Theories Flashcards
Marxist Perspective: Overview
- Religion is an illusion and instrument of oppression.
- The rise of industrial capitalism led to religion being taken over by the bourgeoisie - incorporated into RCI.
- It distorts people’s perception, justifies the status quo and props up capitalism.
- It produces a false consciousness by offering the illusion of hope.
Marx’s Quote on Religion
“Religion is the sigh of the oppressed creature, the sentiment of a heartless world and the soul of soulless conditions. It is the opium of the people.”
Marxist Perspective: How does religion dull the pain of oppression? (1)
- It promises a paradise of eternal bliss after death.
- ENGELS: Main world religions all present a vision of heaven which makes suffering on earth bearable.
- It encourages followers to anticipate something better.
Marxist Perspective: How does religion dull the pain of oppression? (2)
- Makes a virtue out of suffering produced by oppression.
- Followers are encouraged to endure oppression and promised a reward.
- “It is easier for a camel to pass through the eye of a needle than for a rich man to enter the kingdom of heaven.”
Marxist Perspective: How does religion dull the pain of oppression? (3)
- It offers hope of supernatural intervention.
- Followers are offered hope of a better future.
- Encouraged to believe that social change will happen through prayer not individual authorship.
Marxist Perspective: How does religion dull the pain of oppression? (4)
- It justifies the social order.
- Followers are encouraged to believe that God created and ordained the social structure - sacred support to the status quo.
- To change the social order would be blasphemous.
- “Rich man in his castle, poor man at his gate, God made them high and lowly and ordered their estate.” - All Things Bright & Beautiful
Examples to SUPPORT Marxism
- CoE retains political, social and economic influence - Conservative Party.
- Catholic Church exercises influence over people especially in Third World countries.
- Eastern Europe - Christian churches supported the overthrow of capitalism.
Neo-Marxism: Gramsci (1971)
- He was aware of control over consciousness that the Catholic Church had.
- He was critical of the church’s characteristic subservience to the state and ruling class interests.
- He, also, claimed that during historical periods, religions emerged which supported the interests of oppressed classes.
Neo-Marxism: Maduro (1982)
- He rejects notion that religion is always a conservative force - potential to be revolutionary.
- He accepts that in societies where religion is dominant, social liberation can only be achieved if significant changes occur.
- He looks to Latin America - Catholic Church is conservative however liberation theology emerged.
Neo-Marxism: Liberation Theology
- A movement in the 1960s in the Catholic Church.
- Strong commitment to the poor and against military dictatorships.
- Priests criticised the bourgeoisie and helped workers fight oppression.
Neo-Marxism: Marxist Response to Liberation Theology
- The movement has lost influence.
* Pope John Paul II condemned Liberation Theology arguing it was too close to Marxism.
Neo-Marxism: Turner (1983)
- Draws on historical evidence.
- In feudal times the peasantry were indifferent to religion.
- Religion played an important part in the lives of the ruling class.
Limitations of Marxist Theory: Hosking (1988)
- HOSKING points out before the revolution there were more than 50,000 Russian orthodox churches but only 4,000 in 1939.
- LANE argues that HOSKING’S figures don’t support the idea that religion has declined.
- Research suggests that religion remained important even in a communist society.
Limitations of Marxist Theory: Cuba
- Communism still flourishes in Cuba yet so does religion.
- In 1988 Fidel Castro acknowledged this by inviting Pope John Paul II.
- The Pope was met by large crowds suggesting RC remained strong even in a communist society.
Functionalism: Malinowski (1954)
- Religion reinforces social norms and promotes social solidarity.
- He emphasises the psychological functions of religion in certain situations.
Functionalism: Malinowski (Time of Life Crisis)
- Events e.g. birth, puberty and death.
* Religion can defuse the notion of crisis at these times.
Functionalism: Malinowski (Uncontrollable & Uncertain Events)
• Unpredictable events are often preceded by rituals to reduce anxiety e.g. ritual of ‘canoe magic’ before fishing in the ocean - Trobriand islanders.
Functionalism: Parsons (Primary Source of Meaning)
- Religion provides people with explanations for uncontrollable/contradictory events e.g. why do good people suffer?
- Events defy our sense of justice and make life appear meaningless - could undermine commitment to society’s values.