Tax Law Flashcards
TAXATION OF INVESTMENT INCOME
Trustee under a private trust or as a trustees under a Retirement Benefit Scheme have an obligation to?
Invest the assets that are committed to their trust
What is investment income?
It is that which comes from interest payments, dividends, capital gains collected upon the sale of a security or other assets, and any other profit made through an investment vehicle of any kind
What are considered investment income?
Interest earned on bank accounts
Dividends received from stock owned by mutual fund holdings
Sales of gold coins held in a safety deposit box and so on
Can business have income from investments?
Yes
What is often listed in the income statements of publicly traded companies?
An item called investment ‘income or losses’
What is done in this investment ‘income or losses’
The company reports the portion of the net income obtained through investments made with surplus cash as opposed to being earned with the company’s usual line of business
What is investment according to modified version of Webster’s definition?
Act of committing money or money’s worth in order to gain profit or interest
What are the categories of investment?
Direct investment
Portfolio investment
What does portfolio investment referred to in taxation?
Passive income
What forms can portfolio investment take?
- Form of acquisition of securities such as shares or bonds
- Form of a loan
Forms of investment Shares Debunture stock Property Bank Deposit Lending Bonds Treasury bills Leases Promissory Notes Technology What are the income that can be generated from each of them?
Dividend Interest Rent Interest Interest Interest Interest Rent Discount Royalty
What is one of the factors that should guide the investor in his choice of investment is?
Tax implication of that particular type of investment
What is the exception to this factor?
Where the investor is limited statutorily I.e Pension Fund Managers or by the terms of an existing arrangement that he might have with a third party I.e trust deed
What are the other factors that an investor consider when investing?
Time frame within whichnhr needs to realize a return on that investment
- the economic indices prevalent at the time of investment and other variables
Investment could be?
Short term, medium term or long term
The treatment of investment income under the CITA and PITA are quite similar ?
Yes
Where are the treatment dissimilar?
The withholding tax rules
Where does CITA and PITA apply as regards investment
Accrues to a company and an individual or persons taxable under PITA respectively
What are the investment incomes under CITA
Dividends
Interest, Royalty
Rents
What are the investments income subject to PITA
Dividends
Interest
Rent
Royalty, Discounts
Investment incomes under CITA
DIVIDENDS
What does dividends mean in relation to CITA?
It is in relation to a company not being in the process of being wound up or liquidated, any profits distributed to shareholders, whether or not such profits are of a capital nature
- includes an amount equal to the nominal value of bonus shares, debentures or securities awarded to shareholders
In relation to a company that is being wound up or liquidated what is dividends?
Any profits distributed whether in money or money’s worth or otherwise, other than those of a capital nature earned before or during the winding up or liquidation
Under why section of CITA talks about Dividends?
Section 80
What does Section 80 CITA provide?
Dividends become due from or payable by a Nigerian company to any other company or person, the company such dividend or making such distribution shall deduct at the rate of 10% on dividend paid to a company
How much withholding tax is deducted on dividend paid to a company ?
10%
What section of CITA provides for this?
Section 80 CITA
What happens when the recipient is a foreign company and which section of CITA gives rise to this?
The tax withheld will represent the final tax payable by the foreign recipient company Section 80(4)
When will dividend not be taxable by a Nigerian company from a foreign company
When the dividend is brought into Nigeria through Government Approved channels.
What is regarded as franked investment income?
A dividend received after deduction of tax
What section provide for franked investment income?
Section 80(3)
What does the section provide?
Provides that dividend received after deduction of tax should be regarded as franked investment income to the recipient company and sha not be charged to further tax as part of the profits of the recipient company.
What is the recipient company required to do to distribute the dividends to the shareholder?
Offset the withholding tax that it has already suffered on those dividends
Where a Nigerian company earns franked investment income, what will be the tax withheld
10%
What will the tax withheld constitute?
The final tax payable on that income
When the company is computing its taxable profits will it be excluded from the total profits of the company?
Yes it will
What happens when such income is redistributed?
The company is entitled to offset the withholding tax that could have been due from redistribution against the withholding tax that it has suffered on the income
What happens where the company makes distribution to its shareholders from its other profits?
The distribution will be subject to withholding tax
What happens to the company as a result?
The company will not be entitled to offset the withholding tax that it suffered on the franked investment income that it earned in that year of assessment
In order to take of the franked investment income what should the company do?
The distribution that it makes to its shareholders must be from that franked investment income and not from another source of profits
EXCESS DIVIDEND RULE
What section of CITA imposes excess dividend tax?
Section 19
What does section 19 provide for ?
Where a dividend is paid out as profit on which no tax is payable
This tag is payable due to?
No total profits or
Total profits which are less than the amount of dividend which is paid
What happens to the company according to the relevant sections?
The company paying the dividend shall be charged to tax at the rate prescribed in s.40(1) as if the dividend is the total profits of the company for the year of assessment to which the accounts , out of which the dividend is declared
At what rate is the company paying the dividend charged?
30%
What case fall under excess dividend
Oando v Firs
What was the rule under excess dividend rule under the new judgment of the tax appeal tribunal?
Nigerian companies are now liable to income tax at 60%
What was the facts of the case?
The appellant(oando) declared and paid dividends to its shareholders in the year 2005,2006 and 2007. The FIRS, relying on section 19 CITA assessed the dividends to tag at the rate of 30% on the basis that the dividends exceed the company’s taxable profits for the respective years. Oando objected to the assessment but the FIRS subsequently issued a notice of refusal to amend the assessments upon which the company lodged the appeal
What was Oando’s position?
Oando put forward three major arguments
- The dividends were paid out of retained earnings which had already been taxed in prior years.
- Firs should have considered and applied Section 80 CITA which exempts dividend income that has been subjected to withholding tax from further tax
- If Section 19 is considered ambiguous then it should be interpreted in Favour of the taxpayer in line with the contra fiscum rule
What was Firs position?
They appeared to agree that dividends paid from retained earnings should not be subjected to excess dividends tax. It
What was the decision of the court?
The tribunal in interpreting section 19, held that dividends paid from retained earnings, where there is no taxable profit or taxable profit is less than the dividends, should be taxed at 30% regardless of whether the earnings had been taxed previously.
The tribunal outlined four steps to be followed before subjecting a company to tax under section 19
First step?
Ascertain why no tax was payable -which could either be due to no taxable profits less than dividend paid
Second step
Regard any such dividends paid as the taxable profits of the company
Third step
The actual taxable profit for the current year should be deduced from the dividend (deemed taxable profit) to determine the excess