Theories Flashcards
Actor & Affected
In fiction, there tends to be a key difference between genders in who is presented as an actor vs. who is affected by an action. Men tend to be the actors, whereas women tend to be the affected.
Marked Terms
The form of the word that stands out from the norm (eg. ‘hostess’ instead of ‘host’)
Semantic Derogation
Sara Mills in the 1990s described terms for women that have more negative connotations than their male counterparts, etc ‘governor’ vs ‘governess’, ‘king’ vs ‘queen’, ‘master’ vs ‘mistress’, ‘bachenlor’ vs ‘spinster’, ‘lord’ vs ‘lady’
Pronouns and Generic Terms
It is now not commonly acceptable to use male pronouns generically, and we are trying to move away from ‘the male as the norm’
Trudgill (70s)
Men tend to use more non-standard pronunciation, and also claim to use non-standard forms more than they actually do
Lakoff (60s)
Deficit approach; women’s language is inferior due to the process of socialisation. Factors of ‘women’s language’ include: specialist vocabulary centred around domestic chores, extra words for colours, weak expletives, empty adjectives, tag questions, more polite forms/euphemisms, hedges and intensifiers.
Janet Holmes
Tag questions are used to aid discussion/appear polite rather than necessarily a weakness (challenges Lakoff)
O’Barr and Atkins
Features of Lakoff’s research appear both in women and men of lower social class, therefore they adopted the term ‘powerless language’ over ‘women’s language’
Zimmerman and West
Observed that more interruptions are made by men and that women have restricted linguistic freedom (dominance approach)
Jennifer Coates
All female talk is essentially co-operative and designed to negotiate and support. Men and women have two different sub-cultures. (difference approach)
Jane Pilkington
Women aim for positive politeness strategies, and men are less complimentary and supportive (difference approach)
Koenraad Kuiper
Men pay less attention to saving face and use insults to suggest solidarity (difference approach)
Deborah Tannen
Male-female talk is “cross-cultural”
Overt vs Covert Prestige
Seeking overt prestige leads to use of standard English; covert prestige is the opposite
Deborah Tannen & Differences
Men seek status/independence; women are interested in forming bonds; men give direct orders and don’t mind entering conflict; women give polite indirect orders to avoid conflict; men are interested in gaining factual information and solving problems; women want to show understanding by compromising and offering support rather than solving problems