The State Flashcards
Weber’s main objecives
state digtates how force is used (monopo0ly) happens within a certain piece of land, within that space there is only one body that can use force.
communty, territoy, force, legimitacy
Migdal
if we think something is legit we dont need to be forced, it is implied that we know to follow the rules
state as a structure creates rules for all, will use force if necessary
if everyone follows rules then state doesnt have to use force, rules force us to have a certain way
Hobbes view of human nature, state of nature, and solution
need ordet bc we are”
vain
competitive
equal
State nature:
Solution:
leviathan: in order tos stop kilinng each ther and live a happy life, give up our entire bodiily autonomy to a group of people to have total authority over us.
Tilly’s theory if State Building
1)land was scarce and valiable more land meant more wealth
2) to gain money an dpiwer we need to invade neighbors land
3) to wage, aka, protect ourseles we need to build an amry
4) to raise armies we need loyaly and money form people.
5) ti fain legitimacy and money they offered rights sense of shared idenity
war made the state and state made the wa
Coercion and Capital
coercion: raise taxes gov spends on services for people
capital: maintinas peace, protect use force for sake of mnoey and for economy to continue
Defining and measuring legitimacy
legitimacy is how well citizens are willing to follow rules without coercion everyone is on the same level, none is above others.
Marien and Hooghe’s: Political Trust and Legal Permissiveness
legal persmissiveness is the willingness to do illegal things:
they found that the less politiical truat the more likey people were to do illegal things through self reports
How the use of force relates to legitimacy
if the state has to use force then it is not legitimate, force is implied alreayd but needed to be used.
State use of force
set of rules; define appropriate rules
surveillamce: monoitring rules being broken
only then use force to punish if rules are broken
if systems are done right then we should not really see force being used
threat of violence keeps in in check
relationship force and legitimacy?
does not really reflect how much crime there is, but it does seem to influence trust in police and legimitacy
Lowatcharin and
Stallmann’s study of decentralization and trust
hey looked at not the amound of police but the types of police, wanted to see does the amount of decentrilization result in less or more trust?
decentrilization: the more tiers there are in systems, the more decentrilized it is.
this relationship is conditional. only some times is this relationship present, under certain conditions.
only present in rucg countries. why? because rich countries tend to have more resources, better quality, better police because of the money they hold to make these systems high quality.
Hanson and Sigman’s: measure state capacity, including its distinct dimension
essential functions
distangle these functions how are they different
figure out how to measure each function
3 functions:
extraction : tsking resources from the people, raise revenue through taxes
coercion: pressure protect people, state uses forceful violence to keep people in check
administration: regularize things, develop policies to regulate peoples lives
Measuring extractive capacity
not the outcomes, but instead how are the expectations meeting the outcomes
Different definitions and measures of democracy
minimalist vs maxamalist:
min: meeting basic criteria, just elections
max: more complicated things to be considered a democracy, elections representation
practical vs institutional
practical: looks at how laws are being incorperated what is actually happening in pracice
institutional: rules set on paper, what rules do each country have
Measuring Democracy
minmalist: DDI, code 1 if all expectations are met then they get a 1
max: VDEM, the variety of democracy uses many and ALL different questions, hundreds of them
Institutional: polity score, counting democratic and autocratic institutions: just picks up the rules, surface level. but can be the best
practical: freedom house, ask experts to ask experts to see how laws play out in practice