Termination of Marriage Flashcards
Two ways to terminate a marriage in VA
Annulment and DIvorce
Difference between annulment and divorce
- annulment is based on a ground that predates the marriage
- pre-existing capacity problem that one or both didn’t know of
- Divorce is based on a ground that occurs after the marriage
Anullment is an available remedy for these two types of marriages
Void and voidable
Effect of a void marriage
- if grounds for marriage void, marriage didn’t exist at all, no annulment needed
- Typically people in void marriage still get annulment because:
- Makes it official because you don’t have to explain marriage later, e.g. for future marraiges/loans
- For collateral matters
- e.g. custody and property division
Effect of a voidable marriage
- if grounds for marriage voidable, you are married until you get the annulment
- You still get the benefits of marriage
Waivability of void and voidable marriages
- Void marriages are NOT waivable. You can’t consent later and make the marriage valid.
- Voidable marriages are waivable in various ways depending on the circumstances
Grounds that make the marriage void
- bigamy
- Second marriage is void, first is not
- Also punishable as a crime, unless marriage is entered into under mistaken belief first spouse had died
- Consanguinity
- Can marry first cousins
- Can’t marry all other blood relatives
Grounds that make the marriage voidable
- Underage
- Duress
- Mental Incapacity
- Incurable impotence
- Fraud
Voidable marriage-underage
- have to be 18
- 16-17 only with judicial permission
- Ground is waived if you continue to cohabit (living together and sex) after age 18
Voidable Marriage-Duress
- e.g. shotgun wedding
- Waivable if you continue to cohabit after threat of violence terminates
Voidable Marriage-Mental incapacity
- Mental illness
- Under influence of drugs/alcohol
- Developmental disability
- Age-related mental issue, like alzheimer’s
- Waived if you continue to cohabit after impediment removed
- Annulment has to be litigated by a guardian b/c incapacitated
Voidable Marriage- Incurable Impotence
- the inability to have sex, not make babies
- Have to not had sex before marriage , or this is waived
- Can’t be curable, e.g. Viagra/wedding night nerves
- Waived when the other spouse still consents to the relationship
Voidable Marriage-Fraud
Most likely to show up on exam
- any situation prior to the wedding where one party misrepresented/concealed fact that goes to an essential aspect of marriage
- ultimately a discretionary determination
Voidable Marriage-Fraud
Some frauds that have been established by statutes
- concealment of a prior felony
- pregnant with another man’s child at time of engagement
- Man impregnated another woman/had other children by another woman
- Spouse had previously been a prostitute
Frauds that have been established by caselaw
- misrepresentation of religion
- could be what kind of religion or how devout you are
- Lying about procreation
- unable to have kids
- Kids will have genetic birth defects
- Lying about sex
- must be really big, like sexual proclivities, not sexual history
When voidable marriage under fraud is waived
- Waived if spouse stays in marriage despite the fraud