Supreme Court Flashcards
Which article and section of the Constitution?
Article III, section 1
Who created the court system?
Framers left it to Congress
Which act created the Supreme Court?
Federal Judiciary Act 1789
- one chief justice
- 5 associate justices
- created courts below the SC
⤷ district courts - at least one per state (around 94 total)
⤷ circuit courts - 13, collection of courts judges transfer around, each has a court of appeals (reviews cases and do not retry cases or hear witnesses)
What is a district court?
- Hears trials and hearings
- Jurisdiction on almost all federal and civil cases
⤷ criminal - violated law
⤷ civil - disputes
What is a Court of Appeals?
- Reviews cases
- Do not retry cases or hear witnesses
- Handles over 50,000 cases per year
- Less than 10% go to SC
How did Carter impact the courts?
- No SC appointments
- Appointed 260 judges to federal district courts and courts of appeals
⤷ Selected women and minorities
⤷ 2 went on to be SCJs - Ginsberg (1993) and Breyer (1994)
Features of the SC
- Appellate court
⤷ hears appeals to rulings from circuit courts - Original jurisdiction
⤷ right for a case to be heard in its first instance
⤷ e.g. United States v Shipp 1906 - Af-Am convicted of rape but filed a writ of habeas corpus + case accepted by SC, only criminal case ever taken by SC
How many cases does the SC take?
2012 - 8,806 sent, 76 argued
2016 - 7,334 sent, 68 argued
2023 - 62 cases heard
2025 - 65 heard
usually around 1% of cases heard
What act changed the number of justices?
Judiciary Act 1869
- 9 justices
Why is the salary of the justices important?
- Prevents bribes/ exploitation
- 2024 salary
⤷ chief - $298,500
⤷ associate - $285,400
What are the powers of the SC?
Judicial review
- legislation
- presidential acts
When/how was judicial review introduced?
Marbury v Madison 1803
- Established precedents for constitutional law and the modern judiciary
⤷ federal laws that conflict the Constitution are invalid
⤷ judges determine whether federal laws are unconstitutional
⤷ duty of judiciary to say what is law w/o opinion
- Gave power to strike down congressional legislation
Which case set the precedent of overpowering states?
Fletcher v Peck 1810
- Ruled against state law
- Set precedent of sanctity of legal contracts
- Hinted that Native Americans did not hold complete title to their land
⤷ later confirmed by Johnson v Macintosh
Which case set the 5th Amendment?
Miranda v Arizona 1966
- Miranda warnings required before police interrogation
Which case ruled against quotas in college admissions?
Regents of the University of California v Bakke 1978
- Supported race as a factor in admissions process
- Just prevented fixed quotas
- Helped uphold later cases
⤷ Fisher v University of Texas 2016 - 4-3 support of having race as a factor in its admissions process
⤷ Students for Fair Admissions v Harvard 2023 - race-based affirmative action is unconstitutional (14th am)
Which cases involved gay rights?
United States v Windsor 2013
- ruled section 3 of DOMA unconstitutional, meaning govt can’t discriminate against married gay couples for federal benefits and protections
Obergefell v Hodges 2015
- gay marriage legal across all states
Which case set the precedent of their power to review criminal courts?
Cohens v Virginia 1821
Which case set the precedent that they could rule any branch of govt unconstitutional?
Cooper v Aaron 1958
- denied Arkansas School Board the right to delay desegregation
- used the Supremacy Clause to support that the schools must respect the rights of black students as given by the Constitution
How is the SC conservative?
- History of blocking civil rights progress
⤷ Shelby County v Holder 2013 - gutted the Voting Rights Act of 1965, leading to race-based gerrymandering
⤷ Fisher v University of Texas 2016 - Power of police
⤷ Maryland v King 2013 - 5-4 that DNA swabs as part of arrest does not violate the 4th Am as it shouldn’t require a warrant due to probable cause - Supportive of gun rights
⤷ District of Columbia v Heller 2008 - Columbia’s ban on handguns and requirement of shotguns + rifles to be unloaded and disassembled violated 2nd Am - Supportive of limited govt/ less federalism
⤷ Dobbs v Jackson WHO 2022 - Free speech activism
⤷ Snyder v Phelps 2011 - right of protests at funerals
How is the SC liberal?
- Progressive on social issues
⤷ United States v Windsor 2013
⤷ Obergefell v Hodges 2015
⤷ Roe v Wade 1973 - Denied Trump’s request to delay his trial until after inauguration
What are the 5 stages of the appointment process?
- Vacancy arises
- Presidential nomination
- ABA rating
- Senate Judiciary Committee hearings
Senate floor vote
What factors are their in the nomination?
- Experience
⤷ e.g. Harriet Miers 2005 - withdrew as no experience as a judge or in constitutinal law (just a lawyer) + no record on abortion (repubs)
⤷ ABA ratings
⤷ Elena Kagan only one not to have worked for the Circuit Courts, but was Solicitor General to Obama (represents the whole federal government) - Demographics
⤷ attempts to diversify the court
⤷ e.g. Carter
⤷ e.g. Biden - Kentaji Jackson Brown
⤷ e.g. Reagan - first woman (Sandra Day O’Connor)
⤷ e.g. Obama - 2 woman and first hispanic (Sotomayor) - Ideology
⤷ usually aligned with president
⤷ quite known due to their career history
⤷ e.g. Kavanaugh - right wing think tank The Heritage Foundation (aim to build cons social policies)
⤷ e.g. Barrett - called the right to abortion ____
Is the appointment process more political?
Bush - nominated Miers as she would be “a good conservative judge” and was one of Bush’s closest friends
Is the appointment process more judicial?