The Law of Tort Flashcards
What is negligence?
An act or failure to act which causes injury to another person or damage to their property
What must be proved for negligence?
Duty of care
+
breach of duty
+
damage caused
=
liable in negligence
What is duty of care?
A legal relationship between the parties involved
What is the neighbor principle?
The person who is owed a duty of care by the defendant.
What case did the neighbor principle come from?
Donoghue v Stevenson 1932
What are the factors of the three part test?
- Was the damage or harm reasonably foreseeable?
- Is there a sufficiently proximate relationship between the claimant and the defendant?
- Is it fair, just and reasonable to impose a duty?
Negligence key case:
Donoghue v Stevenson 1932
On August 26 1928, Mrs. Donoghue’s friend bought her a ginger-beer from Well meadow Café [1] in Paisley. She consumed about half of the bottle, which was made of dark opaque glass, when the remainder of the contents was poured into a tumbler. At this point, the decomposed remains of a snail floated out causing her alleged shock and severe gastro-enteritis.
Donoghue could not sue due to the fact that they were not an original party of the contract
What is the 3 part test?
An update of the neighbour principle to show who is owed a duty of care in negligence
Where did the three part test come from?
Caparo v Dickman 1990
What case overruled Caparo v Dickman?
Robinson v Chief Constable of West Yorkshire 2018
What is breach of duty?
When the duty of care has been breached
What should be considered when it comes to breach of duty?
Person involved
Risk factors involved
What is the judgement for breach of duty when it comes to professionals?
judged according to standards in profession
e.g. a junior doctor will be judged the same as a fully qualified doctor
What case links to professionals and breach of duty?
Bolam v Friern Barnet Hospital management 1957
What is the judgement for breach of duty when it comes to learners?
learners should be judged at the standard of the competent, more experienced person
What case links to learners and breach of duty?
Nettleship v Weston 1971
What is the judgement for breach of duty when it comes to children and young persons?
Judged at standard of the defendants age at the time accident
What case links to children and young persons and breach of duty?
Mullin v Richards 1998
What is the risk for breach of duty when it comes to vulnerable victim?
Has the claimant any special characteristics to be taken account of?
What case links to vulnerable victims and breach of duty?
Paris v Stepney Borough Council 1951
What is the risk for breach of duty when it comes to size of risk?
Greater care should be taken if higher chance of injury
What case links to size of risk and breach of duty?
Bolton v Stone 1951
What is the risk for breach of duty when it comes to cost of precautions?
Risk involved is balanced against the cost and effort of taking precautions
What case links to cost of precautions and breach of duty?
Latimer v ACE 1954
What is the risk for breach of duty when it comes to knowledge of danger?
If risk is not known at the time of accident, can be no breach
If high risk injury the standard of care is higher
What 2 cases links to knowledge of danger and breach of duty?
Roe v Minister of health 1954
Haley v LEB 1965
What 2 cases links to public benefit and breach of duty?
Watt v Hertfordshire 1954
Day v High performance sports 2003
What is the risk for breach of duty when it comes to public benefit?
Greater risks can be taken in emergency situations
Duty of care not breached in view of emergency
What is damage?
The legal tests of a loss to the claimant from a breach of duty