Topic 12 Asset Market Efficiency and Behavioural Finance Flashcards
What is the principle underlying behavioural finance?
- Behavioural finance is saying investors are irrational and makes all kinds of mistakes makes opportunities for smart investors
How do asset prices change based on information?
- Prices respond to changes in expectations
- Changes in expectations arise from new information
- Therefore, asset prices change as new information arrives
What is the efficient market hypothesis?
‘In an efficient market, security prices fully reflect all available information.’
What does informational efficiency depend on?
a. The type of information is reflected
b. The speed with which new information is reflected - Market rationality
What are the consequences of trading on the basis of information?
a. The first investors to trade make a profit
b. The trading process causes security prices to reflect the information uncovered by market participants
What are the types of information?
- Historical
- Publicly available information
- Private information
What is historical data?
Trading data such as past prices and volumes. People will use the past data to forecast future movement
What is publicly available information?
- Financial statements, announcements, news
- Eg. quarterly reports, annual reports
- These news such as journals, or articles not from the company
What is private information?
- Inside information known to company management but not yet made public
- People who work inside the company are not allowed to trade with this information
o e.g. research data, takeover bid, UNEXPECTED earnings - Private assessment of public information
o e.g. analyst reports firm specific information
Why are we interested in market efficiency?
If market prices reflect only information of a particular type, then we can profit from trading on information not yet reflected in prices. We want to know to what degree the market is efficient to evaluate our trading strategy
What is weak form efficiency?
Prices reflect all information contained in the record of past prices and volumes
What’s the process of changes in price mvoement from access to new information?
a. Traders might have access to new information, and begin to reveal that information by the effect on prices
b. Perceiving a price trend, other market participants may transact in an attempt to profit from the new information
c. This speeds up the impounding of the information revealed by the initial price movement subsequent movements after the initial information has been impounded will be random
What is technical analysis?
Analysing past prices and volumes to predict future prices. Technical analysis involves using charts of a security’s historical prices or levels to forecast its future trends
Why is technical analysis not the best method?
‘Tomorrow’s prices should be independent of today’s prices’
If a market is weak form efficient, technical analysis is not profitable.
It should not be possible to make consistent profits from trading rules set up to detect and trade on the basis of price trends
What is the filter rule?
A commonly used trading rule is a filter rule, where the ‘filter’ represents a set percentage by which a stock must rise or fall in order to trigger a ‘buy’ or ‘sell’ signal, respectively
a. Buy if the stock rises X% from its previous lowest price
b. Sell if the stock falls X% from its previous highest price
What is the logic behind the filter rule?
The assumption behind this trading rule is that the trend identified will continue. Future price movements can be inferred from past prices.
What is semi-strong form efficiency?
Prices fully reflect all publicly available information
What are some features of semi-strong form efficiency?
a. A semi strong form efficient market must also be weak form efficient because historic prices and volumes are publicly available information.
b. Asset prices react immediately to the release of any new information that is made public
What is fundamental analysis?
Fundamental analysis: a practice of using financial statements, announcements and other publicly available information about firms to pick stocks.
What is an example of when semi-strong form efficiency is valid?
An Example: Suppose ABC’s stock only jumps to $104:
* A price of $104 does not accurately reflect all the available information.
* We can make trading profits by buying ABC at $104 and holding until
a. The market realizes we are right, or
b. ABC pays out (in dividends or stock buybacks) the value of the research success.
* Buying at the open at $104 you can profit an abnormal return when it will have a fair value of $110
* Either you buy at the fair value or the market is not efficient and you can buy below the fair value
What is strong form efficiency?
All available information is fully reflected in current prices
What are some features of strong form efficiency?
a. A strong form efficient market must also be semi strong and weak form efficient because publicly available information as well as historic prices and volumes are a subset of all available information
b. Asset prices should reflect private information (private assessment of public info and inside info)
What is an example of strong form efficiency?
- Stock ABC Biotech’ s closing price yesterday $100.
- You work for a stock brokerage company and received a large buy order for ABC’s stocks from a client (a fund) with private information.
- You learned that ABC has got better than expected trial results (extra value=$10 per share).
- You begin to buy ABC’s stock at $100 (house trading to maximise your own profits) prices keep going up as you buy.
- You stop buying when price reaches $110, reflecting private information.
What are tests of market efficiency?
a. Are trading rules using past prices profitable? –> to test weak form: if you can make profit, then it’s not weak form
b. Do prices react rapidly to information around particular events? –> to test semi strong form
c. Is it possible for investors to profit from private information? –> strong form, if it does work then it violates strong form efficiency
d. Can active fund managers outperform their benchmarks?–> if they have access to private assessment and public information, if they can generate abnormal returns it violates strong form efficiency