The Lumbar Spine Flashcards
Describe the impact of low back pain historically and currently.
most common cause of disability and lost work time (other than common cold) in industrialized countries; most common reason to seek physical therapy; overall economic/societal burden has not improved over the last few years, and may actually be worsening
Define prevalence
the amount of people with a condition at any given time
Describe the prevalence of low back pain worldwide.
difficult to estimate acute pain, because it tends to change very rapidly and can have varying definitions; chronic low back pain is likely between 10-30% on any given day.
What percentage of people with low back pain for less than 3 months will recover? How long does this generally take?
80% of people with acute low back pain (<3 mo) will recover within 6-8 weeks
Describe an inception cohort study design.
enroll patients at the time of onset of symptoms and follow them over time
What percentage of people with acute low back pain will return to work within 2 weeks, according to Henschke et al? Within 3 months?
50% will return to work within 2 weeks; 83% within 3 months
What percentage of people with low back pain symptoms will report continued symptoms after 12 months, according to Henschke et al?
23%
Why is it important to advise patients on the nature of acute low back pain and its prognosis?
LBP is probably not an isolated episode, but a condition characterized by flare-ups of symptoms. Patients should be informed that recovery is likely in a short time frame, but recurrences are likely and normal; Flare-ups do not necessarily represent a failure of treatment
What is the prognosis of chronic low back pain?
Highly variable; “refractory to intervention”; though studies show that even patient with low back pain for more than 3 months can recover fully (1/3 of participants reported that they were pain-free and fully functionally recovered within 1 year), so there is always hope
What study design would we need to use in order to determine exactly the factors that cause the development / influence the course of low back pain? What are the ethical issues that this would raise?
Prospective, randomized study design. We’d have to assign a person to perform activities that we believe to be harmful.
What kinds of study designs are ethical for exploring activities that might cause low back pain?
Non-experimental studies such as case-series designs or cohort designs that follow people over time and compare various traits to the outcome
Describe the findings from Bakker, et al on the relationship between specific activities and low back pain recovery.
Bakker et al found no relationship between work-related spinal loading, prolonged sitting, and/or participation in sports activities on the recovery from low back pain
What is the clinical takeaway from the currently literature on activities that cause / contribute to low back pain rehab?
In conflict with previous beliefs, lifting, prolonged sitting, and sports activities are not likely to be harmful to the spine and should not necessarily be limited in those without a clear rationale
Describe the low back pain clinical prediction rule derived by Hancock et al. and their statistical findings
Acute LBP; lower than average initial pain, shorter duration of symptoms, fewer previous episodes = recover more quickly; Hazard Ratio 3.5
What is a hazard ratio?
A measure of how often a particular event happens in one group compared to how often it happens in another group, over time (Hazard Ratio of 1 = no increased risk in the test group, 2 = twice the risk, etc.)
What is a confidence interval?
Probability measurement. A confidence interval is how much certainty/uncertainty there is with any particular statistic. (They can take any number of probability limits, with the most common being a 95% or 99% confidence level.)
Describe the utility of using the current low back pain CPR to predict prognosis of acute LBP
basic guideline, but there are probably more factors than were originally taken into account when the CPR was derived. (Weak-moderate evidence in addition to lack of validation studies)
How long can the average acute low back pain episode last, according to Adam Meakins?
can last up to 6 weeks
What are the 3 primary anatomic regions of the nervous system in which pain modulation occurs
- spinal cord
- brain stem (periaqueductal gray, rostral ventral medulla)
- higher brain centers (anterior cingulate cortex, amygdala, somatosensory cortex)
What is pain modulation?
the way in which nociceptive (danger) signals are amplified or dampened within the nervous system via biochemical activity
Describe pain dampening events at the spinal cord.
non-nociceptive a-beta nerve fibers recruit inhibitory neurons in the substantia gelatinosa of the posterior spinal cord, which chemically blocks nociceptive a-delta and c-fibers before they can send a signal up the spinal cord to the brain
What is a nerve fiber?
axon or dendrite of a single neuron
Describe spinal sensitization (secondary hyperalgesia).
pain is increased (switched on) because dorsal horn neurons have increased excitability and spontaneously discharge ascending nociceptive information; the excitability is due to repeated firing of “pain-sensitive” c-fibers from somatic tissues (like muscles and joints); the excitability is also enhanced by the transcription of rapidly-expressed genes that increase the sensitization of nociceptors; this means that the threshold is lower and the “receptor field” is wider
Describe pain dampening events at the level of the brain stem.
diffuse inhibition of pain (switch off) happens when the periaqueductal gray (PAG) matter and/or rostral ventral medulla (RVM) are stimulated by pathways that descend from high brain centers; PAG system uses endogenous opioids and descends to the dorsal horn
List 4 important neurotransmitters in the central nervous system that have a modulating affect on pain
- endogenous opioids
- cannabinoids
- serotonin
- dopamine
Which tract of the spinal cord sends information to higher cortical brain regions?
spinothalamic tract projects to several cortical regions, creating a multidimensional pain experience
What does the length of symptoms tell us about a patient’s capability to improving low back pain or complete resolving symptoms?
Not much. Though high pain intensity and disability are unfavorable prognostic factors, even patients with longstanding symptoms can improve and even full recover.
What are the three components of evidence-based practice?
research findings, patient preferences/values, and clinical intuition
What is the purpose of an efficacy study?
determine the effects of a specific intervention
What is the difference between an efficacy study and an effectiveness study?
efficacy studies determine the effects of a specific intervention; effectiveness studies measure outcomes from treatment applied in a pragmatic clinical environment
List the 5 recommendations that are common to most, if not all, treatment guidelines for acute or chronic LBP
- early treatment that emphasizes resumption of activity and discourages bed rest (acute)
- recognition of psychological and work-related factors
- supervised exercise
- utilization of cognitive-behavioral therapy concepts
- step-care approach
Describe a “step-care” approach to treating low back pain. When would this approach be indicated?
rapid transition from passive to active treatments with patients receiving reassurance and encouragement to return to full activity soon; most LBP treatment guidelines agree that this approach should be implemented as soon as serious conditions are ruled out
Describe the limitations of clinical guidelines in the treatment of patients with low back pain. Give an example
There will always be variability among patients (“bandwidth”), and adhering too strictly to guidelines may not always match the optimal treatment for the individual patient. Ex: manual treatments may be indicated not according to the clinical guideline, but to specific clinical presentation.
Make the case for physical therapists performing medical screening / direct access treatment of low back pain
- PTs have been performing direct access medical screening for patient with LBP in the U.S. military and Public Health Service for years, as well as in many other countries
- Evidence supports that PTs are well-trained to identify signs and symptoms associated with serious, undiagnosed conditions (Preliminary evidence suggests that having physical therapists as an entry point to the system doesn’t increase the likelihood of missed serious condition)
- Intervention can begin much sooner and with less cost
- Controls use/cost of unnecessary radiographs and other diagnostic tests
What clinical red flags might you see if a patient with low back pain has a metastatic cancer?
history of cancer, night pain or pain at rest, unexplained weight loss, younger than 17 or older than 50, failure to improve over predicted time interval following treatment
List 6 red flags might you see if a patient with low back pain has an infection of the disk (diskitis) or vertebrae (osteomyelitis)?
- patient is immunosuppressed
- prolonged fever (100.5° F or higher)
- history of IV drug abuse
- hx of recent UTI
- hx of cellulitis
- hx of pneumonia
Describe the clinical presentation of cellulitis.
Skin is red, swollen, warm, and tender to touch; Most common on legs in adults, on the face in children; Usually comes along with feeling sick / chills
List 6 historical/clinical red flags might you see if a patient with low back pain has an undiagnosed vertebral fracture?
- prolonged use of corticosteroids
- older than 70
- mild trauma if older than 50
- history of osteoporosis
- recent major trauma (MVA or fall from greater than 5 ft)
- bruising over the spine
List 4 historical/clinical red flags might you see if a patient with low back pain has a dangerous abdominal aortic aneurysm?
- a pulsating mass in the abdomen
- hx of vascular disease
- throbbing/pulsating pain at rest or with recumbency (lying)
- older than 60
What is the most serious pathology that may present as LBP? Why?
metastatic lesions involving lumbar vertebrae; indicates the presence of aggressive disease elsewhere in the body, applications of interventions to the spine could result in dangerous tissue injury
What is the function of Likelihood Ratios?
combine measures of sensitivity and specificity to describe how much a test or a cluster of test (+ or -) will raise or lower the likelihood of a condition being present.
How are Likelihood Ratios measured?
Measurement starts at 1 & moves in either direction
< 1.0 is negative LR, > 1.0 is positive LR;
< 0.1 and > 10 are large/conclusive changes in post-test likelihood of a condition being present;
0.1-0.2 or 5.0-10.0 are moderate changes to post-test likelihood;
0.2-0.5 or 2.0-5.0 suggest small but possibly important changes;
Summarize the efficacy of red flags in the medical screening of patients with low back pain.
- serious diseases that present as low back pain are relatively rare
- traditional red flags are often present in people without serious disease
- in isolation, most positive red flags don’t increase the probability that the patient has a serious disease
- decisions should be based on clusters of findings, as this increases the likelihood of serious disease being present
- current evidence suggests that using a PT for medical screening doesn’t decrease the likelihood of missing a serious condition
List 5 conditions associated with low back pain can be detected with MRI and/or CT scans.
- subtle fractures
- abnormal tissue growth (esp. neoplasm)
- local/diffuse inflammatory exudates (fluid and leukocytes)
- hemorrhage due to fracture/soft tissue injury
- serious compression of the spinal cord / cauda equina / spinal nerves
List 3 tests that are the typical reference standards to try to identify proposed anatomic sources of low back pain? What is the relationship between these tests and MRI?
- lumbar discography (x-ray with radiopaque die injected into the IV disc)
- facet joint blocks
- sacroiliac joint blocks.
- tests are used to attempt to more clearly determine linkages between symptoms and MRI findings
What is HIZ and why is it important to reading MRI imaging of the lumbar spine?
high intensity zone - high/bright signal in the annulus of the intervertebral disc. This signal is believed to be associated with an annular tear; might be a component of “diskogenic” pain
Expand: Studies on the relationship between HIZ on lumbar imaging and discogenic low back pain. Likelihood ratios ranged from 1.5 to 5.9
the presence of a HIZ produced small increases in the likelihood of the pain arising from the intervertebral disk at that level
What is a “Modic Sign” and why is it important to MRI imaging of the lumbar spine?
disruption of the endplate, causing bone marrow edema. This is thought to contribute to impaired diffusion of nutrients and waste products between the vertebral body (subchondral bone) and the disc; might be a component of “diskogenic” pain); Seen on MRI as high (bright) T2 signal in and near the end plate.
Expand: Studies on the relationship between Modic signs on lumbar spine imaging and discogenic low back pain. Likelihood ratios ranged from 0.6 to 5.9.
Finding Modic signs produced minimal to moderate increases in the likelihood of the pain arising from the intervertebral disc at that level
Expand: Study on the relationship between “normal” MRI of the lumbar spine (that did not show disk degeneration) and discogenic low back pain. LR- = 0.21
Normal MRI produced small reductions the likelihood of the disk as a source of pain
Expand: Hancock et al. studied the relationship between physical examination tests and discogenic low back pain. Found +LR 2.8 for “centralization of symptoms”
Centralization of symptoms mildly increases the probability that the pain arises from the disk
What is special about centralization of lumbar spine symptoms in those with discogenic pain?
it’s the only physical examination measure that demonstrates a +LR (mildly increases the likelihood that the disc is the source of pain)
Expand: Study of the relationship between multiple (+) clinical sacroiliac joint tests and discogenic low back pain. +LR = 3.2
Multiple (+) clinical S.I. joint tests mildly increase the likelihood that the pain arises from the disc
Expand: Study of the relationship between multiple (-) clinical sacroiliac joint tests and discogenic low back pain. LR = 0.29
Multiple (-) clinical S.I. joint tests mildly decrease the likelihood that the pain arises from the disc.
Describe the relationship between clinical tests and lumbar spine pain caused by facet joint problems.
No clinical tests have yet to reliably detect facet joint problems
Summarize the relationship between the utility of MRI when evaluating lumbar spine pain sources and treatment.
- MRI is not indicated in the absence of red flags or worsening neurological symptoms
- Early, inappropriate use of MRI may increase patient anxiety and lead to false beliefs about the severity of a diagnosis
What three types of flags signal potential biobehavioral factors that may influence low back pain?
Yellow, Blue, and Black flags
What is meant by the term “yellow flag” in patients with low back pain?
describe a patient’s personal mistaken beliefs about pain and injury
List 7 examples of “yellow flags” in patients with low back pain.
- emotional distress
- hypervigilance
- pain catastrophizing
- elevated fear-avoidance beliefs
- low self-efficacy
- misunderstanding about nature and likely impact of pain
- misunderstanding of best strategies for long-term success
Describe the yellow flag of “emotional distress” as it pertains to low back pain.
high degrees of anxiety (more common with acute LBP) and/or high degrees of depression (more common with chronic LBP)
Describe the yellow flag of “hypervigilance” as it pertains to low back pain.
excessive pre-occupation with pain
Describe the yellow flag of “pain catastrophizing” as it pertains to low back pain.
overestimation of the negative impact of pain
Describe the yellow flag of “elevated fear-avoidance beliefs” as it pertains to low back pain.
inappropriate belief that benign activities are harmful to the spine
Describe the yellow flag of “low self-efficacy” as it pertains to low back pain.
a patient’s belief that they have no control over the pain
Describe the yellow flag of “misunderstanding about the nature and likely impact of pain” as it pertains to low back pain.
a combination of factors that lead the patient to believe that they may have a much more serious condition than is actually the case
Describe the yellow flag of “misunderstanding about the best strategies for long-term success” as it pertains to low back pain.
the patient may believe that passive, not active treatments are needed (i.e. “someone needs to fix my back”)
Why is the Pain Catastrophizing scale clinically relevant for those with low back pain?
score is an independent predictor of disability (stronger predictor than pain intensity)
What is important to remember when interpreting scores from tests like the Fear-Avoidance Beliefs Questionnaire or Tampa Scale for Kinesiophobia?
- Detecting elevated fear-avoidance beliefs can be useful in helping to predict chronicity of symptoms but are not good predictors if used on their own.
- They become moderately strong predictors when combined with imaging findings of multi-level degenerative disc disease, a strenuous or stressful job, leg pain, and low educational background.
What is meant by the term “blue flag” in patients with low back pain?
relate primarily to injured workers, describe a patient’s perception of work and work conditions that may impair a return to work (ex. low job satisfaction, personal conflicts with employers/co-workers)
What is meant by the term “black flag” in patients with low back pain?
wide context of factors such as social and financial issues (ex. reimbursement incentives to remain disabled)
Explain the relationship between self-efficacy and pain & disability in patients with low back pain.
The belief that one can achieve future goals has been shown to be a strong predictor of successful treatment. Additionally, a patient’s beliefs about how pain can be controlled is one of the most powerful predictors of the development of pain-related disability.
Describe the current state of the evidence for spinal manipulation/mobilization.
Several systematic reviews have been conducted:
- Assendelft: relatively small decrease in pain and disability vs placebo / ineffective treatment
- Ferreira: larger and more clinically meaningful improvement vs placebo
- Bronfort et al: moderate support for patients with acute pain, minimal to moderate support for patients with chronic LBP; more effective than combination of home ex and advice at 12-week follow up, but not 1 year
Describe the 5-item clinical prediction rule for using lumbar manipulation developed by Flynn et al and validated by Childs et al.
Presence of 4 or 5 = +LR 24.38 for successful outcome:
- no sx distal to knee
- less than 16 days
- score of less than 19 on FABQ
- at least 1 hypomobile segment (P-A)
- at least 1 hip with more than 35° IR
Describe the controversy surrounding the Flynn et al clinical prediction rule for lumbar spine manipulation.
although the CPR was validated by Childs et al, it was also found to be less successful by Hancock et al. In recent years, the generalizability of the rule has been challenged.
What’s the bottom line on the use of manipulation/mobilization of the lumbar spine to treat low back pain?
An argument can be made that in the absence of contraindications, mobilization/manipulation should be a first-line treatment for patients seeking PT for LBP. It’s unlikely to be helpful if used without patient education and purposeful increases in physical activity. This is especially true for people with chronic low back pain or post-operative patients.
Describe the clinical premise behind motor control exercises (a.k.a. stabilization exercises) to treat low back pain.
Individuals with low back pain have altered muscle control of the trunk and back muscles that leads to inappropriate loading on painful lumbar motion segments. Motor control exercises target deep trunk muscles in an attempt to have the patient actively stabilize their spine.
What evidence is there to support motor control exercises to treat low back pain?
- Costa et al: ultrasound biofeedback to enhance learning of motor control exercise in patients with chronic LBP for 12 sessions. Patients reported improvements in recovery and activity tolerance at 2-, 6-, and 12-month follow-up. Though, there were no significant differences in pain.
- Macedo et al: systematic review for patients with chronic LBP. Motor control exercises were superior to minimal intervention at short- and long-term follow-up; likely to benefit the patient when combined with another therapy for pain
Describe the concept of graded exposure in treating patients with low back pain
Asks patients to generate a hierarchy of feared activities and then gradually progress through these to attempt to reduce activity-related anxiety. Uses operant conditioning to reinforce healthy behaviors and progress the patient through different levels of functional activity.
How might a physical therapist decide if they should use motor control exercises or graded exposure in treating a patient with chronic low back pain?
Macedo et al used the Clinical Instability Questionnaire to identify patients who would benefit. Patients with a score of 9 or higher did substantially better with motor control exercises, while those with a score lower than 9 did better with a graded activity approach.
Describe the treatment approach for Motor Control Exercises described by Costa et al.
Stage 1: train coordinated activity of trunk muscles
- independent activation of deeper muscles (transversus abdominis and multifidi)
- reduce over-activity of superficial muscles in an individualized manner
Stage 2: implement precision of the desired coordination
- train skills in static tasks
- incorporate these skills into dynamic tasks and functional patterns
List the 15 items of the Clinical Instability Measure
- back feels like it is going to “give way” or “give out”
- feel the need to frequently “pop” the back to reduce pain
- frequent times when pain occurs throughout the day
- past history of catching or locking when twisting or bending
- pain sit sit-stand or stand-sit
- pain with lying-sit if not done carefully
- pain incr with quick, unexpected, or mild movements
- difficulty sitting without back support (chair or supportive backrest)
- cannot tolerate prolonged positions when unable to move
- condition is getting worse
- pain for a long period of time
- temporary relief with back brace or corset
- frequent muscle spasms
- fear of movement due to pain
- traumatic back injury in the past
Describe the effects of aerobic and resistance exercise on patients with low back pain.
Aerobic: reduces increased awareness of neural stimulus (central sensitization)
Weight training: reduces frequency of acute episodes of low back pain
List & describe 3 areas of patient education for those with low back pain.
- advice to stay active, but avoid excessive loading of injured tissues; understand the difference between “good pain” (post-ex muscle pain) and “bad pain” (inflammatory pain)
- behavioral education: cognitive-behavioral theory & graded increases in activity and exposure
- physiology of pain: concepts of neuroplasticity and sensitization for patients with chronic symptoms (patient’s negative appraisal of pain is decreased & they understand that symptoms are expected and do not represent a serious undiagnosed disease)
What is the bottom line when it comes to the effectiveness of the most popular treatment approaches for patients with low back pain?
- mobilization/manipulation, directional preference, and various exercises all have a relatively small (but potentially important) effect on both pain and disability
- there is no demonstrated differences in effectiveness between different types of manual therapy
- patient education regarding pain and advice to stay active is likely to be a key central component to recovery
Describe the central tenet of the modern neuroscience approach to treating low back pain.
Draws on the current imaging literature that demonstrates changes in motor control that occur with substantial changes in nervous system structure and function in people with chronic low back pain
Describe the clinical application of the modern neuroscience approach to treating low back pain.
substantial time is devoted to “pain neuroscience education” followed by exercise & manual therapy that includes cognition-targeted motor control training
Describe the current state of the evidence for the modern neuroscience approach for treating low back pain
well-constructed clinical trails are underway, but there are currently no data that support or fail to support this approach.
What is a trigger point?
- Palpable, tight bands that are tender to palpation.
- can develop in any skeletal muscle
- may be the result of injury or microtrauma
How is it currently theorized that trigger points contribute to pain?
it is postulated (but still unproven) that trigger points are local areas of sustained muscle contraction associated with fluid congestion. Research has identified an increase in inflammatory cytokines within the substance of trigger points. Others have found 15% O2 saturations and decreased pH levels within the trigger point environment
- disruption of local chemical environment is referred to as “end-plate noise”
Describe the concept of “end-plate noise” as it relates to musculoskeletal pain.
- Proposed mechanism behind trigger point pain
- the combination of sustained muscle contraction & alterations in the chemical environment of the trigger point
What are the potential mechanisms for dry needling to reduce pain in muscle tissue?
several theories are proposed:
- “gate-control theory” (actives a-delta nerve fibers that stimulate dorsal horn interneurons).
- corrects for levels of circulating cytokines
Describe the “gate-control effect” of pain modulation.
a stimulus activates a-delta nerve fibers that stimulate enkephalinergic (endogenous opioid peptides / endorphins) dorsal horns interneurons, creating an opiate-like pain reduction
What is the current state of the evidence for dry needling as a treatment for low back pain?
There is some evidence that suggests that dry needling may be useful as an adjunct treatment, but the overall evidence base is inconclusive