The role and powers of devolved bodies in the UK and the impact of this devolution on the UK Flashcards

1
Q

What is devolution ?

A
  • The dispersal of power but not sovereignty within a political system
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
2
Q

What is asymmetrical devolution ?

A
  • A type of devolution where various regions have been granted unequal amounts of power
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
3
Q

What did the 2006 government of Wales act do ?

A
  • Provision for further powers in 20 key areas to be transferred from Westminster to Wales, if this was requested through a referendum
  • ## 2011 : 64% voted to confirm that further devolution was preferred (including healthcare, education, transport and the environment)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
4
Q

What did the 2011 Welsh devolution referendum also do and when was their influence shown ?

A
  • Creation of the silks commission which investigated the ways in which financial powers could be devolved and how it would better meet the needs of the people
  • 2012 : commission proposed the transference of the tax-raising measure to give it eventual control in raising 25% of its annual budget (Adopted in 2014)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
5
Q

When did the Welsh assembly officially become the Welsh Parliament ?

A
  • May 2020

- Known as Senedd Cymru

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
6
Q

Why were further powers granted to Scotland in 2016 ?

A
  • 2016 : in response to the surge in nationalistic feeling following the close result in the 2014 Scottish independence referendum
  • Granted financial autonomy known as ‘devo-max’
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
7
Q

What did the Wales act of 2017 grant ?

A
  • Some proposals of the second part of the silk commission

- Granted similar levels of legislative and fiscal powers and responsibility to those of Scotland

How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
8
Q

What is the West Lothian question ?

A
  • Scottish and Welsh MPs voting on matters that don’t effect their own constituents eg 2002 : Uni fees were raised to £3,000 a year due to Scottish MPs voting in favour despite it not effecting Scottish students
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
9
Q

What is EVEL ?

A
  • English votes for English laws
  • If the speaker determined a bill as only concerning England or England and Wales then could be vetoed by MPs representing those regions
  • FAILED to ensure measured desired by a majority of English MPs would be passed
  • Eg 2016 : Extension of trading on a Sunday passed the EVEL stage but was defeated by a vote of the whole chamber with SNP voting against even though Scotland wouldn’t be directly effected
  • Uni fees were tripled under cameron in which the SNP supported yet it didn’t effect scottish students
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
10
Q

Where has there been devolution in the England ?

A
  • During the coalition, attempts were made to introduce directly elected mayors to major cities in England
  • Parliament granted the 12 largest English cities on whether to have a directly elected mayor or not
  • Only 1/10 other major citifies voted to have a mayor (Bristol)
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
11
Q

What was introduced across England ?

A
  • Combined authorities / metro areas
  • Areas that were previously metropolitan areas with a local council could combine resources and share services across a wider area to make them more effective and efficient
  • Means of cutting cost and providing an economic incentive
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
12
Q

What did the 2015 chancellor commit to and why ?

A
  • Osborne was committed to granting autonomous powers to large cities as means of tackling the issue of underperformance in major cities
  • Announced in Oct 2015 that combined authorities would be allowed to keep all revenue from business rates if they agreed to have a directly elected mayor
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
13
Q

What enacted devolution to cities in England ?

A
  • Cities and local government devolution act 2016
  • Represented a major step towards more devolved local government in England with a sizeable economic incentive to adopt them
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
14
Q

As of 2021 how many metro-mayors were there ?

A
  • 8
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
15
Q

What are the powers of the Greater Manchester devolved body ?

A
  • 30 year investment fund of £900 million
  • Control of £6 billion health and social care budget
  • £30 million per year hosing investment fund
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
16
Q

Tees valley devolved city powers ?

A
  • 30 year investment fund of £450 million
  • Consolidated transport budget bus franchising £59 million transforming cities fund
  • No control over health
How well did you know this?
1
Not at all
2
3
4
5
Perfectly
17
Q

What happened with regards to devolution in 1979 ? (Wales and Scotland)

A
  • Referendum on Scottish devolution failed to reach 40%

- Wales : only 20% were in favour of devolution

18
Q

What happened with regards to devolution in 1997 ? (Scotland and Wales)

A
  • Scotland : referendum of Scottish devolution passes with a comfortable majority
  • Wales : referendum passes with a narrow majority
19
Q

When did the Northern Irish Assembly get suspended (twice) ?

A
  • 2002-2007

- 2017-2020

20
Q

What happened in 1998 with regards to devolution (Scotland, Wales and NI) ?

A
  • Scotland : Scotland Act established further devolution and a Scottish executive + Parliament
  • Government of Wales act granted considerable admin. devolution to Wales + also promised a referendum on income tax raising powers
  • NI : Belfast agreement is approved in a referendum, Northern Ireland Act is passed granting devolution and the First elections to the NI National Assembly
21
Q

What happened in 1999 with regards to devolution (Scotland, Wales and NI)

A
  • Scotland : First Scottish parliament since 1707 meets and the gov. starts to operate
  • Welsh assembly is elected, holds its first meetings and a Welsh executive is formed
  • NI power sharing gov. takes power
22
Q

What happened in 2014 with regards to devolution ? (Wales and Scotland)

A
  • Wales : Wales Act gave the gov. powers over several taxes and a referendum on income tax-raising powers
  • Scotland : Referendum for independence was defeated 55% to 45%
23
Q

What happened in 2016 (Scotland) ?

A
  • Scotland Act which granted wide-ranging financial powers to the Scottish government including control over income tax rates
24
Q

What happened in 2017 and 2020 (Wales) ?

A
  • 2017 : Government of Wales act passes which devolved greater political, administrative and fiscal powers to the Welsh assembly
  • 2020 : Officially renamed the Welsh parliament
25
Q

Why is there not an English parliament ?

A
  • England has 84% of the UK’s population and 95% of the UK’s GDP meaning England would dominate its own English Parliament as well as the UK parliament
  • Traditionalists argue Westminster is already an English parliament and further devolution would lead to the break up of the UK
26
Q

Regional devolution in England :

A
  • 2004 : Referendum in the North East region for administrative devolution but it was rejected 78% to 22% (then abandoned)
  • Police commissioners were introduced to improve accountability but turnout is low (2021 : 31%) and few people even know who their commissioner is
27
Q

When was the Greater London Assembly created and what do they do ?

A
  • 1997
  • Mayor controls the allocation of funds
  • 25 assembly members have the power to veto the budget and proposals of the mayor
  • Mayor has the power of patronage but appointments can be vetoed
  • Checks and balances system + AMS election system meaning one party doesn’t have an overall majority
28
Q

Who were the last 3 London Mayors and what have they been instrumental in ?

A
  • Livingstone, Johnson and Khan

- Improved community policing, Growth in the arts scenes in the capital + improve public transport

29
Q

Should cities be given more independent powers ? (yes)

A
  • Local democracy is closer to the people and will therefore more accurately reflect their demands
  • Local needs vary a great deal so ‘one size fits all’ is not realistic
  • The whole UK is ‘London centred’ so local government may boost local economies and spread wealth
  • Demonstrating that local councils and mayors have significant powers will boost local democracy
30
Q

Should cities be given more independent powers ? (No)

A
  • Central control means that all parts of the UK should receive the same range of quality and services
  • Central control will prevent irresponsible local government over spending
  • Turnouts tend to be low so local government is not held accountable enough
  • There is a danger the traditional unity of the UK may be jeopardised
31
Q

Scotland 1998 Act features

A
  • Powers devolved : health service, education, roads and transport, policing and income tax +/- 3%
  • AMS system to elect MSPs + First minister would be head of the executive government
32
Q

Provisions of the Scotland Act 2016

A
  • Included the following measures : widening the area Scottish Parliament could pass laws, power over regulation of the energy industry, control over welfare, income tax and some business taxes
33
Q

What issue has been caused by leaving the EU/Brexit ?

A
  • Scotland voted to remain in the EU : 62% to 38%

- The only way to join the EU is for full independence

34
Q

Provisions of the Government of Wales Act 1998 and why ?

A
  • Fewer powers as the turnout was 50% and voted on devolution by less than 1%
  • Purely administrative : health, education, public transport and agriculture
  • Reliance on an annual grant from the UK government
35
Q

Provisions of the Government of Wales act 2014 :

A
  • Referendum in Wales to decide whether the government of Wales should have partial control over income tax
  • The Welsh government was granted control over various taxes including business taxes
  • Limited powers to borrow money on open markets
36
Q

Provisions of the Government of Wales act 2017

A
  • Greater freedom in borrowing
  • Administrative and legislative responsibility for more areas including electricity production
  • Creation of Welsh Revenue Authority
  • Renamed the Assembly to the Welsh parliament (came in to force 2020)
37
Q

Why is devolution different in NI ?

A
  • devolved government 1921-1972 but with violence breaking out in the 1970’s it was dissolved in 1972
  • Religious conflict
38
Q

Belfast agreement / good Friday agreement 1998 :

A
  • STV : ensured ministerial places for all major parties
  • Compromise and coalitions
  • Included : Education administration, healthcare, transport, policing, agriculture and passage of laws not reserved to Westminster
  • Been dissolved which shows that devolution isn’t the same as federalism and sovereignty remains at Parliament
39
Q

Key differences in devolution (policies) :

A
  • Wales : Greater help for the homeless, Uni tuition is capped at £6.000 and more free home care for the elderly
  • Scotland : No uni fees, SNP dominance, free prescription and greater fox-hunting restrictions
  • NI : Gay marriage not recognised until 2020, greater abortion restrictions and prescriptions are free
40
Q

What recent event has highlighted differences in devolution ?

A
  • COVID-19

- Differences in lockdown measures, travel arrangements, school closures etc