The Desgin argument Flashcards
What is the design argument?
It is the argument that because the universe is ordered towards some end or purpose it would make it more probable that the universe is ordered because it was created by an intelligent being.
a posterior
Based on sense experience, the evidence for this is our senses
What is the anthropic principle
The argument that the reason and purpose of the universe is to support human life
What is the strong anthropic principle
it states that it was necessary for the universe to have the properties it did and the fine tunings in its creation, it was not just happen it had a creator (God)
The weak anthropic principle
we are here because the universe must have properties necessary for life.
doesn’t explain why the universe is the way it is
Inductive argument
process of reasoning particular intense to general and probable conclusion
William Paley’s Watch analogy
It is the idea that when a person sees a watch they come to the conclusion that the watch has a watch maker due to the many functions it has that allows it to fulfil its purpose (telling the time) the same can be applied to the universe, the universe has many functions and therefore must have a creator. Paely argues that it would be unreasonable to assume that the watch came without a watchmaker and the same can be applied to the universe.
Weaknesses of the design argument
-experience of the universe is limited, there is no experience of universes being designed or built so cannot infer the cause
- analogies don’t always work well, not enough similarities between the watch and the universe
-
Ockham’ she razor
The principle that the simplest explantation is the most likely
deductive argument
Reasoning that seeks to produce a hypothesis from an observation using the simplest and most likely explantation
Weakness of the anthropic principle
Assumes human beings are so special
Cosmological argument
Are generally a posterior and exist in both inductive and deductive forms. Questions how the universe began, why it was created and who caused it, these questions are answered with causation, motion and necessity
Leibniz sufficient reason
Total explanation
Kalamazoo cosmological argument
Origins From medieval Islamic scholasticism
P1 whatever begins to exist has a cause
P2 universe begins to exist
P3 therefore universe has a cause
C therefore God exists
Is the Kalam cosmogonical argument dectuctive or inductive
Deductive