreme Court judge
When appointing a new Attorney-General other than reason of the death of the previous holder or the removal of the previous holder from office, the PM will first consult the existing Attorney-General and further consult the Chief Justice and the Chairman of the Public Service Commission before tendering advice to the President. True?
True
What are the two functions of the Attorney-General?
- Advise the government on legal matters and perform other such duties of legal character
- Institute, conduct, or discontinue any proceedings for any offence at her/his own discretion
The President can veto a decision by the Prime Minister on appointment of Attorney-General. T/F?
True
The Attorney-General need not be an MP. T/F?
True
What are the qualifications of a Supreme Court Judge?
- No less than 10 years as a Qualified Person or
2. No less than 10 years as a member of the Singapore Legal Service
A Supreme Court has guaranteed tenure until the age of 65 years or no later than 6 months after the age of 65, if the President may approve. True or False
True
The President has discretion in the appointment of the Prime Minister and other Ministers
True
Before the constitution was amended, the President was elected by the Parliament by a majority vote. True or false?
True
Which of the following is true?
I. The government wanted the President to be a safeguard of Singapore’s substantial financial reserves
II. The government wanted a President who could be removed from office by a Parliament with 2/3 majority
III. The government feared that a populist government would go unchecked
IV. The President was to secure the integrity of the civil service
V. The government wanted the President to present a kind of adversarial check on the government
I, III, IV
Which of the following is true?
I. The Attorney General takes advice from the Prime Minister when deciding on whether or not the AGC should prosecute MOE for failing to protect the safety of students during P.E
II. Due to a conflict with an event company, the Minister of Foreign Affairs is considering a litigation against the company. The Minister goes to the Attorney-General for advice on litigation.
III. The Government wants to draft a new piece of legislation. It asks the AGC to help with writing the legislative details.
IV. The Attorney General is part of the Executive
V. The Attorney General may sit with the Cabinet occasionally
II
III
IV
Which of the following is true?
I. Parliament is holding a motion to pass a Supply Bill. NMP Sim is able to vote for it.
II. Parliament is holding a motion to pass a Supplementary supply bill. NMP Sim is able to vote for it.
III. Nominated Members of Parliament can vote to remove the President from Office
IV. Nominated Members of Parliament can vote to amend the Constitution.
V. There can be up to 8 NMPs in Parliament
VI. NMPs can vote in a vote of no confidence
ALL LIES.
NMPS CANNOT VOTE FOR SUPPLY BILLS.
CANNOT REMOVE PRESIDENT.
CANNOT AMEND CONSTY,
CANNOT REMOVE PAP.
MAX. 9 NMPS.
Since 2017, there can be up to 12 Non-constituency Members of Parliament (NCMP)
True
In addition to the 5 Opposition members who were elected into Parliament, there can be an additional 12 NCMPs for a total of 17 non-PAP members.
False
Which of the following is true?
I. There can be up to 6 members in a group contesting in a GRC
II. There is no minimum limit to the members contesting for election as a group in a GRC.
III. At least one of the candidates in every group must be a person belonging to a Malay community or, Indian or other communities
I, III
Must have at least 3 in a group.
Elected President is an alternative center of power. T/F?
False. Law Minister had to speak out and say that it was not an alternative center of power.
Elected President is an alternative center of power. T/F?
False. Law Minister had to speak out and say that it was not an alternative center of power.
A NCMP has all the voting privileges of a normal MP. T/F?
Yes, since the Constitution was amended in 2016.
Changes to the Constitution and Parliamentary Elections Act passed in 2010 guarantee a minimum of nine opposition MPs in Parliament after the polls. T/F?
True. But this was changed in 2017. From 2017, there can be up to 12 NCMPs.
NCMPs must get at least 15% of the valid votes. T/F?
True.
Which of the following is true?
I. Singapore follows the UK style of drafting. This means that it tries to cover all possible situations and contingencies.
II. Singapore follows the UK style of drafting. This means that it applies common law principles.
III. Singapore follows the UK style of drafting. This means that the judge does not interpret the legislation because it is already clearly set out
IV. Singapore follows the UK style of drafting. This means that courts do not fill in gaps in the legislation.
V. Singapore follows the UK style of drafting. This means the legislation will tend to be more complicated to a layman.
I
V.
Statute is meant to be distinct from common law.
Courts must still interpret the legislation if there is ambiguity (legislation may not be perfectly drafted)
Courts CANNOT fill in gaps in legislation. They can only interpret what the words already say.