Theories Of Religion Assessmnet FC Flashcards
What do functionalist Argue about society
Society most basic need is for social order + solidarity. So members can cooperate
Possible through value consensus which stops people from pursuing their own selfish desires + stops society from disintegrating
How is religion linked to functionality views of society
Religion crates and maintains VC, order and solidarity
What is the key feature of religion according Durkheim
Distinction between the sacred (symbols with holy meaning) and the prophane (mundane)
Religion involves sacred rituals in a collective have powerful meaning
Example of durkheims scared and profane
Arunta clans perform rituals involving the worship of sacred totems. Reinforce groups solidarity and sense of belonging. Sacred symbols represent society’s collective conscience
Rituals reinforce this
What does collective conscience mean
Shared norms and values that make cooperation between individuals possible without this society will disintegrate
How does the scared symbols represent society’s collective conscience
Participating in shared rituals binds individuals together reminding them that they are part of a community which they owe their loyalty
Makes us feel part of something great which performs as a function to motivate us to overcome obstacles
What are the cognitive functions of religion
Durkheim sees religion as a source of this for two reasons
- fulfils our intellectual and cognitive capabilities = ability to reason and think conceptually
- religion created categories eg time space
what is the evaluation of Durkeheim on religion
- postmodernists argue it cant be applied to contemporary society no longer a single shared value system ie Giddens and Beck- individualisation thesis
- secondary research - unreliable
what does Malinowski argue about psychological functions
agrees with Durkheim that religion promotes solidarity but in his way it is by performing psychological functions
two types of situations in which it performs this role
1. uncontrollable + uncertain situation
ie study of Trobriander islanders. differs between lagoon fishing (safe, no ritual) + ocean fishing (dangerous/ uncertain accompied by canoe magic- ritual to ensure safe expedition) gives confidence in hazardous situations
2. at times of life crisis
minimises disruption caused by birth/death eg funeral rituals reinforce solidarity
what is Malinowski evaluation
emphasises positive functions of religion religion ie social solidarity but it neglects negative aspects of ie source of oppression for women and poor
what does parsons argue (values and meaning)
parsons agrees with Malinowski that religion helps individual cope with uncontrollable outcomes
in addition performs two essential functions that religion performs
- religion creates and legitimates society’s central values by sacralising them eg USA sacralised American values ie meritocracy. promotes VC + social stability
- provides a source of meaning by answering ultimate questions ie life and death
evaluation of parsons theory
ignores religion as a source of division + conflict especially where is more than one religion ie Huntington religious differences between civilisation are major source of conflict
what does Bellah argue about civil religion
like parsons is interested in what unifies society
argues that civil religion unifies multi faith societies eg USA does this by attaching sacred qualities to society
involves loyalty to the nation state + belief in God ie expressed in ritual of singing the national anthem
sacralise American way of life + binds american togther from many different ethnic backgrounds + religious backgrounds
evaluation of civil religion
- conflict with the substantive definition of religion as this does not include a belief in the supernatural
- also ignores conflict between ethnicities as the BLM movement cause a divide in America
what are the Marxist main theories
see society as divided into classes, capitalist class exploit WC. Exploitation can be overcome when WC become conscious of their exploitation and unite to overthrow capitalism. There will be no need for religion in classless society so it will disappear