Themes Flashcards
In which book is it argued that it doesn’t matter how educated one is, because both educated and uneducated are very capable of learning from and fulfilling God’s desires?
Libro de las Profecias, Christopher Columbus
In what book does a character justify his previous conquests by saying his capabilities and desires for completing the sailing trip are given by God?
Libro de las Profecias, Christopher Columbus
In which book do the people rejoice and thank God when they see land?
The Voyage of Christopher Columbus
In which book does the navigator lie to his crewmembers about how far they have gone?
The Voyage of Christopher Columbus
Who claims that it will be easier to convert the indigenous people to Christianity by being kind and friendly to them than to try and force them into it?
Christopher Columbus
Who used a divide and conquer method to pit the native tribes against each other?
Cortes
Which two people had to deal with discontent from the sailors working for them and lied to them?
Columbus and Cortes
Which tribe surrenders to Cortes and works for him to defeat Tenochtitlan?
The Tlaxcalans
How does Cortes justify the brutality against the natives?
Claiming the indigenous people deceived and attacked him (unreliable narrator), claims amazing military odds by saying that God was on his side and supports the conquest, focusing on material and wealth gain
Who compares Tenochtitlan to Spanish cities like Granada and why?
Cortes, to justify his travels and the decisions he made were worthwhile
Discuss Montezuma in Cortes:
Lack of resistance, Montezuma gives big pompous speech to Cortes, he tears down all the idols and they accept, Montezuma is captured, Montezuma knew the size of Cortes’ forces and knew he had allied with the Tlaxcalans from sending out messengers/spies and was frightened
Which Spaniard does Cortes fight while in Mexico?
Navarez
How does Cortes describe Montezuma’s death?
He makes it very uncertain how he died, to try and make it unclear whether they or the native people killed him.
In what ways is Cortes an unreliable narrator?
Minimized his role in attacking the natives, likely overestimated how well he did in fights, covers up cause of rebellion
Why is the Florentine Codex being written?
To preserve the language of the native people and highlight the trustworthy indigenous perspective
What are some examples of omens?
things begin burning without someone actually setting it on fire, lakes boiling,
people having visions, birds, people who were disfigured, lightning while it was barely raining, volcano, comet.
How does Montezuma try to gather intel on Cortes?
sends many people to spy on the Spanish, contradicting Cortes’ narrative
which says that the native people were naive. He also sends witches and soothsayers to try and test/stop Cortes. They give Cortes gifts, hoping to appease him and that he will leave.
Discuss the intricacies in the idea that the natives thought of Cortes as a god
“Teotl” means god/divinity. “Hombre dios” is another word used to describe a
“god-man,” which is different from a god. Even though the Cortes account indicates that they thought of him as a god, this isn’t necessarily true since they have different words they use to refer to him. It is also worth noting that they dress him up as Quetzalcoatl, who was a human who became a god.
Describe the Spanish encounter with the Tlaxcalans from the indigenous point of view
The Otomi were a group the Tlaxcalans hired to fight for them who initially came up against Cortes. After seeing how this encounter went, they decided to ally with Cortes. They manipulate him to slaughter the Chuluans for them and have a common enemy with Cortes in Montezuma
What is the general indigenous sentiment around Montezuma in Tenochtitlan?
Montezuma is nervous about Cortes and the public turns on him; they see him as weak and stop obeying his orders and treating him as king, which explains why they are rude to him and burn his body after he dies
How does the start of fighting at Tenochtitlan actually happen?
The Spanish ask the Mexica to celebrate a festival. When they are distracted and all together, the Spanish massacre them. This isn’t included in the Cortes account
How does the indigenous account treat Montezuma’s death?
They mention he is dead but not how he dies. He is burned and in disgrace during the funeral, in contrast to the nobleman from Tlatelolco
How does Tenochtitlan fall?
Battle shifts in favor of the Spanish because of smallpox and famine. The Mexica surrender and ask to pay a tribute. The Spanish loot
What is the name of Cortes’ interpreter?
Mariana
Why are the omens included at the beginning? What does this have to do with how and where the text was written?
This is the only (out of six) indigenous text where Montezuma is displayed as helpless and omens occur. It was written from Tlatelolco with their perspective. It makes sense that they might want to blame things going wrong on Tenochtitlan and Moteuccoma while leaving their own people blameless. The omens might be to help come to terms with the fact that they were doomed, so no matter what they did they wouldn’t have been able to win. Again, shifts blame off the Mexica and towards god/universe.