The Supreme Court and Civil Rights Flashcards
what are the 4 most recent courts up to present
Warren (1953-69)
Burger (69-86)
Rehnquist (86-‘05)
Roberts (‘05-)
who did Obama appoint to the Supreme Court
Sonia Sotomayor
Elena Kagan
who did Donald Trump appoint to the Supreme court
Neil Gorsuch
Brett Kavanaugh
strict constructionist/originalist
interpret strictly/literally
stress rentention of states rights
which judges would be classed as strict constructionists
Roberts
Thomas
Gorsuch
Alito
loose constructionist
interprets constitution less literally
stress broad power to federal gov
living constitution
dynamic, take into account contemporary views
put in context
what did Scalia say about the constitution
‘not meant to facilitate change’
who favours a living constitution
Kagan
Sotomayor
why is capital punishment controversial in regards to controversial
constitution says ban on ‘cruel and unusual punishment’
originalist-capital punishment was around at the time+accepted so not what this is talking about
what are the 5 stages of the appointments process
- vacancy occurs
- president searches for nominees
- announce nominee
- confirmation hearing
- debate+vote
how many vacancies have been filled on the supreme court since 1789
119
=1 every 2 years
Trump 2
Carter none
how can the judges on the supreme court be described
echo chamber where earlier where views from earlier decades can still be heard
e.g Kennedy appointed by Reagan-stayed on court 30yrs after Reagan left
what posts do SC judges often hold before becoming a justice
federal judge
where can presidents looks for sc nominations
state courts ('81 sandra day o'connor Arizona) department of justice (Kagan general solicitor '10)
which part of the announcement process of SC court judges has become tradition
American Bar Association standing committee rate them
well q,q,not q
who was the only recent SC judge not to be given a well qualified rating by ABA
Clarence Thomas
qualified
the SC nomination confirmation process
stand before Senate Judiciary committee
hearings wi witnesses support or oppose
vote on it
what happens if the hearing is going badly for the SC nominee
withdraw
2005 Harriet Miers
what happens if the vote is close or lost
likely to be defeated
1987 Robert Bork
42-58
examples of unanimous approvals of SC justices
Ruth Ginsburg
how many nominees has the senate rejected since 1789
12
confirmed 125
what are the 3 main problems with the appointments process
politisicisation of media, congress and president
what kind of appointments are republican presidents likely to make
conservative justice
literal+strict view of constitution
what is the ‘litmus test’ that presidents do to justices
scrutinise their previous judgements
espeically on abortion,affirmitive action+captial punishment
example of politicisation of senate when choosing a justice
defeat of Robert Bork
TV ad against him=$15mill
interest groups against his nom e.g national abortion rights action league
how did Clarence Thomas describe the senate part of nomination process
‘circus’ ‘national disgrace’
Thomas did lack qualifications, but hearing focused on sexual harrassment accusations+conservative philosophy
evidence to show partisan politicisation of nominations in the senate
Thomas
only 11 dems voted in favour
2 repubs against
what are ‘soft questions’
asked from senators of presidents party
not rlly trying to scrutinise nomination
this way pres can get anyone through
how much money was spent during Alito’s nomination process to shape public opinion on him
$2 mill
what is the flaw with the scrutiny of the nomination process
attempt to embarass/expose people
qualified people less likely want to stand
don’t get best possible justice
what does the refusal of Merrick Garland’s nomination show
politicisation
wait for Obama to leave office
if repub pres gets in they can pick
unprecedented
how did Edward Lazarus describe nominations to the court
‘election campaigns for political control of the court’
how did the media politicise clarence thomas’ nomination
didn’t focus on his qualification
focused on sexual harrassment