The nature of law and the English legal system Flashcards
What is the distinction between enforceable legal rules and principles and other rules and norms of behaviour?
Enforceable legal rules and principles are rules that can be enforced by the courts, while other rules and norms of behaviour are social expectations that are not legally enforceable.
What are the differences between criminal law and civil law?
- Purpose
Criminal law: aimed at trying to maintain law and order, to protect society. Civil law: upholds the rights of individuals. - Person starting the case
Criminal cases: usually the state through the Crown Prosecution Service. Civil cases: the individual or business which has suffered as a result of the breach of civil law. - Legal name for that person
Criminal = Prosecutor.
Civil = Claimant. - Courts hearing cases
Criminal: tried in either the Magistrates’ Courts or the Crown Court.
Civil: heard in the High Court and the County Court. - Standard of proof
Criminal = beyond reasonable doubt
Civil = on the balance of probabilities - Person making the decision
Criminal = Magistrates in MC + a judge & jury in CC.
Civil = Judge + very rarely a jury - Decision
Criminal = ‘guilty’ (convicted) or ‘not guilty (acquitted)
Civil = ‘liable’ or ‘not liable’. - Powers of the court
Criminal = prison, community order, fine, driving ban
Civil =an award of damages ( compensation) or injunction.
Source of law
Custom
Statute
Common
Custom law
A rule of behaviour which develops in a community without being deliberately invented historically.
Statute law
Law created by Parliament and creates major new law, can change or revoke any laws.
Common law
Unwritten law that developed from custom and the decisions of the judges.
What is the role of law plays in society?
-Law can be described as a mechanism of social control.
-Comprises rules for keeping order in all societies and to protect
What is the effect of law on enforceable rights?
What is the balance required between competing interests (e.g. public and private)?
What is the meaning and importance of fault in civil and/or criminal law?
What is the distinction between law and morality and the diversity of moral views in a pluralist society?
What is the relationship between law and morality and its importance?
What is the legal enforcement of moral values?
What is the meaning of justice?
What are the theories of justice?
Distributive justice
Concerned with the fair allocation of the benefits and responsibilities of life.
What is Aristotle concerned with distributive justice?
What is Thomas Aquinas concerned with distributive justice?
What is Karl Max concerned with distributive justice?
What is Claim Perelman concerned with distributive justice?
What is the extent to which the law (civil and/or criminal) achieves justice?
What is the rule of law
What are Dicey’s three rules?
The rule of law + law making
The rule of law + the legal system
The rule of law + substantive law
Green paper
White paper
Parliament
What is the role of HOC?
What is the role of HOL?
What is the formal legislative process in parliamentary law making?
- First reading
- Second reading
- Committee stage
- Report stage
- Third reading
- HOL
- Royal Assent
First reading
Second reading
Committee stage
Report stage
Third reading
HOL
Royal Assent
What is a bill?
Government bill
Public bill
Private bill
Private members’ bill
Hybrid bill
Advantages of law making in parliament
DIsadvantages of law making in parliament
What are the influences on parliamentary law making?
How the pressure groups influences on parliamentary law making?
Advantages of pressure groups
Disadvantages of pressure groups
How the political parties influences on parliamentary law making?
Advantages of political parties
Disadvantages of political parties
How public opinion influences on parliamentary law making?
Advantages of public opinion
Disadvantages of public opinion
How the media influences on parliamentary law making?
How the Law Commission influences on parliamentary law making?
Advantages of Law Commission
Disadvantages of Law Commission
What is the doctrine of parliamentary supremacy?
What are the limitations on parliamentary supremacy?
How the effect of the HRA 1998 limited on parliamentary supremacy?
How the devolution limited on parliamentary supremacy?
How the EU membership limited on parliamentary supremacy?
What is delegated legislation?
What are the types of delegated legislation?
- Orders in council
- Statutory instruments
- By-laws
Orders in council
Made by the Queen and Privy council, in time of emergency ( when Parliament is not sitting).
Examples of Orders in council
-Foot and mouth disease breakout in August - law must be passed to kill off diseased cows.
-The Misuse of Drugs Act 1971 (Amendment) Order 2008
Uses of Orders in council
-Transferring responsibility between gov departments.
-Bringing Acts or parts of Act of Parliament into force.
-As a member of the EU, giving legal effect to the European directives.
Statutory instruments
Created by gov ministers in their department; often called ‘regulation.’
Examples of Statutory instruments
- An increase in the maximum penalty for speeding.
-Give way to buses
-Codes of Practice under PACE
Uses of Statutory instruments
-Deals with a different areas of policy
-Can make rules
-Regulations in respect of matters it deals with.
-Can be very short, covering one point such as making the annual change to the minimum wage.
-Can be very long + detailed regulations.
By-laws
Made by local authorities make laws for a local area, may also made by some public corporations.
Examples of by-laws
-TFL enable to pass the law for wearing masks in the transport.
-A law rerouting a public footpath
Uses of by-laws
-Many local by-laws will involve the traffic control, such as parking restrictions.
-Other by-law may be for such matters, e.g. banning drinking in public places.
-Can also made certain companies for matters within their jurisdiction which involves the public.
What are the parliamentary controls on delegated legislation?
What is affirmative resolutions procedure?
What is negative resolutions procedure?
What are the judicial controls on delegated legislation?
Ultra vires
Procedural ultra vires
Substantive ultra vires
Why is delegated legislation used?
Advantages of delegated legislation
Disadvantages of delegated legislation
Why do we need statutory interpretations?
What are the three rules of statutory interpretation?
What is the literal rule?
Advantages of literal rule
Disadvantages of literal rule
What is the golden rule?
Advantages of golden rule
Disadvantages of golden rule
What is the mischief rule?
Advantages of mischief rule
Disadvantages of mischief rule
What is the purposive approach?
Advantages of purposive approach
Disadvantages of purposive approach
What are the internal aids (intrinsic) ?
What are the external aids ( extrinsic) ?
How do the European Union law impact statutory interpretation?
How do the HRA 1998 impact statutory interpretation?
What is the doctrine of judicial precedent?
What is the original precedent?
What is the binding precedent?
What is persuasive precedent?
What is the hierarchy of the courts?
What is stare decisis?
What is ratio decidendi?
What is obiter dicta?
What is law reporting?
What are the reasons for law reporting?
What are the operations of precedent?
What is following?
What is overruling?
What is distinguishing?
Advantages of judicial precedent
Disadvantages of judicial precedent
What is the law commission?
What Act was set up by?
Reform
Codification
Repeal
What are the success rate ( implementation rate) ?