TINA and Price and Cost Analysis Flashcards
What is the basic reference guide for Government pricing?
Contract Pricing Reference Guides (CPRG’s)
What are the three elements of the Basic Pricing Policy?
(1) Purchase from responsible sources at fair & reasonable prices
(2) Price each contract separately & independently
(3) Exclude contingencies
What are the two components of pricing each contract separately?
(1) Perspective
(2) Government contracting
What are the conflicting perspectives under pricing each contract separately?
The seller’s position might be that the firm lost money on the last contract so that an effort needs to be made to make up for that loss on the next contract
The buyer’s position might be that the contractor made too much profit on the last contract so the next contract should be structured to restrict profit
What is a contingency?
A contingency is a possible future event or condition arising from presently known or unknown causes and the outcome cannot be determined at the present time
What are the two types of contingencies?
(1) Contingencies can arise from permanently known and existing conditions with the effects of these conditions to be foreseeable within reasonable limits of accuracy
(2) Contingencies can arise from known or unknown conditions, where the effects cannot be measured to provide equitable results to the contractor and the government
Type of Contingency of Foreseeable within reasonable limits of accuracy affect contract price how?
- INCLUDED in contract cost estimates to make those estimates as accurate as possible
Example: Cost of rejects/Cost of defective work
Type of Contingency that Cannot be measured so precisely as to provide equitable results to the contractor and to the government affect contract price how?
- EXCLUDED from the cost estimates under the several items of cost
- DISCLOSED SEPERATELY (Including the basis on which the contingency is computed) to facilitate the negotiation to appropriate contract coverage
Example: Results of pending litigation/costs of volatile material price changes
What is the Truth in Negotiations Act (TINA)?
It is a Public Law that was enacted in 1962 to place the Government on equal footing with the contractor with respect to negotiating contracts and modifications
Requires contractors to give the Government “cost and pricing data” as a “surrogate” In the absence of normal market forces (competition) to determine fair and reasonable prices
What is the dollar threshold for TINA?
$700,000
Define Price Analysis
Analyzes prices in their entirety
The process of examining and evaluating a proposed price to determine if it is fair and reasonable, without evaluating its separate cost elements and proposed profit
Define Cost Analysis
Analyzes prices by reviewing the individual elements of cost (price) & the appropriateness & necessity of each element of cost
Cost analysis is the review and evaluation of the separate cost elements and proposed profit/fee of an offeror’s certified cost and pricing data or data other than certified cost and pricing data
Define Cost Realism Analysis
Independently reviewing cost elements to determine are they realistic for the work to be performed
Cost realism analysis is the process of independently reviewing and evaluating specific elements of each offeror’s proposed cost estimate to determine whether the estimated proposed cost elements:
Are realistic for the work to be performed
Reflect a clear understanding of work
Are consistent with the unique methods of performance and materials described in the offeror’s technical performance
Price Analysis is required:
You must use price analysis to determine if a price is fair and reasonable when an offeror is not required to provide certified cost and pricing data
Everytime
Cost Analysis is required:
When TINA applies, you must use cost analysis
Cost Realism Analysis is required:
Cost realism is required for all cost type contracts
Cost realism may be used for fixed price contracts when:
New requirements may not be fully understood by competing offerors
There are quality concerns
Past experience on the contractor yields quality or service shortfalls
When would it be appropriate to use a price analysis?
May include evaluation of data OTHER THAN certified cost or pricing data
If cost or pricing data is not required
When would it be appropriate to use a cost analysis?
May be used to evaluate data OTHER THAN certified cost or pricing data to determine cost reasonableness or in performing cost realism analysis
If certified cost or pricing data is required
The types of price analysis methods that are the most preferred are:
Comparison of prices received in response to the solicitation (COMPETITION)
Comparison of previously proposed prices with current proposed prices for the same or similar items
The types of price analysis methods are:
Price Analysis
Cost Analysis
Cost Realism Analysis
When is TINA required?
Cost analysis shall be used when certified cost or price data are not required (TINA APPLIES)
What types of items does a technical analysis review?
material and labor
Types & quantities of material Types & quantities of labor hours Labor mix Pertinent technical aspects Processes Special tooling Equipment Real property Scrap &/or spoilage
Can cost and price analysis be used together?
Yes, it’s a matter of decision
Cost analysis may also be used to evaluate data to determine cost reasonableness or cost realism when a fair & reasonable price cannot be determined through price analysis alone for commercial or non-commercial items
Which type of cost estimating method should a contractor use?
In general, an offeror may use any generally accepted estimating method that is equitable and consistently applied
What are the three types of cost estimating methods?
(1) Round Table
(2) Comparison
(3) Detailed
Round Table cost estimating method pros and cons are:
Strength: Can be used with limited data
Weaknesses: Lack of data
Increases variability between estimators and true costs