Terms and Concepts Flashcards
sources of law
legislative, judiciary, and executive branches of government
primary vs secondary sources
primary: sources of law, including cases, statutes, acts, codes, executive orders, regulations, treaties; secondary: commentary to explain the law but not binding; treatises, legislative history, law journals, legal encyclopedias, restatements
constitutions
document that organizes government, ensures basic rights, all later laws are judged against that document; US Constitution also states have Constitutions, state cons cannot conflict with fed but it can afford more rights
common law v enacted law
common law: law that came from cases; enacted law comes from legislature
statutes v regulations
both are primary law. statutes come from legislature; regulations are created by executive agencies; statutes overrule regulations
functions of statutes
Clarify the law for the public, put the public on notice, more general and accessible to public; change the common law; can address broader situations where cases just focus on facts in front of court; codify patchwork of common law
relationship between statutes and cases
cases can interpret statutes; statutes overrule cases; judicial review - power of courts to review statutes for constitutionality
hierarchy of authority between federal and state
each system is separate, but state courts may hear federal law and vice versa
federal v state law
federal statutes and state statutes are separate bodies of law; may run into federal law in state courts and vice versa
jurisdiction
which court has the right to hear a case; subject matter jurisdiction - the substance of the case; personal jurisdiction - whether the court has power to bind a person with a ruling; venue - geography
Basis for federal court jurisdiction
- diversity jurisdiction 2. question of federal law 3. if US is a party
WI court names
circuit court; court of appeals (unified court, 4 districts); WI Supreme Court
Federal court names
District Court (District Court for the Western District of WI); Circuit Court of Appeals (7th Circuit); Supreme Court
co-equal vs unified courts of appeals
co-equal: sister courts do not have to follow each other’s rulings; unified: all court of appeals districts are binding on all trial courts and court of appeals cannot contradict each other
Federal Circuit Courts
13 federal courts of appeals; 12 regional courts; 11 numbered courts based on geography; 12th is DC court also based on geography; Federal Circuit - subject matter jurisdiction over specialized cases such as patent law
stages of a civil case
complaint, answer, discovery, trial, post-trial
bench trial
trial before a judge instead of a jury; judge decides law and facts
fact-finding
typical role of the jury; what happened in a case
motion
request the court to do something
affirmative defense
saying I didn’t do it, but if I did do it, here’s why I should not be held liable or found guilty
precedent and stare decisis
a court must follow their own previous decisions - promotes fairness, efficiency, and predictability
binding v persuasive authority
binding - a court must follow it; persuasive - a court may choose to follow it; a binding decision is a decision from a court in your appeals chain
case of first impression
a case that has not been seen by a court before
standards of review
lens through which the appeals court will review a case; measuring stick of how they will judge an appeal regardless of the underlying subject matter
de novo review
higher court reviewing a lower court decision; they look at the questions of law with no deference to the lower court;’s decision
concurring opinion
a judge reaches the same conclusion as the majority, but for different or additional reasons
dissenting opinion
a judge disagrees with the majority
holding v dicta
holding: binding decision by the court; dicta: not binding in theory, but judges have different views, commentary that is not necessary to resolving the issue of the case
per curiam opinion
opinion by the court as a whole, anonymous, usually for very routine and noncontroversial cases
reverse and render v reverse and remand
Reverse and render: higher court reverses the decision as matter of law; reverse and remand: higher court reverses the decision but there are facts to be decided so it has to be retried by the lower court
reverse v overrule
reverse is when a higher court changes the ruling of the lower court in a case; overrule is when a court changes its mind later, could be ten years later; WI Supreme Court has said that WI Court of Appeals is not allowed to overrule its own decisions
appeal by right v discretionary review
appeal by right: intermediate appellate courts have to take an appeal; discretionary review: highest court does not have to hear an appeal; you have to talk them into taking the case
petition for certiorari
Request for discretionary review; have to convince the high court 1. to take your case and 2. why court of appeals erred; Note: High court decision to deny review is not a comment on the merits, nothing substantive.
en banc
All the judges of the intermediate court of appeals hear a case. Appeals are typically heard by 3-judge panels
state, regional and federal reporters
Federal District Reporter: F. Supp.; Federal Circuit Court of Appeals: F. F.2d. F.3d. (Federal Reporter Third Series); SCOTUS: U.S., S Court, Lawyer’s Edition; State reporters are less frequent these days: WI official reporter is Wis. 2d.; Regional reporter: commercially published, unofficial reporter for state appellate cases N.W.2d. (N.W. includes WI, Iowa, Mich, Minn, Neb, ND, SD)
Citation spacing rule
No space between adjacent single capital letters. In all other situations, put a space between abbreviations. Ex: Wis. 2d (space), N.W.2d (no space)
stages of a case publication
slip opinion, advance sheets, bound volume